TL;DR: Do [you], as someone who is doing a basic urban job in sales, service, at a desk, etcetera; really use/need your EDC items?
Full disclosure: I'm not asking for advice on changing my EDC. I know I could "trim the fat" and still have a very functional EDC for my lifestyle, but that's not the point
I, like many, don't work a trade or anything that requires serious tools; I'm almost always doing mundane stuff around the city. However my EDC still includes:
-a 3-3.5 in blade knife (usually a SB caly 3/3.5)
-victorinox cadet/victorinox pioneer x/victorinox classic sd/leatherman juice s2/leatherman squirt ps4
-a light (usually a streamlight microstream)
My question to you fellow Keyboard-Commandos is: how often do you really use what you carry? The SAK classic or squirt PS4 could do a good 75% of my cutting (at least; although it fails in the "tasks" department), and the other tools could do a good 80-90%. I carry the knife to do the other 10%, because they lock, and because they're one-handed; sure, but really I carry the knives in addition to the multitools because I like them. Similarly, the flashlight on my phone would do fine in the context of my uber-urban life. It's cumbersome, not very bright, and not really capable of being any illusion of a spotlight, but it would work considering most of my time is spent inside or out during the day.
At the end of the day, the items can still be useful, but it's not nearly as important for me as it is for others. They're convenient and I enjoy them, but having just one of my common multitools would be plenty enough for me.
I hope I was clear enough without being too pedantic. If not, feel free to ask me to clarify
Full disclosure: I'm not asking for advice on changing my EDC. I know I could "trim the fat" and still have a very functional EDC for my lifestyle, but that's not the point
I, like many, don't work a trade or anything that requires serious tools; I'm almost always doing mundane stuff around the city. However my EDC still includes:
-a 3-3.5 in blade knife (usually a SB caly 3/3.5)
-victorinox cadet/victorinox pioneer x/victorinox classic sd/leatherman juice s2/leatherman squirt ps4
-a light (usually a streamlight microstream)
My question to you fellow Keyboard-Commandos is: how often do you really use what you carry? The SAK classic or squirt PS4 could do a good 75% of my cutting (at least; although it fails in the "tasks" department), and the other tools could do a good 80-90%. I carry the knife to do the other 10%, because they lock, and because they're one-handed; sure, but really I carry the knives in addition to the multitools because I like them. Similarly, the flashlight on my phone would do fine in the context of my uber-urban life. It's cumbersome, not very bright, and not really capable of being any illusion of a spotlight, but it would work considering most of my time is spent inside or out during the day.
At the end of the day, the items can still be useful, but it's not nearly as important for me as it is for others. They're convenient and I enjoy them, but having just one of my common multitools would be plenty enough for me.
I hope I was clear enough without being too pedantic. If not, feel free to ask me to clarify

