tglb test

boring

Gold Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2005
Messages
2,713
comp finish model. one night, drinking beers by the camp fire, i hacked at a piece or two and thought, looking good. Finally got some daylight and put it against a becker 9 and an ontario 18" chete. Of course the chete smoked em all on the soft wood. I was surprised that the bk9 chopped better than the tglb. is it because the tglb is thicker? Convex edge? I really thought the tglb would have done better than it did. The tglb only cut a couple branches. the bk 9 went though a chopping/slashing test between a becker 2, machax, esse 6 and a cg fbm. thoughts?
 
My TGLB is a very much superior to my Tops Firestrike 45. Hard to imagine the BK9 beating out the TGLB.

I have a few pics posted in some of my more recent activity. I waiting for my next camping trip to really work it.
 
The BK9 is also longer than the TGLB, so that would add more momentum to each swing.
 
should i expect a big difference between a basic 10 and a bk9?
 
I guess I thought the weight might make up for an inch of length.
 
You aren't quite comparing apples to apples.

The BK9 is also longer than the TGLB, so that would add more momentum to each swing.

This. 1.5" longer

should i expect a big difference between a basic 10 and a bk9?

The Basic 10 will kill the BK9 but the comparison isn't apples to apples.

thanks for the responses. I guess I am still in shock.

Why shocked? Should a Busse outperform a larger knife?
 
As was already stated, you are comparing apples to oranges. Yes INFI is a better steel but that doesn't mean every blade Busse makes will out chop others. Should an AMS out chop a Junglas? The TGLB is a combat knife. The BK9 is more of a chopper. You want to out chop a BK9? Get an ASHBM. Plus it's not all about out chopping. It's also about the steel. If you have 2 identical blade designs but one is INFI and the other is 5160, what do you prefer and why?
 
1504055_641819515873995_3108121701898174832_n.jpg


Took 5-6 swings

10153144_641819535873993_1211884460918836393_n.jpg


That's 1,

10154039_641819572540656_5824657684907676884_n.jpg


and 2.
 
Blade geometry will play a role , also I'm willing to bet the Tglb's blade won't damage as easy as the bk9
 
Chopping is all about momentum meeting resistance, which is just geometry and physics. A longer blade develops more rotational momentum than a shorter blade. Handle offset (cant) introduces leverage angle as a mechanical advantage, with dropped handles enhancing momentum over straighter handles, which is how the Machax performs. A thinner edge/thinner blade cuts with less resistance, because it's having to cut through and spread less material to penetrate to equal depth as a thicker edge/blade. When you say your machete smoked the others, that's its design. Thin, flat steel with much greater blade length for momentum and penetration. However, the machete won't stand up to abuse because it has no lateral strength, and it's so thin that it will tend to bind in thicker wood because its thin blade penetrates deeply without spreading the wood enough to overcome the resulting friction the sides of the cut exert on the blade flats, once it comes to rest in the wood. So on skinny branches and weeds, none of the others can keep up with the machete, although you could buy several machetes for what any of those other knives will cost. The TGLB isn't designed as a dedicated chopper, because its role as a combat knife requires speed and balance that isn't a priority for a dedicated chopper. Doesn't mean you can't chop with it; just means that if you want a dedicated chopper you should probably look for a different Busse design. For example, a Basic 9 is in the same blade length range as your Becker, and is probably even lighter overall, but I guarantee you the Becker will not stand up to a Basic 9 as a chopper, because the weight-forward design of the reduced-tang Basics and the asymmetrical edge of the Basic 9, which enhances penetration in wood, will eat the Becker's lunch.
 
Using a lanyard, try choking back on the tglb so you have thumb and 2 or3 fingers on the rear swell. Results may be different.:)
 
thanks for the comments.

When i tested them, I choked back on both, the tglb and bk9.
 
The TGLB is no Double Bit Axe , but for the size and weight it seems to be very choppy.

When chopping into the pressure treated 4x4 I was using a full grip, probably would have ate through the entire 4x4 with a modified grip.

The Edge Geometry is fantastic on the TGLB, comparing it to the Tops Firestrike 45 there is no competition as seen in the photos.

However the Firestrike 45 did fare better in the batoning (only marginally) due to it's geometry, piercing is where it really excelled. The tip is very stabby, Tops calls this the Bayonette point and it seems for good reason.

I still haven't had to sharpen my TGLB yet, this is quite a nice surprise for me.
 
Great user pics bro! Good for you for using your tools!


Good to know one of them is a Busse too.....at least you have it after the others fail you.:p
 
Back
Top