Thoughts on BM Vs. Al Mar

Joined
Apr 27, 2007
Messages
874
I am getting ready to add another carry knife to my collection and have decided that I want a high quality steel blade and G10 handle. I have narrowed my selection to the BM 745, the Al Mar Mini Sere or the Al Mar Nomad. I know that the Al Mars are about $35 more, but I figure that over the like of the knife that is actually very little.

Any thoughts or recommendations that might help me with this decision?
 
I don't have the 745 but I do have both of the Al-Mars you are considering. I also have 15 or so other models from Benchmade and carry a mini-RSK as my EDC, so I do have some confidence in BM.

All of these are pretty close in design, lock style, and size. The 745 will have a slightly larger blade than the Al-Mars and it will be S30V instead of VG-10. I guess it depends on what you plan to do with the knife. S30V is a nice steel for slicers, and it can take some amount of hard use, but it's not as flexible as VG-10. The VG-10 Al-Mars should be a bit tougher in terms of impact resistance, but if that's not a concern for you, then BM's S30V is really sweet to sharpen and use. And I've had no chipping issues with any of my S30V from BM or Spyderco.

My opinion? I love my Al-Mars. They came as sharp OOB as any Spyderco I've ever owned, the lockup is rock solid even after some months of use, and I really love VG-10 as a great all-around steel for a folder, especially if it's a slightly larger knife that might see some hard use. The G-10 scales that Al-Mar puts on the liners was a perfect fit all around the edges and it's nice and grippy w/o being damaging to fabric or skin. The rest of the F&F on my Al-Mars was also first-class, and the Nomad has a flat ground blade that slices as well as any knife I've ever used.

I don't have a 745 because I don't the looks of the knife. I didn't like the Lum designed Spyderco, either. Of the two Al-Mars you've listed, I would probably get the Nomad first because of the usefulness of the flat ground blade. If you want a real low-rider, however, the mini-SERE is the best choice. The clip attaches to the butt end of the knife so the whole knife except the clip rides out of sight.

Whichever you get... enjoy!
 
Back
Top