Swiss army knife or folding plier-type multi-tool?

Joined
Dec 19, 2006
Messages
8,210
Which do you use most often? For me it's usually both, since I always carry a Victorinox Rambler or Classic on my keychain and typically have a larger plier-type multi-tool in a pocket, belt sheath, or coat pocket. Other times, I'll have two Swiss army knives: the one on my keychain and a larger model, typically the Soldier or Farmer.
 
I usually carry a SAK with 2 or 3 layers. I prefer carrying them instead of my plier based multitools, because the SAK's are a smaller and lighter and I don't need pliers very often. Recently I have bought a Leatherman Juice S2, which is smaller than a 91 mm SAK, but it is a bit wider and heavier. It is a nice tool.
 
Most of the time I just carry a SAK or two, but a Leatherman sometimes features just to keep things interesting.
 
Leatherman Wave and Victorinox electrician.

Lately the Vic the one that sees more use: the little electrician blade is very useful for opening packages and envelopes and the main blade is reserved for food. I'd say that my SAK is reserved for the light and "clean" tasks (even though it can handle tough use with no problem) while the wave takes care of the actual hardware related jobs.

Regards.


Jaime Orozco.
 
I almost always carry a SAK (Usually a Compact, sometimes an Electrician or one with a saw) instead of a plier-based multitool. Better tool selections for my needs, and easier to carry. I'd rather carry a SAK and an actual set of pliers when I'm doing something where I'll likely need them.

That said, I do keep a Swisstool Spirit in my backpack just in case.
 
I'm a minimalist pliers-based kind of guy. The SAKs offer a lot of utility, and I can get along just fine with them. However, in my line of work, a nice set of needlenose pliers really comes in handy. I like my big chunky multi-tools, but a standard PST or Kick or Fuse riding along in my watch pocket can usually handle 90% of my needs. Heck, I haven't even thought about dropping another tool in my pocket since I started carrying the Sideclip I won a couple weeks ago. It does everything I need, and to be honest, if i ever decide to retire it or want more of a beater a Kick with a pocket clip will probably be the next tool i buy:thumbup:
 
Easily a SAK tinker, it rides in my back pocket beside my wallet every day, I only carry a multi tool with a plier, a skeletool, when I think I will need it later that day for work.
 
Although I have carried one or another multitool since age 12, for most of that time pocket knives held little interest for me as a subject, any more than sandpaper or hammers have for me today (no offense intended to the sander/banger communities.) Early on I recognized the value of having a pocketable set of tools on hand, and for this my first scout pattern Kamp King was just fine over 15 years.

My next was a Wenger SAK, which lasted a few years until falling apart. It was replaced with a Victorinox that had a bunch of tools more than my previous 4-bladers. I liked that a lot, opened worlds to me, but my continuing lack of interest in the fine points was such that I don't have a clear memory of all the implements or what the model was called.

I could tell, however, that Vic was the goods. When that knife was stolen, I went all the way with a Swisschamp, which I carried exclusively for years. During that time I felt no need for supplementary gear beyond a maglite solitaire. As far as I was concerned, I was set for life with the ultimate multitool. Then came a disturbance in the harmony.

During a 1996 weekend, I was in a rural environment with a recent acquaintance and his 8 year old son. We were improvising some fishing gear, and I noticed he kept producing a little stainless steel thing out of a leather belt pouch, pull out a knife blade to whittle or cut something, thumb out a file to smooth a handle etc. It was some sort of multiple use pocket tool, providing capabilities I already had with the Swisschamp. Then he opened a needlenose pliers to bend some thick wire. That got my attention. I had met my first Leatherman, a PST model.

ASAP, I got myself a one. After a trial period, I concluded that even though the real pliers were much more useful the dinky ones on the Vic, the PST didn't show me enough, so I went back to the Champ. But I was vulnerable to the next Leatherman that came along, a Super Tool. Locking blades, the heft, sharp cut screwdrivers, etc. made clear this was a working tool. The only thing missing was scissors, but then Leatherman introduced the Micra, a perfect complement. That closed the deal. For the next bunch of years, that pairing was my main EDC.

Collateral damage: doing research on multitools led me to this and other knifely forums, so everything changed. I now have several each of Leathermen (including a PST, which I revisited), also Victorinox, and spend altogether too much time doing stuff like this :o .

Then the pendulum swung back. Often when I carry a Leatherman, I miss the Champ. So I strap on the Vic until I miss the Leatherman (repeat.) This has been going on for years.

That's my story.
 
I always carry a SAK and a multi , the SAK gets most of the use . Kinda brings the whole multi concept up for review doesn't it ?

Chris
 
Alox Farmer for me. Weight, size, and simpicity is what I like about it. Plus it's a lot more ergonomic than my Wave.
 
Usually a SAK is what I carry. I prefer more of a spartan approach to EDC, and I appreciate the lighter weight of a SAK in comparison to a plier based tool.

I do keep a plier based tool in my car or sometimes a backpack, but I generally do not EDC them.
 
I have the S2 juice and a Wave, but I carry my SAKs much more often.

in order of carry frequency: Tinker, Pioneer, S2 juice, and Waiter. The Wave only comes along for special occasions -it generaly stays in my back pack in the car.
 
leatherman wave around home but in woods I tend to carry a SAK of some sort...I just feel that pliers aren't needed as often so I can either pack it or just substitute.
 
From my own experience, a SAK (champ) seems to work better when in the woods, and a multitool (wave) for urban environments. It's probably the difference between working with primarily natural materials vs. manmade, or mechanical. I have tried to belt carry both, and it is just too much for me, as I always carry a 6v surefire flash on my belt. I found thru reading that some of the top outdoorsmen do carry both. I usually belt carry one, and carry the other in my pack. Ah! The constant search for perfection. Now, as to needle-nose or blunt nose pliers on my MT.
 
My 111mm Hunter is my EDC. While I do carry a Multi when working Rescue it is still my SAK that I go to. Unlike many others I do not find a 3 layer 111mm like the OHT, Ruck, Hunter etc. to big for pocket carry. I carry it along side my creds support side rear pocket.
 
Back
Top