Steeling?

kamagong

Gold Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2001
Messages
10,928
Is steeling primarily meant for knives that cut soft materials (e.g., butcher knives)? The reason I ask is that I know that steeling aligns an edge. But wouldn't that realigned edge be weaker than one that is freshly sharpened, or even one that is freshly stropped? Wouldn't that realigned edge have a greater tendency to fold over again during use?
 
I think that you are referring primarily to a bur, or to a wire edge. This is not necessarily the case. An edge will have tiny microscopic serrations. With use, these tiny serrations bend. They will bend in both dirrections, making it feel as though there is a bur on both sides. the steel only realigns these teeth so that they /\ as they should. The result is a sharper, stronger edge.
-KC
 
It also depends on the steel and heat treat. Of course the steeled edge will not be as strong as a freshly sharpened one with the bur removed. On some steels however this is more or less a moot point unless the blade has been repeatedly damaged and steeled back many times. The basic goal of steeling though is to maintain a usable edge without actually removing metal, which is often not necessary if the damage is small enough and the steel isn't weakened.

The sort of damage that steels (of the sort talked about here, smooth steels are preferred to grooved ones, as grooved steels are basically files) can fix are rolls and dents, IE: deformations caused by contacts with hard objects/ twisting in wood, etc. If you tag a small rock, or after chopping some hardwood your edge has some rolled spots you can usually push them back with a bit of work on a steel, as opposed to grinding away the damage. Chips have to be sharpened out. It is always a good idea though to recut the edge with a good sharpener from time to time , so that fresh unfatigued/unrusted steel is what you do all your cutting with.
 
I use steel as a quick refresher sharpening or something like that. I'll spend a good amount of time getting something really sharp. Then once a week or so, I'll hit it with steel to keep it sharp.
 
After I get a razor edge, I give the blade a couple strokes on each side with my Gerber flat steel and that seems to make a difference in the sharpness.
 
Back
Top