The dwindling blades.

Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Messages
17,617
When I was a kid, my dad gave me a scout knife.

The occasion was I had joined the local boy scout troop that met in the old church in Wheaton. So dad, being the wise man he was, gave me a scout knife. It was great. It had four blades, a nice wide spear blade, the cap lifter, can opener, and the awl. Four really useful blades and tools. Of course it became my treasured item. A precious. That scout knife served me well for many years, and I didn't feel the need to get another knife. Only when I went off to the army, did I leave it at home, fearing it would disappear in an army barracks.

Serving in the army, I still kept to the four blade design out of habit. The army had all those MLK knives, the ones the civilians call the demo knife for some reason. They had loads of them in the supply room, and if one broke, which they did on occasion, you just got another one. Somewhere along in my army service, I stumbled on Swiss Army knives. Even more blades and tools, so I bought one. I guess I must have lived the first half of my life with a scout or Swiss army knife in a pocket, and to be honest, they did come in handy on occasion. A loose screw here, a beer bottle there. Okay, lots of beer bottles.

Time went on, and somehow, I never quite figured out how, I got a stockman. Okay, I think I know, but it's the army's fault. They gave us a P-38, and I got to know how useful one tiny item could be. It not only opened cans, but it could be used as a screw driver, scraper, awl, and more. As for bottles, there's many ways to open a bottle without a dedicated bottle opener. I remembered my dad having one in his wallet, and using it as much as the Sear's keychain screw driver. That may have started my weaning of knives with tools. So there I was a the PX, and looking at the Buck knife display, and being drawn to the 301 stockman. For the next chunk of my life, I was a three blade pocket knife man. Clip, sheepsfoot, spey, a blade for all uses. If I needed a screw driver or can opener, I had one in my wallet, like dad did.

Of course, there was dad, still going on about his life with his little two blade peanut. Just two little blades, and it seemed ill equipped to me to be going on in the world with just two blades. But life is for learning. And in 1982, I was in a backpacking store, and they had a jar full of weird looking wood handle knives up near the register. Opinel. What the heck is this, a knife with no springs, not even a second blade? But it was so light, I bought one and used it now and then. But it never got to be a regular carry for a lot of years, as I wasn't done with my evolution. I still had to have more than a single blade on my pocket knife.

The peanut came to use after my dad passed away. I'm not sure why, but I downsized my pocket knife as I got older, and maybe I figured if dad could do it, so could I. I put a Sear's keychain screw driver and a P-38 in my wallet like dad did, and I got by just fine. The Opinel got carried now and then, but never by itself. I was a little leery of it still, having only one single blade in a light weight package, it just seemed soooo delicate. My mistake. Only later did I learn how sturdy the Opinel was.

Only of late, with my new fascination of old school European friction folders, did a really learn to love the single blade knife. These days I find myself in possession of a Turkish, Sardinian, and French folders that are friction folders with a single blade. I carry them as my edc pocket knives, and the world has not stopped turning, the sun still rises in the east, and I've cut whatever I've needed in my day to day life of a retired gentlemen of leisure. THis means I actually need and use a pocket knife more now than when I was working. There's fishing, picnicking with a Texas gal that has been with me for more years than I want to contemplate. There's hot dog sticks to whittle for the grandkids, and house stuff I never had time for when working, like the garden out back.

It's only taken most of a lifetime, but now I seem to get along very well with a single blade. Maybe old dogs can learn new tricks. :D

But I think it was Fausto's Resolza that was the tipping point. I never had a knife feel so nice in the hand as the Sardinian knife. The horn handle sculpted so well that it nestles into the hand with no other blade to upset the exquisite design and feel. Now I'm spoiled.

Carl.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for posting, I enjoyed reading about your journey. I myself am a single blade man, but I am only 30 years old and my opinion changes if the wind blows..... Of course I carry a vic classic on my key chain everywhere I go....
 
Back in the days when I was seriously supplementing my meager income with furs, I had a practical reason for carrying a multi-bladed knife.

I sometimes had more varmints to skin than one blade would stay sharp for.

I used to carry two and sometimes three knives to the woods so I could keep on skinning without running out of a sharp blade.
 
As I started out about the same as Carl, I began with a Cub Scout knife. My direction went the opposite way. I then started carrying the small peanut sized single blade Schrade. Then in the 90’s I got mixed up in the one hand single blade knives. Before the 90’s were over I was carrying a Stockman. And now my most carried knife has to be my SAK cadet. I use it for just about everything. Pretty interesting how we end up carrying what we carry. I think it does depend on what your doing and use a knife for as time moves on.
 
A very enjoyable read, as always Carl :)
 
Thanks for the thread, Carl.

It´s great to see a real knife-knuts personal history when it comes to knives :)
 
Great read Carl, I've sure been enjoying your stories, having just discovered them about a week ago and been devouring them with great delight. :)

I'll be 50 yrs old in a couple of months. But I personally never did care for multiple blades on a pocket knife. Most of the ones I've owned and carried in my life were single blade or perhaps 2-bladed. The more blades the "fatter" the knife becomes and I don't like a bulky pocket knife, I like them slim so they don't irritate me in the pocket with their bulk or weight.
 
Thanks for the great story Carl, I'm still evolving myself, actually more of a metamorphosis than an evolution. ;)
 
Thanks for sharing Carl. As a young in I also used a sak but over time have come to enjoy a single blade most. I still do appreciate multi tooled knives though :)
 
Carl I love reading your stories. My first knife was a SAK my pop gave me and same story as you left it at home when I joined the Navy. Bought two benchmades at the PX, gave one to dad and kept one. Dad has worn his down to a sliver and I lost mine in 2006. My wife bought me a hen and rooster whittler and ever since I'm fascinated with the complexity of multi-blades so I'm evolving the other direction as you.
Respectfully, Chance.
 
Different path but nearly the same starting and ending points for me.

I got my first BSA Ulster when I was 8 and my grandfather had hopes that I would complete scouts. Despite stern warnings to the contrary, I carved backwards while sitting on the beach at his cabin and promptly got 5 stitches in my thumb and a lifetime love for knives (weird, huh?).

Scouts was a bust for me, which says something more about me than Scouting. By high school, my collection of Scout knives lay scattered among various "stuff" drawers in disuse. In hindsight, the problem was the damnable emblem, reminding me of work left undone.

Scouting left me with another bad taste in my mouth. The rich kids. They had flashy SAKs with a bunch of wizz-bang thingies while I was throwing papers on porches trying to earn enough for a Buck 110 from Herters. In high-school, I discovered bikes, being a bike mechanic and backpacking. I went to college with a Millet rucksack from REI, my Buck 110 from Herters, a nice Fuji, some bike tools and a lingering chip on my shoulder about rich kids.

In college, I got deeper into being a mechanic and into bike touring (first) and backpacking (second). The heavy Buck got set aside with the fishing gear and I started dabbling with multi-tools. But they were still too heavy.

I went to graduate school trying to follow in my fathers and grand-father's steps, both of whom were math professors. I lugged along a SOG paratool on many trips but it stayed with the backpacking gear and I fell out of the habit of having a knife nearby. The Vic Classics started showing up on key chains around then and I followed suit while holding my nose. My grudge was confirmed as I went through at least 10 of them, all falling apart in rather short order. One did end up in my 1st aid kit for backpacking though and pretty much stayed there. A well meaning brother in law gave me a nice Camillus small serpentine jack and I carried that backpacking for several years but never warmed up to it.

I should mention that my tool and knife use, acquisition, disregard and reconsiderations were formed by 2 opposing viewpoints. As a mechanic, I understood the virtue of using the right tool for the job and the perils of using the wrong tools. Multi-tools weren't real tools and that was frustrating.

But, as a cyclist and backpacker, I was attracted to minimalism and kept St-Expery's famous quote taped on my computer monitor. "In design, as in all things, perfection is not attained when there is nothing left to add, but rather, when there is nothing left to remove."


About 10 years ago, I was trading some bike and ski parts and in the mix, ended up with a funny wooden knife with a lock ring. For reasons unknown to me, I put it in my pocket and it was like a tumbler in a lock sliding into place. Here was a knife I could get my hand around. I could actually cut food with it. But it was light. Stripped of all unnecessary stuff. Over the years, since, I've learned that it is also tough. But it lacks tools...

I honestly can't say when I tried the Leatherman Micra. I know it was after tossing out yet another wrecked Vic Classic that had fallen off my key ring piece by broken piece. [The tooth pick is the first to eject. Next is a race. Will the more secure tweezers find their way out on their own or will the scissor spring bust off first? After that, it's the scales.] But the Micra was too big really for key chains and using any tool with keys attached is silly. At the suggestion of a work mate, I tried in in my left front pocket and another tumbler slid into place for me.


I'm almost never without a pack or bag of some sort. Years of carrying that trusty Millet rucksack, gave way to messenger bags and computer bags and now a sling pack. The old SOG Paratool my then new bride gave me has never been far off. Just trying to find it's right place - somewhere between my pockets and belt (where it doesn't belong) and my tool boxes (where it's superfluous). It's place is in my pack. Nearby, if really needed.

These are in my pocket nearly every day. Paratool is in my pack.


edc-pair by Pinnah, on Flickr
 
Last edited:
My personal knife evolution has been more about size than number of blades.

I started carrying a yellow Schrade Walden Trapper my dad gave me when I was six. That was my constant companion until I hit my teen years and became enamored with folding hunters.

A bunch of us redneck boys that ran together carried those big rascals in our back pockets, and kept them hair popping sharp. It was sort of a local fad. We were all hunters and outdoorsmen and also fancied them for other less innocuous purposes.

Adulthood made me back off on knife size a little, but I have always liked bigger folders, Trappers and large Stockmen.

Right now I have on order a single blade GEC #15 Boy's knife and a #92 Eureka Jack.

They are a step down in size.

I don't ever see myself being a Peanut type guy, but I have evolved down a little.
 
Really enjoyed reading that, thanks! I'm just getting into knives and that was very touching. Can't wait to pass something down to my future kid one day.
 
I seem to be trending in that direction, too. My next step is to have Fausto get me a resolza. With any luck it may be my Christmas present this year.
 
Back
Top