The One?!

Joined
Jan 30, 2012
Messages
240
Written as more of a collection of my thoughts; apologies if it's not relatively easy to follow.

For as long as I've been a pocket knife enthusiast, I've liked the idea of a signature knife. One that is on your person most days, although it can be supplemented given the situation (in my case, the secondary is a Victorinox Rambler that I consider more of a multi-tool). Something that ages with you, and that your children fondly remember you using. I think this way about a lot of things: watches, tools, particularly nice bags/luggage and shoes.

I like smaller knives. Anything more than 3" closed is often just too big for my tastes. Maybe it's because I'm built slightly, but I can "feel" a larger (to me) knife in my pockets. I also subscribe to Carl/jackknife's maxim that anything a smaller knife can't cut for you, and additional inch or two probably won't make much of a difference. In other words, you'll likely need something substantially larger (still trying to find something that will fit that bill, although there is no rush since I can't think of a time it was a need).

Speaking of Carl, his posts influenced me to pick up a yellow delrin CV Case Peanut not long after I found bladeforums. In fact, I carried a Peanut and Victorinox classic combo just like Carl did. I know Carl has had a profound effect on a lot of folk here, particularly the newbies. Must be some parts cool, some parts creepy that a bunch of random people on the internet follow your example! Getting back to the peanut, I learned I'm just not a big fan of clip points. Can't explain it. Tried several others, but they just don't "sing" to me. Did a GAW for the peanut here. Don't recall who won it, but hope it's getting the use it deserves. (Honestly, still kinda miss it.) Also prefer the Manager over the Classic for the pen and the blade the opens away from the keyring.

What I do like are spear points. It would also be nice to have a straight edge, for variety and utility, and mostly because I've owned only a few examples (which I barely used). I appreciate, and daresay prefer, that pocket knives can have multiple blades. Seems more ... efficient; packing more in the same space. I have also realized that while I like smaller knives, I also prefer chunkier ones. More blades helps with that. See Vic Manager vs. Classic.

Earlier this year, pmew/Paul - a terrific guy - sent me a GEC #18 Coyote in brown jigged bone. It was my first Wharncliffe. Besides appreciating the thoughtfulness of the gift, I quite liked the frame. I don't think that I've mentioned this to Paul, but I'm saving it to give to my son when he's old enough - I'm going to have the shield engraved with the initial of his first name. The PPP blade etch are actually my initials! His twin sister will get the 2016 limited edition Vic Classic alox in Orchid, which is more or less purple - her favorite color. When they are old enough is going to be determined in part by their mother. My wife doesn't understand my hobbies, but loves me enough to let me pursue them (responsibly).

I hadn't really considered the #18 Beagle, but I decided the other day on a whim to look at some knives (how often do you all do that?!) online, and came across some. Then it all came together regarding items above, as well as a few others:
- Less than 3" closed. Check.
- Peanut-like and chunky. Check.
- Spear point main. Check.
- Straight edge secondary. Check. (Not to mention secondary behind main.)
- Natural stag covers. Check. Sambar deer are native to India (along with other places in Asia) - I ethnically Indian, and was born there.
- Made in the USA. Check. Proud of my South Asian heritage, but equally proud to be a citizen of this great country. I try to support US manufacturers.
- Serial number 78. Check. My birth year.

DLT Trading was awesome to do business with (I believe they are a site sponsor, so the mention is ok. Obviously, if not, mods please remove.), and the shipping was fast. Without further ado, I give you:



I've been CEing and CFing it all week. Makes a terrific worry stone. If you've made it all the way through this post, thanks, and I hope you enjoyed it!
 
Last edited:
Great post and I love small knives but my hands don't. I carried a peanut for many years and like others if fell from rotation. I then picked up a Beagle in Cola? bone and really really like it. Feels quite substantial. I love the blade combo, takes a wicked edge, f&f is top notch with solid blades, it's just a great knife.

You've got a great one there:thumbup:
 
Last edited:
Thank you for posting this. I have the same thoughts but plk7 you articulated it better than I could have. There are things I buy and sometimes pay more for because they will last longer, could become an heirloom for my family or act as some sort of identifying reminder of me to my family. Not that my identity is wrapped up in the things I own just simply a tangible way to connect me to my loved ones. This feeling has grown tremendously since the birth of my daughter. I want to have a few trinkets that aside from financial value have sentimental value. Knives and watches for example fit that bill perfectly. Perhaps I'm looking too hard but I still have not found that one knife that checks all of those boxes yet. As my knife collection grows this nagging thought keeps popping up... does too many unspecific knives cheapen what I'm trying to build? That's totally separate from "I personally like pocket knives so I collect knives I like." It may seem silly to others but I enjoy having less of something but having the best for my needs.

I'm excited for you plk7 that you were possibly able to find that one, congratulations! I hope to do so as well someday sooner than later.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Paul - Thanks for your words. I appreciate your posts, and enjoy seeing photos of your collection. I'm glad that you are enjoying your Beagle; substantial is an appropriate for to describe it. I would enjoy visiting your part of the country some time; the photos I've seen look beautiful.

JITDC - Thanks for taking the time to reply. "I have the same thoughts but plk7 you articulated it better than I could have. ... It may seem silly to others but I enjoy having less of something but having the best for my needs." <-- I think you nailed it there. When I'm trying to locate something, my wife always says "stop looking, and you'll find it." This turned out to be the case for me. My unsolicited advice to you would be enjoy watching your little girl grow (I'm sure you do), and you'll come across the knife (or knives) that's perfect for you at the right moment. Maybe even an IRJ!
 
That's a great post. I'm still look for "the one". I typically carry more than one with me, dependent on what my plans for the day are. I, like you, would like to find one that I carry every day - always - at least as a secondary. Perhaps with my journey into traditionals, I will find what I'm looking for. Until I do, I've got a lot of experimenting to do :)
 
I love small knives. ESPECIALLY smally slip joints. Thanks for the great post. YOu have got me thinking about getting an #18 myself lol :D
 
I have to admit, Carl and his cult made me try out the Peanut after thinking for years that 3.5" knives were "small" and 4" was better. I tried it out and now always have a Peanut of some type with me. Love the pattern. I've got a couple of Beagles too.
 
I really enjoyed your post, plk7! And I like your Beagle! Beautiful! I share many of your sentiments regarding knives. I, too, prefer spear points. Another member here, the awesome mrknife, recently gifted me a lovely GEC #14. It may be The One for me. It checks off all of my boxes. It is my favorite knife, hands down. I absolutely love it. [emoji4] I might look into getting another identical knife down the road to have as a back up. I love canoes, barlows, and peanuts, but the #14 really speaks to me. However, seeing as how you like your Beagle so much and it has a spear point, I might have to look into it!


Alex
 
Back in the day I always liked Barlow knives. After ruining a lot of blades trying to use as a screwdriver I picked up SAK's and learned to appreciate stainless. Still liked Barlows but no screwdriver meant I wasn't going to carry one any more. Then I found the ONE.
ZeRfpSr.jpg

It's a Trestle Pines Grand Fortage. Or as I call it, 'Barlow with a screwdriver'.
Anyhow it's what I carry now. I sometimes miss some of the stuff on my old Explorer Plus, but I just don't feel right carrying anything else anymore. I would've given my right arm for this 30 years ago.
 
Congrats on finding the perfect Beagle for you! I've got a Coyote and Beagle now but tend to favor the Coyote.

I've carried the same Peanut almost everyday since the first week of June, and I'll continue to carry it for the foreseeable future. I always carry multiple, though, and I've recently found the #14TC to be a nearly constant companion to my Peanut. Now that I have two nearly constant secondaries, I've been rotating a third and even fourth knife daily. I'm starting to feel like GT! :p
 
"The One" is a hard knife to find. I've been actively searching for over 20 years, (closer to 30, if you count my misguided youth). I have a couple that I find that I carry much more often than any others.

First is the 2013 Bladeforum's Traditional, the Irish Jack reverse-Congress, with the extra long straight edged blade (can never remember if it's called a sheepsfoot, or what), and small pen. I may have messed up on the name of this thing, but you should be able to I. D. it from my description. Anyway, it's the one most likely at the bottom of my pocket. Love the blade combo, the size and the looks. Really, it could do everything I'd ever need a knife to do.

Second would be the Bose/Case Lanny's Clip in Chestnut bone, that I picked up a few years ago. It is, by far, the most expensive traditional I've ever purchased, pre-paying full retail, just to make sure I didn't miss out. This knife is just perfection in manufacture. Plus, with the 154CM steel, it's nearly indestructible. It doesn't hurt that it's gorgeous, as well. This one often rides in a fine leather slip sheath that came with a French Le Thiers knife I also like quite a bit.

Have I found "The One?" Probably not, but I am content to continue looking. It's the journey that makes life interesting.

I am constantly discussing, using, showing off, and playing with my knives, so I don't think my kids will have trouble associating any given knife in my collection with "Dad" and his crazy knife habit. Those that don't get used often will probably be sold off at some point, but not yet.
 
You know, each time I think I found the perfect knife, something else comes up. Its the journey that matters. Dont stop believing :D
 
netguy - As someone with a background in scientific research, I can tell you that experimenting is a good thing!

Mark - Thank you. I remember an older thread where you documented carrying/using a CV Peanut from when you first got it. Still have it?

Woodrow - I sometimes wonder just how many people have picked up a Peanut because of the Cult.

FelineGirl - I have a 15, and given my preference for smaller knives, the 14 was very tempting.

bt93 - Outstanding knife!

Wurrwulf - How do you pick which one to use?

Daniel - I appreciate your comments. Your faves are a couple of really fine knives. Maybe for you it's not about The One, but The Two - and you've already found them!
 
I also like small knives and thus like Chris Reeve Mnandi. I've been looking for the right Peanut, but I really like the 78 you posted. Maybe they have one left.
 
plk7, 9 times out of 10, the Peanut gets the work. The others are really just pocket jewelry. I still haven't cut anything with my #14TC, but the size is fantastic and it's gorgeous. :o The others are auditioning for more pocket time.
 
plk7 : Enjoyed reading about your finding The One . I decided to get the Coyote in Stag and also in the Red Bone because it was just a new pattern . After receiving them I was very impressed with both of them as well . They are outstanding little knives to carry when I feel that I should carry something small. However , right now what I would call my The One is a 73 in Stag. I really like the 73 pattern , but there is also just something about having some stag in my pocket . This particular 73 is one that my Son bought me and that also makes it special to me .
I hope your The One brings as much enjoyment to you as mine does to me .

Harry
 
I know what it is, been looking, it never appears.:confused:

Thought about having a Custom but it's tricky, not many maker's do patterns other than what's on their book. Then the details must be right....:rolleyes:

Simple, but elusive: Serp , single-spring 2 blades Pen, just under 3.5". ALL stainless construction, no brass please. Polished bolsters (maybe Rat-Tail), thick scales no skimpy stuff. Bone type and shield TBA....

All Pens I've found are with brass&carbon. The Buck 309 is a nice small un, but 2 spring, not Serp and those Sabre blades are just too dinky to cut up foods.:(

It's out there, somewhere!:D:D
 
Nicely put. I have been on the search for the "One" for going on 5 years now. After many declarations of success, I believe I finally have found the "One". I tried Sod Busters, stockmans, SAK's, Trappers and Lockbacks. All good knives, but not anything that I really connected with that I thought my daughter or future grandkids would identify as "me". Case makes the 087 Medium Jack in smooth black Delrin and also in a stag and 1 color of bone. I have the black Delrin and it ticks all my boxes except for handle choice and steel. Sized just right for watch pocket use, clip and pen blade in jack knife configuration. I'm declaring that as my one go to, along with my peanut. I'm hoping and holding out for Case to make me a decent colored (Chestnut) bone scaled knife with CV blade. My Grail knife. It just hits the sweet spot for me. The peanut, as great as it is, may be just a tad small for me to make it in old age with arthritic hands. Something that is just now beginning to make an appearance with my fumbling fingers. I have a shoebox full of pocket knives, and at some point, I'm going to go through that box and start gifting out some knives to folks. I don't need them, I don't really use them and I'm getting to the point in life where I have just too much stuff.
 
I've been looking for the 'one' knife almost my entree life. There was some periods where I actually found it, and carried nothing else for spoke years at a time. But…life has a habit of changing, due to jobs, lifestyles, marriage, kids, area of dwelling. And, sometimes this big change of life means a change of edc stuff.

For about 20 years my 'one' was a Buck 301 stockman. The three bladed knife was good for a young single guy travel ing the world, camping, fishing, hunting, and some whatever. It was good work knife for the construction sites in the army engineers, then the machine shop I worked at. But…life changed as I got older and the three blade stockman was a bite much. For those years I carried it, I felt no need for another knife, except a SAK that was in my pack, but most times if my pack wash[t near, and I needed a screw driver or can opener, I used the P-38 in my wallet or the sears 4-way screw driver.

After my dad passed away, I carried his little peanut for a while. Mostly out of some sort of sentiment and sense of something gone but still much on the mind. I carried it not as a sole edc, but with my old stockman. But a strange things happened; I would use it now and then for some cutting jobs, not wanting to 'mess up' a family history artifact, and it cut so well that I decided to experiment. I put dad's old peanut back in it's place in the tray on top of my dresser, and bought a yellow Case peanut. I then left my old war horse Buck 301 home and just carried the 'nut. It did everything my old stockman did; cut the filthy tape holding round stock in the shop, cut gasket material, cut cardboard, twine, fishing line, opened mail, plastic blister packages, whatever. It did the job of the edc pocketknife, so it became one, while taking up amazingly little room in the pocket. For almost ten years it was my sole edc, and it became the 'one'. My old Buck got retired.

For the next several years, the Case peanut was my 'one', and I never felt the need for another pocket knife. Then I discovered this place and everything went to heck. I tried sodbusters, trappers, larger jacks, pen knives, and barrows. In the course of a few years I tried more knives than I had ever owned in my whole life. After a few years of the insanity I backed off and just went back to my 'one'. I gifted off most of my knives and kept just a few of my edc favorites, ones that I actually used the most. Today, a peanut still rides in my pocket, but it shares duty with a SAK. I am oldr now, and the SAK is just easier on arthritic fingers with it's smooth even pull. The peanut gets left home a lot now, just because it's a bit more fiddley to deal with than a SAK.

I've come to the conclusion that the 'one' will change with the changes of life we have have to deal with. Even my dad, who loved his little peanut, and swore that it was all the every day pocket knife he needed, retired it to the sock drawer in his older years, because his fingers couldn't deal with the nature of it, and he carried a little Christy knife in his pocket for the easy opening of it. His life had changed, and he had to change with it. Now, as a senior citizen, I look back and realize that I have done the same over my life. What was my 'one' 30 years ago, could not be my 'one' now. I am not the same person I was then, as now.

Today, my edc is smaller than it was when I was younger.
19785783570_36f1029750_c.jpg
[/url]
 
Back
Top