Spydie Moran report

Joined
Dec 3, 2000
Messages
3,002
Just wanted to pass onto y'all a tale 'bout my fathers Christmas gift last year, which happened to be a Spyderco Moran.

Ya' see, my father has classically had a horrible time cleaning his game up at the cabin, always a kinda task. Last season he was down right annoyed with an Old Timer he'd been using, wound up doing the whole job with a Gerber his buddy had. Well, naturally I didn't like to hear of my old mans hard time, 'specially when I'm fully aware that the most dangerous knives out there are the dull ones, and he'd already gotten rushed back to town once for sticking a Leatherman blade in his Radial artery.

So, I went to the local knife shop and looked like hell for a new skinning knife for him, out of the thousands of blades there the Moran looked the best, so I picked it up for him.

He fell in love with the feel of it first thing when I gave it to him, and was very impressed by the hair splitting edge on it, although he was VERY skeptical that it would last very long at all. I myself was more optimistic, but we'd just have to wait and see.

Well, he just used it on his first caribou this year, and he was totally blown away by the performance of it. He's called me three times from a radio phone to tell me how terrific it is, and he's still raving about it.

The first time he called he told me what a fantastic job it had done. Said it'd probably need sharpening a little later, but it did awesome. It wasn't 'till after he hung up the phone that he discovered that the edge would still take the hair off his forearm!! on his second call he went on about how the knife just went through the meat like it was silk, and how it's so incredibly easier to use this knife. As an understatement the man stands mightily impressed.

So, anyhoo, I just wanted to report that knife has made my father one hell of a happy man, and that takes quite a bit when it comes to hunting equipment.
 
Good report. And good on ya' for getting the old man a blade worth raving about. As you can see from the picture under my username, I'm sort of fond of the Moran myself. That VG-10 is good stuff.
 
Runs With Scissors,

Your father should be very proud of his son (you), who thought enough of him to buy him a GREAT knife!...Perhaps your next gift to your father should be a Spyderco Sharpmaker 204, to keep that Moran razor-sharp with...:).
 
Thanks for the kind words!

Funny you should mention that...

Coincidentally that's his only complaint is that he wants a better sharpener than the carbide steel pocket thing he's been using to maintain the knife.

Although he also just lost his pocketknife, an' since he's so fond of the VG-10 I'm thinkin' 'bout gettin' 'im one of the new Delicas as well. Some day if I keep workin' at it maybe he'll be able to relate to my love of knives a bit more...:D
 
Hi Runs with Scissors. Thanx much for the confidence and the story. It does help to hear about ELUs pleased with the results of our efforts.

While the subject is here, the new Impala (scheduled to ship next week) is also VG-10 and one model has a very effective guthook.

Next is a question. Do you think that there would be any interest in a Moran with a gut hook?

sal
 
I think that a Moran with a guthook would be incredible...
it would easily be the best skinning knife on the market
 
Without a doubt, Spyderco's are my favorite knives, and the Moran 'drop point' is my favorite 'small' fixed blade...it's damn near perfect as a skinner or defensive tool...

That said, don't even think about putting a non-useful 'gadget' like a gut hook :barf: on a Moran inspired caping knife...are you guys freaking dense, or are your boxers just bunched up? Either way, knock it off!

And, don't use a 204 on the FB...use a soft strop or similar...Moran wasn't famous for his designs, Moran was famous for his edge.

'Roll' the edge, Appleseed it if you will...ala Marbles and Blackjack, but whatever you do, don't even try to 'vee' grind it!

Mel

-edited to remove nasty comments-
 
hmmmm...a Moran with a guthook, eh?

I actually read that much earlier in the weekend and I've had some time to seriously ponder the question, and to be honest, I've gotta give a definite "no" vote on this one.

The moran is lightweight, well balanced, and well designed enough that I just don't think it would benefit from a guthook at all. If a person can't use that knife in it's current form without a problem, then I don't think they would be likely to benefit from a guthook either.

I talked to my father yet again regarding his Moran and got his opinion. After he ranted, raved, and went on about how he's gonna sell off all the rest of his hunting knives now, that's the only one he'll ever need again,he took care of that entire caribou from beginning to end with that one knife, etc. his sentiments were pretty much the same as mine. He honestly feels that you've got fixed blade perfection in the Moran, and should NOT mess with perfection.

Well...to be honest a more exact quote was "hell no! treat it like a sore d#%*! and don't !*%k with it!" but I thought I'd paraphrase a little bit...

:D

Also, for what it's worth he's been showing that knife to every darn person he can out there, and they've pretty much given the same underlying sentiment as I've already stated. I guess you'd have to go to that area to appreciate it, but the area I'm referring to is a bush community that's a pretty good ways out, even by Alaska standards. His friends out there are composed of full time residents AKA subsistence hunters, bush pilots, guides, etc. Even though most of them don't eat, breathe, live, and practically worship knives like alot of us do, they know what works and what doesn't, and that Moran has definitely gotten a very high rating in his peers eyes exactly as it stands. Actually my father told me that when he gets back in town he may be asking me to aquire a few more for some of his buddies.

So, anyhoo, that's my rambling perception.

Even though I'm not real fond of the idea of a Moran with a guthook, it's nice to see your always looking for new ideas and willing to talk with us forumites and knife nut types about it.

Thanks!
 
For sharpening your Moran, try an old mousepad as a base. It is firm enough when you set it down on a table top and will have just enough give to allow for the contoure or the edge. Place a sheet of 600 or higher (dependant upon what kind of edge you want)sandpaper down on top of it. Strope away from the cutting edge just opposite of how you would sharpen a V ground knife. Once you have your edge where you want it, use the back of a legal pad to remove the wire edge.
This should leave you with a wicked sharp blade.
Hope this helps.
Doc
BTW- The Moran DP is, so far, my favorit get down to the cuttin' knife.
 
Absolutely no gut hook on the Moran Drop Point. Gut hooks are of limitedu...get gunked up with fur, blood, fat and other crap. It is much more effective to zip the belly from the inside out with a drop point knife.
 
Sal,

I've never found guts hooks to be of much use. Sure they work, but I find them uneccessary when armed with a good drop point blade design.

As well, I agree with the others that the Moran is of a design that should not be messed with. It is perfect exactly the way it is.

Thanks for listening and for asking our opinions how you do.

Jeff/1911.
 
Just wanted to give an update...

The ole man is up to four caribou and a moose, still hasn't resharpened his Moran. It's gotta be butterknife dull by now but he still keeps using the thing. (no, he hasn't shot them all himself, everyone up there has a way of helping each other)

last week he was back in town for a day or two and my mother suggested to him that he leave it at home so I could resharpen it for him. "perhaps you could use one of your old knives for a week or so while he resharpens it for you" He simply jammed it into his pack and looked at her as though she'd gone mad- spoke not a word.

In case you're wondering why he hasn't resharpened it himself- He still hasn't assimilated what this "Moran Edge" thing is about and he's PARANOID of messing up his knife, so of course he's gonna get it so dull that it won't cut warm butter and hand it to me to fix... :rolleyes: Not that he's unintelligent at all, he just doesn't speak "knife-ese" very well at all, and there's obviously going to be some communication issues when explaining these things overa crackling radio phone.

Anyhoo, just thought a couple of y'all might be interested.
 
Yup...Ya GOTTA get your dad a Spyderco Sharpmaker before it's too late!.:).
 
Back
Top