SYKW Dog Father or Fehrman Final Judgement

Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Messages
402
I am going to be in the market for a 9" to 10" chopper (bowie) style blade, and everything that I have read has pretty much stated that you cannot go wrong with either design/manufacturer. I would like to know what you folks think?...SR 77 or CPM3V pros...cons??

For hard use which will be the more solid design?

Thanks:thumbup:
 
I can say that the Dog Father is a real beast of a chopper.
It has plenty of forward weight and the handle is easy on the hand.
It keeps the edge very well.
It's my main chopper now and no disappointment with it at all.
There isn't anything pretty about it, just pure user. :thumbup: :thumbup:

I have no experience with the other knife.
 
the fit and finish on fehrman knives is the best on any knife you are likely to try. they are flawless!
 
I have owned both and IMO it would come down to which feels best in your hand. Both are great blades and will serve you well. For me either one fits my paw so I would have a hard time choosing. I would have to say if I was going with only one, I'd go Fehrman based on the fact that it is a custom blade and would offer that aura to the owner :)
 
I have owned both and IMO it would come down to which feels best in your hand. Both are great blades and will serve you well. For me either one fits my paw so I would have a hard time choosing. I would have to say if I was going with only one, I'd go Fehrman based on the fact that it is a custom blade and would offer that aura to the owner :)

For the price of the Final Judgement your could probably get a custom made by our good friend Bill here. I've heard nothing but great things about his work and intend to eventually scrape enough cash to get one of my own.

That said I would go for a DF. The price vs. performance ratio is outstanding as in you get performance similar to a FBM for about 1/4 the price.
 
I don't have the Final Judgement but I have the First Strike, Last Chance, Thru Hiker, and the Peace Keeper. All are outstanding workmanship and the CPM3V steel is DAMN TOUGH stuff. The people there at Fehrman Tool & Die are also great people to talk to and they will do their best to make you a happy customer.

So, as to your question....FEHRMAN ALL THE WAY!

Ciao
Ron
:thumbup: :thumbup:
 
it probably comes down to whether you like a resiprene handle or not. I doubt you could damage either one as long as you weren't chopping rocks. The Fehrman probably has better edge-holding.
 
Thanks for the replies, although I still feel torn between the two. I may have to eventually get both, but may start out with the Dog Father.
 
That's the ticket. When you can't decide, buy both. Unfortunately my credit card has suffered badly due to this philosophy. Good Luck! :D
 
When I look at my Final Judgement, I think of it more as a piece of art. The lines, fit and finish are really smooth. Most of the folks who have seen the Fehrman blades will agree with me: they are beautiful. The knife I actually use is a Peace Maker, and frankly, I could very easily use this knife for the rest of my days and never need another. The knife addiction will no doubt nullify this scenario. I never was the kind of guy who could just waltz into Wally World and get a 110 and never look back, although such an action is probably the most frugal and pragmatic way to go about dealing with the ever present EDC question. This solution is terribly 'vanilla' and boring.

My DF has seen extensive use and works well as a medium sized chopper and camp knife. It is similar in performance to my Basic 9, sharpens well, and is probably as bullet-proof as a knife can be. For the hard earned cash, the DF is the benchmark. Some days I wonder if there is any real difference between INFI and the wonder-steel that scrapyard employs. The variance in performance is woefully slim in my estimation. I can hear my credit card clapping somewhere in the back of my mind. Are there any readers here that have stacked up the credit card bills as a result of knife purchases, and now you are forced to gather your spare change to pay the minimum?

When I need real power and speed, the re-profiled 18 inch Ontario comes out and performs sheer magic. Never fails to bring on the smile. Hossom has a lot of experience in this area, and pushes the idea of using a properly honed machete in concert with a SAK for survival purposes. I wonder how he kicked the knife addiction and what he did with all his extra money that he saved by not ordering more Busse products.

Anyway, to answer your original question, I'd order the DF and use the rest of the dough for some pizza and imported brew. Then, I'd log on to bladeforums again.
 
Back
Top