Temperance review

Joined
Oct 12, 1998
Messages
1,569
It turned out a bit long, but I hope you’ll like it anyway.

Li’l Temperance, Leaf Blade, Plain Edge

Since the beginning I was thrilled with Spyderco’s MBC line, because I knew it would be responsible, complete en technically perfect. However, until recently most models were rather overtly self defense weapons (Gunting & Chinook). This might not be a problem for most Americans or people in other cultures, whose laws are more liberal in carrying weapons. In my country (the Netherlands), it is forbidden to carry a weapon, period. The courts interpretation of the weapon carry, would be that ‘you were just looking for trouble’. So that leaves me with only carrying tools, like my Surefire D2, Mini Maglite AAA, and a trusty pocket knife. The Temperance is perfect for my purposes. It is strong and sharp enough for any kind of emergency and I can honestly explain it as a modern technologically advanced pocket knife.

I got this knife from Toolshop (www.toolshop.de), but don’t count on him having any huge stockpiles of Temperances laying around. I think I just got lucky in receiving the Temperance so fast as I did. Apart from trying to make everybody green with envy, the following is mostly intended to share some impressions and review of this knife, I did not conduct any hardcore cutting and breaking tests. Perhaps when the trainer comes out.

The blade

Well y’all know what it’s made of, so I won’t bother you with that. The full flat grind is ingeniously ‘hidden’. There are no visible grind lines on the blade when open, I first thought that the pictures were all of prototypes or something. The full stock thickness of the blade only starts under the handle scale, when opened. This leaves the user with the maximum amount of cutting edge in a 3 inch package, so to speak. The flat grind exudes both strength and sharpness. The blade is very thick, but I’m used to my Native and Delicas in this size folder. Unlike the Military the tip on the Temperance doesn’t seem to be fragile or anything. The overall blade design is very reminiscent of my Military, but the Temperance features a more upswept shape and perhaps a stronger tip. Note, I did not put my Temperance in a vise and started my version of an ABS test, these are my personal subjective impressions from handling the knife. The XL opening hole is a dream and the Temperance is very very fast on the draw, no doubt the placement and size of the opening hole has something to do with that.

The blade’s design, with what I would call a “hidden full flat grind”, contributes to its ‘calm’ and unassuming appearance. My Native’s blade design with its many grind lines, would appear much more ‘aggressive’ to a knon knife person. The Temperance’s blade not only looks much more peaceful because of its length, but also because of its lack of lines or design on the blade itself. I hope you can understand what I mean, English is not my native language. So far, I’ve only used my Temperance in the kitchen, and it slices fruit and vegetables with the best, like my Military.


The Handle

Feels like putty, truly feels like it was custom designed for me. I started knife collecting in the late 80s early 90s. Back then my Al Mar fixed blades stood out from the SOGs and Cold Steels because of their handles. The Al Mar fixed blades all had big hand filling handles, really something you felt you could get a good solid grip on. The handle of the Temperance is like that. Compared to a Delica or Native it feels much bigger, but not too big. After handling the Temperance I feel that a Native could ‘disappear’ in my hand, but the Temperance becomes a part of it. The Temperance fills the hand without being too big that you would worry about holding it securely. The G10 scales are nice and thick, and feature double nested liners. No flexing handle for the Temperance!!

The grip on a Temperance is totally pinch free for me. The clip is flat and does not pinch the hand at all with a tight grip. The indexing holes are a welcome addition, but I still have to gain more confidence with this knife to spin it around wildly, which is no part of my MBC skills and training anyway. The handle also appears secure on both top and bottom side. When holding the Temperance in a standard forward grip, there are protuberances before both your thumb and forefinger. The thumb, when resting on the knife’s spine can be used for indexing the blade without it being stuck there in a thrust, like could be the case with the hump of a Delica for example. The Temperance’s upper guard fits flush with the blade’s tiny hump. This means that there is a lot of room for your thumb. Perhaps this feature was meant to test the convenience of the cobra hood? The knife’s butt tends to rest in the palm of your hand. What all this means is the following: When thrusting the knife in a hard object (e.g. watch or belt buckle), it seems that the knife can rest on a small ‘guard’ in front of your index finger and the knife’s butt is supported with the palm of your hand. The thumb is free to move forward in such a hard contact without compromising your grip or thumb. Mind you, this is a subjective impression, I do not have the heart to jam my brand new Temperance into a brick wall, but I would do it if you promised me a new knife afterwards. I am not afraid that I would lose a finger or two in the process.

The color is a nice dark green, which is slightly ‘duller’ on the deeper polished parts of the handle (the area that holds the three indexing holes). The rough and higher parts of the handle feature a nice rough texture, perhaps an even rougher texture than on my Wegner. I like that.


Operation

The Temperance is smooth. The opening action feels as smooth as a linerlock. The whole design and operation make the Temperance the fastest tip up spydie I have handled. This is my first experience with a compression lock and I could adapt to it fast enough. Within minutes I could open and close the Temperance one-handed. Reverse grip opening also feel very secure, hardly surprising if you consider that this knife just has a lot of handle to hang onto. And if that isn’t enough you can hang onto the clip with its 3 indexing holes. These holes are roughly chamfered, like every Spydie hole, so your finger does not move out of there if you don’t want it to. The compression locking lever’s serrations do not interfere with my grip, i.e. no chafing in a tight grip or grip change. Until now, the detent on the compression lock was very tight, the blade hasn’t come out yet when I didn’t want it to. Inertia opening is not very easy with a brand new Temperance, unlike with my Military which also has more blade to swing out.

Druthers??

One of the first things I did with my Temperance is to change the clip from tip down to tip up. This leaves the pivot washer and area exposed through no less than 4 screw holes. Perhaps I can get my Tuff Glide in there more precisely now, but could it also attract unwanted dirt in this area? I don’t know, and long term carry will have to determine if these 4 little holes are big enough to attract lint and dirt in this seemingly critical area of the folder. Also the blade had some tiny side to side play out of the box. This was largely remedied with a twist of my torx key in the pivot pin.

Overall Impressions

The Temperance is a very unique and unusual knife, it feels totally different in the hand than any of my other Spydies (Military, Wegner, Native, Delica). Like the Native, the Temperance has a mega grip, totally secure, but even more evolved and refined. The look of this knife is very custom like, it sure stands out from anything the shops may have in the window in terms of factory pieces. The knife looks big to the uninitiated, but when you let them hold it in their hand and let them measure the blade, they agreed that it wasn’t too big or aggressive looking. That is what I like most about this knife, its looks and name are not overtly weapon, but for the knowledgeable the Temperance handles like one. Which is perfect for people who live in jurisdictions that frown upon carrying weapons for self defense. What I would want improved in this knife? A plug for the exposed clip holes, like Chris Reeve offers for the Sebenza, and a Trainer. I am curious to put this knife to the max, so a Trainer would help. The Temperance (Leaf blade, plain) is now part of my EDC, replacing my Native as a three inch bladed right hand tactical folder. If a Spyderco Custom Shop would ever be realized, I would ask for different colors and a left handed version to match. Perhaps food for thought for a new forum knife? Different color G10 and/or a bug inlay? ;)

Cheers,

Wouter
 
Thank you for your superb review. Now I want one!

BTW, your English is also quite good as well, and I had no trouble following what you were saying.
 
Hehe, nice review, I was thinking about getting a upswept Temperance myself... You kinda remind me of Sergiuz Mitzin, great reviews, great English, foreign guy...
 
Mr Blonde, very nice write-up. I just got the warry version of the Temperance, called the Chinook, and while certainly a rather impressive piece of folding cutlery (big, scary sharp, very agressive design, nasty back cut on it) it is laughable that it came with a clip instead of a sling-carry system.

I see the Temperance as a nicer version, the same aggresive blade with a civvie friendly green handle and a cool designo clip, it almost looks non-weapon-like. I will get mine with the bowie/ swept point, but I have to say you are right on target with your focus on handle size, big hole, all those features which make it a ood USING knife instead of one I will sell at a loss or trade in three months.

Great job, MB. Now tell ya what, can we trade you some of our martial permissiveness for the improved educational system or maybe some of those good bars and beer?

By the way, www.toolshop.de is a fine looking place to do biz. Were I part of the EEC I wold shop there in a heartbeat. Only issue they got wrong is the Al AMr SERE 3003 being used in Vietnam war. Great selection of everything, including a Puma Al Mar copy for half price.

Parker
 
Nice writing, Wouter, thanks!

Only one thing I disagree certainly - about tip-up carry. The Compression Lock does not hold blade closed position enough firmly to make this carry mode safe.
 
Thanks for the kind comments everyone. I can add that the indexing holes in the Temperance's handle work really great. With a little practice I can change from forward to reverse grip very fast and very securely. Grip - place fingertips in indexing holes - spin - proper grip, no further adjusting is necessary!

Sergiusz, I was kind of weary about that too, at first. Especially, after reading about incidents with people's Guntings opening in their pockets. Granted, it is a tip down knife with a horn that is desigend to open with pressure. I haven't encountered any accidental openings with my leaf blade Temperance yet. After initial handling I decided that the compression lock, uses similar technology to the linerlock to hold the knife closed, i.e. ball detent. I found that it took the proper amount of force to open the knife one handed, so I converted the clip to my favorite carry mode for 3 inch bladed folders, tip-up. So far, no accidents or almost accidents have happened, the knife has always remained close untill I wanted it. My carry mode for this knife is IWB "appendix" carry. That, and the perhaps lower profile of the leaf shape blade may be the main reasons for it staying closed. Did you have a problem with accidental openings with a Temperance, or a different compression lock Spyderco, I am curious? Thanks,

Wouter
 
Wouter,
I don't have too much experience with Temperance because I do not have one yet. But I have played with prototype at last year IWA and basically my impressions match yours.

As to closed position retention. Yes, Gunting have opened in my pocket and made nice hole, fortunately just in pocket but not in leg. Usually I carry my knives in the right rear pocket, but the Gunting displayed self-opening exactly at the moment I have put it into pocket. The horn obstructed with pocket upper edge and caused slight self-opening. So I moved it to right front pocket (jeans style). Now it stayed closely OK, I probably caused opening unintentionally catching the horn with my hand or clothing...
Nothing serious, just small hole in the pocket outside but the topic to think about.

I have also Vesuvius but I have set it up for tip-down carry at the very first moment when I got it into my hands. No problems with lock in this position, but I certainly would like firmer closed position retention for tip-up carry.

No one knife is ideal. Just to know it's strong and week sides and to take them into consideration - this is the recipe for safety and comfort, in my opinion.
 
I think -- and somebody else can check this -- but the Guntings do not have a detent in the lock. That, combined with the horn, makes accidental opening pretty easy. New Compression Lock knives may have a detent, as I think Mr. Glesser mentioned something about the "next generation" Compression Locks holding the blade closed better.
 
Back
Top