The One Year Plus Review Thread! Share your experiences

Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
473
I thought it would be a good idea to make a thread for members to post reviews of knives they have loved (or hated) for more than a year. This will create more comprehensive reviews compared to the reviews of knives people just got :D

Ill start off with my Caly 3 and Delica 4 reviews!

I look forward to everyones contributions!

Knife Reviews:

Caly 3 Super Blue: Post #2
Delica 4 Super Blue: Post #3
Svord Mini Peasant: Post #4
Benchmade 810: Post #5
Paramilitary 2: Post #7
 
Last edited:
The Caly 3 has been one of my favourite models this past year, and I would like to share my thoughts on it. I originally purchased 2 Caly 3 SB's from Knifecenter when they came out to go along with my 2 Caly 3.5 SB's. After using the Caly 3 in the kitchen for a couple days, I decided it wasn't for me as at the time I couldn't stand the vertical play that lock-backs are known to have. So up on BF they went, all sold except my Caly 3 that I currently have. So after a couple weeks I just decided to use it instead of selling it and I am glad I did.



I used the Caly 3 for most of the summer last year while working construction and it exceeded my expectations. The ergos, blade design, steel, and the overall complete package won me over and it made way for me to try more lock-backs.

The SuperBlue steel was one of the first things that made me fall in love with this knife. Takes a very nice edge with very little effort sharpening, and held the edge for a good amount of time. My knife has had a lot of change over the year in regards to the patina, which added to the fun of carrying the knife often.









The ergos were the next thing that amazed me about the knife. Nothing melts in my hand better than the Caly 3 does. Heres some more photos just for fun. Highly recommend the Caly 3 to anyone looking for a nice knife with great value.



















 
The Delica 4 in sabre ground VG10 was my first spyderco and I ended up selling it to my friend as I wasn't a big fan of lock backs at the time. When spyderco released the SB Delica I decided I would give the model another try since Lockbacks were growing on me :D After carrying the Caly 3 for so long I could warm up to the Delica's ergos and ended up selling the knife. For whatever reason I purchased another D4 SB on impulse and I am very happy I did!

After using the Delica for a couple weeks I warmed up to the ergos and started to really enjoy the knife. It was by far my most used knife last year while working construction and it served me very well. I prefer the Delica to the Caly now due to the very thin spin and the increased slicing ability.



Ergos aside, the deep-carry wire clip on the Caly is a big upgrade in my opinion from the Delica's clip. I felt too much of the knife stuck out for me to carry it in public. I fixed this problem recently with one of Casey's Clip and it makes this knife almost perfect as far as I'm concerned.



As I mentioned in my Caly 3 review, Super Blue steel is a joy to use and sharpen. It takes an edge easier than any other steel I have used and can take a decent amount of punishment without chipping. Overall I highly recommend this model to anyone who like the Delica or wants a very thin capable slicer in a fun steel.

Here are some photos take in roughly chronological order since purchasing the Delica I have been using :D



































 
This was originally posted in another thread, but I will share it here:

Svord_Mini_EDC.jpg


I've been carrying the Svord mini peasant knife for a year now, exclusively, except for a few formal occasions when I have carried other knives. It just went into my pocket and I never wanted another knife from then on. Every morning I reach for the familiar curved orange handle, and I'm on my way. Why do I like it so much? Because it cuts well and is no fuss.

Here are my thoughts after 1 year:

STEEL: I thought it was L6 carbon steel, but Svord now lists 15N20, which is very similar to L6. I put the edge retention on par with Opinels, SAKs, Buck's 420HC ,which is perfectly adequate for me. It's not very hard, but it's easy to sharpen with basic tools. I use a ceramic rod and strop on cardboard. I use it to shave some facial hairs. There's a nice patina from cutting fruits and vegetables.

BLADE GEOMETRY: The blade is 2.5" long and 1.5mm thick. It's plenty strong for its size, and large enough to prepare a meal without undue discomfort. You can see the funky "Svord grind," which is fully ground at the tip, and then recedes toward the tang. There is a secondary bevel. Bottom line, it cuts well due to its slim stock. I find the drop point with generous belly a versatile layout. This knife is a competent wood carver (see the butter knife below).

HANDLE: It's polypropylene with a nice, non-slip texture. The scales are thick enough to provide comfort when bearing down hard on the blade, and for hours of carving. The protruding tang does not cause any discomfort. When pushing hard on the blade, the handle flexes somewhat, though one's confidence stays intact. I've cut away the pointy tip to shorten the knife and avoid premature wear on my pockets. The scales show no signs of wear after a year.

CARRY-ABILITY: It's all about the tang with the Peasant knife. It is a big turn-off to the casual observer, who cites two issues: 1) The tang makes the knife longer. I can't deny that, but in my front pocket, I really only feel the handle, not the tang. If anything, the extended tang helps keep the knife vertical, which is a plus. 2) The exposed tang can cause accidental opening in your pocket. I adjust the rear screw to pinch the blade closed. I bike to work daily, lift heavy equipment, and the blade has always stayed secure. Accidental opening is a non-issue for me. Maybe if you practice Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu with a peasant knife in your pocket, who knows? As a pocket knife, I have no reservations about recommending the Mini Peasant for EDC. It weighs 1.5 ounces, which makes it easy to stash in any pocket. I wear Dickies, which are on the loose side. If tight jeans are your thing, maybe this isn't the knife for EDC.

EASE OF USE, MAINTENANCE: It's easy to operate the Svord Mini Peasant with one hand. The knife is already returning to the pocket in the time it takes to open a two handed knife. There is no lock as this is a friction folder. That means, my hand gripping the handle and tang keeps the blade from closing. This system has never failed. When I sweat in the summer, condensation does start small rust spots if I don't wipe off the blade. I don't oil the blade, just tighten the screws every month or two. If I cut food, I wash the blade, blow out the pivot with my lungs, and wipe dry. The knife is so simple, not much can go wrong. When I first got the knife, I did install a thicker stop pin to keep the blade from touching the rear screw when closed. This fix is still working.

CONCLUSION: I did not know this knife would work so well for me when I got it. I still want to get other knives, like a Buck 501, which is so handsome. However, the 501 weighs twice as much, so I doubt it will displace the easy-going Mini Peasant. The unassuming Peasant knife isn't going to impress people with good looks or exotic materials. Luckily, I prize utility above all else. For the foreseeable future, this knife will still be my top choice for EDC.

My original impressions on Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tRSFC--GDkI
How tough is the Mini Peasant? Watch it bust up a big branch.

svord_butter.jpg
 
Fantastic report man, and a great idea.

I only have a few knives that I carry consistently. One is a Benchmade 810, the other a Fiddleback Forge Kephart.

My 810 has been carried quite a bit over the past couple of years. The very tip was broken off by a coworker the edge is 28° inclusive, and the Cerakote has been stripped. I prefer a patina on all of my blades if possible.

The ergonomics and fragile backspacer (when using the carbide glass breaker) have been an issue for some, but neither have been a problem for me. It's not a knife I'd use for whittling or times where the ergos might come into question, but it slices and does general cutting very very well.

DnnFVZJ.jpg


The blade swings freely, but there is no wiggle, and it's centered. I couldn't ask for a better large general use folder.
 
Awesome contributions! I'm pretty sheltered in that I only really pay attention to spyderco so I look forward to reading about other companies products!
 
This knife has had endless reviews so I may not provide any information that hasn't been said already. But all else fails, I'll provide a bunch of pictures to make the review more entertaining :D

The paramilitary 2 is the reason I got into knives and it led to my discovery of Spydercos and high end knives in general. I ended up collecting this model and purchased multiples of most of them. I found the Para2 to provide the perfect balance of weight, strength, size, and blade length for my needs at the time. But, like most, the aspect that set this knife above others for me was the compression lock. This lock in my opinion is by far the most entertaining to use and provides the most control out of all the locks I have tried. I find the Ergos to be perfect for my hand when using the knife with or without the choil. And I find the blade provides a good balance of strength and thickness with slicing ability.

All the hype around different steels led my to buying the CTS-20cp sprint which started my collecting stage and I ended up with 10 at one point before selling almost all of them :eek:







Now I'll talk about my experience with the Para2 while using it extensively during my time working construction.

The Para2 I found was a perfect knife for construction due to its lightweight and ability to take a beating. I dropped the knife on concrete and rocks tons of times, pried with it, scrapped material, and even did some very light batoning at times and the knife help up great! The g10 on most of my users had chips and dents, and the blades had scratches, but that will happen with any knife.

The most damage I did was to my 20cp model and it was just a tiny chip from cutting through material and hitting rocks underneath





And that model I decided to stonewash and dye after that little incident :D







Couple extra photos just for fun :D













I ended up selling all of them except for one M390 Para2, which is my favourite out of all of them. The Gayle Bradley was the major determinant in my decision as the Fit & Finish, steel, and overall design of the GB was mind blowing for me and made it easy to justify selling off the collection. If/when Spyderco does a run of M4 Para2s I will not hesitate to buy 2 of those however :D

Some shots over last summer of my M390 Para :D



















 
Back
Top