strop question?

Joined
Nov 27, 2007
Messages
255
i have a question,on my strop ive been using a white buffing compound. i dont have green rouge yet.i ordered it though. will the green do beter than the white? it doesent seem to work as well as the posts ive read about the green. is it all that different or is my problem my sharpening technequie? also i tried making a strop with the warm leather and oil and compound, but the result was a sloppy mess that did not seem to work. do you think it could be the compound? or mabey i used too much oil. any ideas? thanks willy:):)
 
According to a chart that someone posted awhile back, white is more coarse than green. I have some white - one is the hard, crayola stick kind and the other some French stuff, almost creamy, that a fellow Forumite sent to me. I don;t use either. Not because they don;t work, just because the green suffices.

If I remember correctly, black is coarse, followed by white, then green, and red is the finest.....more or less anyway.

Clean off your strop getting as much oil out as possible. Use rags, blue shop towels, whatever you have. Heat the leather and the oil will come to the surface (or at least be more easy to wipe off). Once you're satisfied, reheat the leather and apply your rouge like you're scribbling with a crayon. Sometimes it will sort of sit on the surface in flakes...that's ok, you'll wipe that off later. Keep rubbing, getting the rouge worked in to any and all areas. When you're done, take a blue shop towel and wipe down the strop.....very light pressure. Some areas of your strop may have a thicker application than others, don;t worry about that. It will work fine for your purpose. Once you begin getting good at stropping and seeing the results (which will be nil unless you start with a nice, sharp, crisp edge), you can refine your rouge application - maybe going back to oil or something.
 
i have a question,on my strop ive been using a white buffing compound. i dont have green rouge yet.i ordered it though. will the green do beter than the white? it doesent seem to work as well as the posts ive read about the green. is it all that different or is my problem my sharpening technequie? also i tried making a strop with the warm leather and oil and compound, but the result was a sloppy mess that did not seem to work. do you think it could be the compound? or mabey i used too much oil. any ideas? thanks willy:):)

You need to learn what is this polish made from.

The Rouge (red in French) which here called Red Rouge (red red...) is Iron Oxide also known as rust. It may be good for gold and silver, but not for steel.

Green Rouge (sound like green red ???) is made of chromium oxide which is hard enough to work on steel.

I learned it on some jeweler website, and posted some time ago here - can not use search not to find that post - use google for this. I do not remember anything about White Rouge - it may differ from manufacturer to manufacturers. I also saw - Green Rouge as well as Green Polishing compound - both different thing, so really hard to tell.

Green Rouge works excellent for me.

Thanks, Vassili.
 
i got the white from home depot,its packaged by ryobi. its called white rouge buffing compound.(2.5 microns) says for shining to a high gloss finish hard metals,soft metals,nickel,chrome and plastics. also says crystalline silica free. is this too fine for use as a strop? it does verry well for putting a mirror polish on my blades.:)
 
It's not too fine, Willy.

I saw those little tubes of rouge and considered getting the "C" grade (I think it was - maybe it was "B"). Black or a dark grey, best I could tell. It was for aggressive polishing on steel. I'd like to get some of that to use for removing scratches and to augment my white, red, and green supply.
 
i got the white from home depot,its packaged by ryobi. its called white rouge buffing compound.(2.5 microns) says for shining to a high gloss finish hard metals,soft metals,nickel,chrome and plastics. also says crystalline silica free. is this too fine for use as a strop? it does verry well for putting a mirror polish on my blades.:)

I think it is not too fine, for polishing it is coarse. I am not sure if it will produce mirror polish - may be, but it it right on the border. Green Rouge I think finer.

Thanks, Vassili.
 
I switched to diamond paste/mineral oil mix (really diamond paste/Handamerican CrO2 gel which I heard is mineral oil based). 15 micron to 1 micron.
 
Back
Top