Straight edge vs 50/50

[ejt]

What do you think about the usefulness of the serrations on a 50/50 type edge?

I do have a serrated blade that's occasionally useful for some things, but I prefer a smooth edge for most general use. I would be concerned the serrations would actually get in the way when using the straight portion (catch & tear when I want a smooth cut.) I'm wondering if anyone thinks the small amount of serrations on a 50/50 blade, starting way up at the handle, and ending half-way down the blade length, are really useful, or if that's just to make someone happy if they can't decide which they want, or can't afford 2 knives? ANyone's experience?

 

[Crayola]

The first good folder I bought was a combo AFCK. I wish I would have gottent the plain edge At least I learned a lot.

Yes, serrations are great for the really fibrous stuff, like plants and rope ans stuff. Unfortunately, I don't cut that kind of stuff a lot, and having 4" of plain edge would have served me MUCH better than having 2" of plain edge and 2" of serratiosn that only see occasional use. Since you have a serrated folder, get a plain edge folder and carry both.

For every day carry, I find a folder with a rougher edge (i.e. grey sharpmaker stones) does very well on fibrous material too, and most other chores.

 

[Lone Hunter]

Ok,I'll go first.Your going to get alot replies form guys who don't care for serrations,and 50/50 even less.I however take the other side,I like 50/50.Now I admit I buy mostly plain edge now,but I always carry at least one 50/50.

I carry on the job a 50/50 710 or CQC7,and up untill recently a Spyderco Rescue,'cause no matter what i may cut during the shift I know at the end of the day I can still at least "saw' though with the serrations.Also if I have to cut something that really calls for another tool,but all I got is a knife I feel I have a better shot with the serrations.

Some feel that with the 50/50 you don't have enough of either.I have not found that true for MY use.I have gutted deer,cut rags,done food prep.,cleaned fish,cut rope,cardboard,hose,belts,cut the clothes off a man who was hit in the head with a hatchet with my 50/50's,can't say I ever had a problem.(unlike the guy with the hatchet in his noggin)

Sure there not for all knife tasks,I would not choose one to scrape hide,but for 90% of my knife uses their fine.

Well I guess I'll go second.

 

[tater72]

I guess I'm about in the middle of the road. I like having the serrations in case the regular edge gets dull after much use and I need to saw through something (like Lone Hunter). It's come in handy quite a few times, which is why I keep carrying my CS Voyager (primary) and Spyderco Delica (back-up) everyday. Most of the time, the serrations are a little annoying, but it's nice to have the option.