The knives I kept.

Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Messages
17,577
I've had a lot of knives in my life.

Being a knife knut, I guess it was inevitable that I would buy lots of knives. I don't know if I've had as much as some here, but enough that some of my non knife knut friends and family wondered about my metal state. I've had big knives, small knives, yella handle knives, sak's, barlows, stockmen, jacks, and sodbusters. About the only knife I didn't have was the Buck 110. I admit that I'm maybe the only person on the planet that didn't have one, at one time or another. I remember seeing my first one, and wondering why somebody invented a boat anchor with a blade on it.

But most of my knives ended up going down the road. Oh, I;d keep them for a while, play with them, then they'd go to a worthy cause. Someone who didn;t have a knife, or a good one. Or given to a local kid who was in the scouts. Looking back, there was only a very few that I kept for long periods of time. And they all had one thing in common.

I don't seem to have kept any knife longer than 3 and something inches. Or without at least two blades. My two longest used knives, overlapping about 25 years, with some use still in rotation, were 3 1/2 and 3 7/8ths inches. A sak and a Stockman. But even that has changed. Over the last 20 years, I seem to have went down to just an even 3 inches or so. A Victorinox bantam, Victorinox classic, Buck cadet, and my old standby that I seem always to come back to, my Case peanut. I even found myself eying an Eisenhower.

I just don't seem to need as much knife these days. It can't for lack of need. Being a retired old fart, I have time to go fishing, shooting, canoeing, scooter riding, woods rambling, and tent camping more than ever. Karen and I love our camping trips to Assateague Island, and combine the camping with canoeing to a canoe in only camp site. Certainly I use a knife more now than ever. But 2 inches or so of blade seems to be enough for me these days.

It seems to be enough for whittling a few extra tent stakes on a windy day to hold the tent down better. It seems enough to slice up the steak, onion, and bell pepper for the kabobs to go over the coals. Certainly seems enough to gut and clean some fish. There's something so right about a yella handle peanut with a nice dark patina gutting a pan fish. Folksy, you might even say. Not to mention being retired, now I have no excuse for those home projects Karen likes to come up with. The honey-do list. Slicing open bags of mulch, trimming the rough ends of the piece of lumber I just used a saw on, cutting some jute twine for the garden lattice work out back.

I feel a little shocked that I've become the old guy with the pen knife syndrome I never understood when I was a young stud. Heck, I'm not sure I understand it now, either. But then I didn't understand whiskey when I was young either. And once upon a time, I said I'd give up motorcycling when they pounded that last nail in the lid.

So, how many of you guys have noticed a change of taste as you got older?

Carl.
 
Last edited:
Well, I'm not just as old as you are Carl, but at 44 years of age I have switched from my fully serrated Spyderco's to Sak's exclusively.

Before I carried the Military in full SpyderEdge, now it's my Alox Bantam and Classic.:p

Further more I'm not canged all that much.

I guess you can say that I've alway been of "older age" :o
 
Looking back, there was only a very few that I kept for long periods of time. And they all had one thing in common.

Nope, two things. The other thing they have in common is that you've never posted any photos of those knives here for your biggest fans! Would it help if we begged, Carl? :D

-- Mark
 
i doubt i qualify as an old fart (33 here)

but i've noticed that growing up watching TV in the 80s that real life is nothing like you saw on TV. I used to think that a knife wasnt a (real) knife unless it was big (crocadile dundee anyone?)

I actually had my boy scout knife taken away from me because i was caught throwing it at a cabin door by our little troup leader. He was right to take it from me though, because i didnt think of the knife as a tool, i thought it was a toy.

the older I am getting the more I realize that you just need something sharp, I keep stressing to my niece and nephew (8 and 9) that a pocket knife doesnt have to be big it just has to be sharp. And even if I wanted to, my job wont let me carry around some big fixed blade attached to my hip. So i started carrying a sak.

The sak (highlander model) was all I ever needed for years until i really started getting into knives. Went though a bunch of different styles, but no matter what is in my right pocket, I always got that sak in my left pocket. I just like having all the tools on it available.

Now I have upgraded my wenger highlander for a victorinox tinker (in my opinion better fit and finish, but its a 91mm vs the highlanders 84mm and i wish i had held out for the small tinker)

So, to answer Carl's question, i guess my tastes (and ideas of what a real knife is) has changed significantly over the years....
 
Nope, two things. The other thing they have in common is that you've never posted any photos of those knives here for your biggest fans! Would it help if we begged, Carl? :D

-- Mark

LOL.
Inb4 someone from BF.C shows up at Carl's house, takes pictures of his knives, and rushes off to post them on line. Haha.
Would be really cool to see some of your Knives. A picture of your dad's venerated Peanut, of Andy Warden's Cadet, or even of your old, 20 some odd year old Buck would be amazing.
Note to Carl: Tell your grandson to take pictures for you and post them on here. STAT!!
lol.
 
Even though I am older than Carl, I still have not stabilized. I love everything from tiny gentlemen's knives to hunters, and am known to carry everything in between. I envy minimalism but I cannot seem to bring myself to go that route. I can hardly walk through my house for the books, gadgets, tools, photographic junk, firewood, hardwood lumber and smoking woods, pots and pans of every imaginable ilk... you get the picture, and my knife situation follows suit. I guess I'm just crazy about "stuff."
 
I too am retired. Basically carry a silver alox SI or a nice black alox pioneer I just bought. I don't have hundreds of knives, but more than I've bothered to count lately. Still, I carry the two least expensive, utilitarian ones I own. Even my minimalist father carries something with a bone handle. Hard to figure.
 
I always carried a fixed blade with 4" blade for edc and a vic huntsman. Realizing i never used the fixed blade for anything but kept carrying it just in case i needed something stout made me step back last year.

I got my first real slippie and havn't looked back. I liked it so much i got rid of the sak too and started carrying your 4-way screwdriver and p-38. Most important of all with this is i'm happy with just a slippie now and don't miss the other.
 
Maybe we need a traditional knife forum for us (lucky) retired guys who get to sit around ruminating on these important issues ...:p
 
Maybe we need a traditional knife forum for us (lucky) retired guys who get to sit around ruminating on these important issues ...:p

You mean like our very own Liars Circle on the front porch?

The chairs are for the esteemed members, upended orange crates for the young guys. Yeah, I could go with that!:D

I'll bring my own wicker rocker.

Carl.
 
You mean like our very own Liars Circle on the front porch?

The chairs are for the esteemed members, upended orange crates for the young guys. Yeah, I could go with that!:D

I'll bring my own wicker rocker.

Carl.

I'll bring bourbon and cigars...
 
Elliott. I bring A few EKA 38 and when we have been lookin on your Bourbon I will give you the chance to switch one of those materpeices for a simple Eriksson cattle knife.

Notice, no smileys, Im dead serious about this opportunity for you.

Still no smileys.


..Please dont ban me from this forums.

Bosse
 
I'll think long and hard on your offer, Bosse.



(Okay, I'm done.)


;)
 
Blues. I dont realy understand your answer. Is it the yellow plastic you want or my wooden one. If its the orange one Im rather attached to it so if you want that one you may consider tempting me with a stockman simular bone handle, I belive you understand witch one. Or is it the white stainless one with the lazy spring. I dont know if that possible because lazy springs on a EKA 38 is very rare to find.

In honor of Cars original topic I will thank you for inspiering thoughts again. A thread like this deserve an chain of own thoughts.
The answer to the subject is that I dont evolve anything as for size. In the beginning I liked my handles to be 8,5-9,5 cm long and the blade to be 6-7 cm long. I didnt want them to thick or heavy. This is still 30 years later what I want from a Pocketknife. May it be a modern thing as a U2 or a medium case stockman. This is the smallest size for me to be realy useful for what I sometimes do and the biggest I can carry in a pocket comfortable. I use bouth smaller and bigger knifes but this is what I realy feels at home with.

Bosse
 
I'm 31, and don't have the "qualifications" :p to comment on this one.

Carl, you've helped in my conversion to actually using a peanut, I need to get one (2.5" blade length rule and all ;) ). Listening to you older gents has lead me from hulking, folding monstrosities with thick blades and grinds, to smaller folders. I don't really get much use out of the big folders anymore. I just can't get rid of them, all, yet.
 
I don't know, Bosse...we're so Nirre, and yet so far...

Let's just save it for the campfire. ;)
 
Campfires is the best. I will not embaress myself anymore, If you feel a regret later on just give me a call, my offer stands proud. ;)

I have an old puma prospector that is acctually the closest image to my ideal knife and still I seldom use it. figure that. I even keep a spare one in case I loose the knife I almost never carry in fright of missplasing it. I sometimes realy think about why I dont use my best things all the time. Life is short and I,m the one liking the things. Last week I had my case stockman missplaced and thought about where it was. When I got home again I emideately found it but I had to Think clearly about it again as my feeling of feared loss made me careful with it. Its a treasured gift I dont want to loose but Im thinking if I dont use it Its walue for me will fade away. Much of the love for my knifes lies in the feeling of my hands so to say.
And further more it has the exact right size 6 cm blade and 8.5 cm handle. " good extra blades too. what a waste to just have a knife like that in a collection not using it.


Bosse
 
Sir, I enjoy very much your thoughts. You are a really good story teller and always provide food for thought. Please keep them coming.

About the only knife I didn't have was the Buck 110. I admit that I'm maybe the only person on the planet that didn't have one, at one time or another. I remember seeing my first one, and wondering why somebody invented a boat anchor with a blade on it.
LOL Exactly my view, I never got one, either. But I bet it's a best seller...

So, how many of you guys have noticed a change of taste as you got older?
I'm an eclecticist, variety has been a constant in my entire life. I'll worry when I start sticking to the same thing. When I find my self in that rut, that's when I'll know I'm really old (not meaning any disrespect for those who like constancy, there is nothing wrong with that, I'm just saying that's not me). :)
 
Back
Top