Sword Question

sevenedges

BANNED
Joined
Sep 14, 1999
Messages
992
I am looking for the highest possible quality swords. Mainly interested in japanese katanas. Who should I be looking at other than Bugei. And how does Bugei stand in terms of quality?
Thanks.
 
If you really want the highest quality Katana, be prepared to shell out several thousand dollars.

There are many people far more knowledgeable than I on this topic, but Bugei's higher-end stuff is very nice.

The Howard L6 is kinda the holy grail of modern production Katanas. It's around $5-6K and is probably the one I'd get when I have the cash.

Either that, or I'd want to get one direct from Japan. Do they still have those laws barring people from exporting kats?
 
I've been eyeing the Howard L6 for a while. It is the best sword I have been able to locate so far. I would just hate waiting for one to be made. 16-18 months. I'm not sure about the jap katana export laws.
 
L605 is a Wonderfull Material. Combines hardness and toughness as no other on earth. We make critical use parts for nuclear reactors and other extreme uses out of L6. It is pretty hard to machine, will chew up cutting tools like crazy, but when your finished... its all worth it. For a blade, i cannot think of any Material that comes close to the performance L6 offers, period.
 
Bugei does not make katanas. They carry Hanwei (Paul Chen) products. The good thing about Bugei is that they personally inspect every and each sword. The inspectors are those who know what they are doing.

My opinion about the best katana is Howard Clark L6 bainite. Bar none.

For aesthetic purposes, there are no such things as the 'best' katana unless you are prepared to spend $20,000+
 
sevenedges;

Another thing to keep in mind when asking "what's the best" of people is, what is your intended purpose?

Are you actually going to be practicing a sword art, entailing live cutting, or do you just want to own a work of art?

From what I've read (and I've done a fair amount of reading on the topic) the L6 is the pinnacle of toughness, performance, and traditional beauty.

You really gonna get one? I'm soooooo jealous.... :)
 
Thanks guys, It looks like Howard Clark is the way to go. My main purpose for the sword would be to both admire it and use it cutting mats once in a while. At 6-7 K It will probably be a while before I feel like I can afford it. Kevtan, you can see pictures of the L6 at www.bugei.com under custom katanas. I'm not sure if he has a website, I'll have to check that out.
 
Howard Clark's website is http://www.mvforge.com or you may omit the www part.

He does not sell L6 blades himself anymore, they must be purchased either through Bugei or on the secondary market (not very common to find these on the secondary market).

I think his L6 swords are great, and they are excellent performers. However, from what I have seen of his work in the last few years, I think his 1086M blades are equally as good. I think people over-emphasize and hype the abusability of Howard's L6 stuff, when in reality his top-end 1086M stuff is not as far behind as people tend to imagine, and what it sacrifices in flexibility, it gains in abrasion resistence and edge retention.

Of course, it's up to the buyer. If the buyer prefers a slightly lighter blade or a more flexible blade, the L6 would be a good option. If aesthetics and edge retention are important, the 1086M may be up your alley. It is also a less expensive option last I remember.

Really depends on what you want. They are both awesome blades and I think I would snag up either one if the chance lended itself to me. Would almost need at least one of each, to reflect mindset and style at the time. They are some of the top performing blades of their style in the world, and are an excellent value compared to modern made Japanese swords.
 
Back
Top