Thoughts on custom knives

Les Robertson

BANNED
Joined
Oct 10, 1998
Messages
3,565
Hi, this post is just a thumbnail history of custom knives in the US and my thoughts on why I buy custom knives. This is fairly long so please feel free to hit the BACK Button and escape!

The term custom knife was probably coined long ago. When in fact handmade knives were made only for the wealthy or warrior classes.
These edged weapons of warfare or ornamentation were infact custom made to order.

There have been knifemakers in the US as long as it has been the US. The most famous of the 1800's is probably James Black, purported to be the maker of the Knife for Jim Bowie.

The 19th century brought William Scagel, a reclusive knifemaker who was the inspiration for Bo Randall, who in turn became the inspiration for hundereds of knifemakers since. Others included Richter, Nichols, Ek,Ruana and others who carried the load through the 40's and into the 50's. Here several of the Giants enter, Moran, Loveless, Pete Heath,Gil Hibben,Merle Seguine and Walt Kneubuhler and others. The 60's brought even more recognizable names. George Herron, Jimmy Lile, Ted Dowell, D.E. Henry, G.W. Stone, Ralph Bone, H.H. Frank. The 70's saw, Frank Centofante, Buster Warninski, Ron Lake, Herman Schneider, Steve Johnson, Corbet Sigman, Jess Horn, Harvey McBurnette and several other very talnted knifemakers who are still making today.

Its at this point that the term "custom" knife starts to become generic for any handmade knife. The United States Knifemakers Guild is Formed in 1970 in Tulsa Oklahoma. Rules for what is considered a handmade knife that is acceptable to gain entry into the new guild are put in writing.

So the term Custom is probably antiquated at this point. The term handman or perhaps manmade is more appropriate. However, people still do order unique knives that makers produce one of for that customer, hence that knife is truly a custom knife. This is truly the literal sense of the word and not the figurative sense that word Custom now holds in handmade knife lexicon today.

So the word Custom has basically taken on a Genric term to describe the handmade knives being produced today, most within the guidlines the US Knifemakers Guild has set forth. This is not the only set of guidelines out there, the American Blade Smith Society has their Guidelines as does the Professional Knifemakers Association. The one thing all three of the organizations do have in common is that the maker must do the majority of the work on the basic knife (not to include such things as engraving, scrimshaw, etc.).

At this point, you are allowed to insert all of the guidelines you feel are appropriate to support your opinion. This is an endless debate.

Why do we buy custom knives. I purchased my first custom knife because I had a bad experiece with a factory knife during my Officer Basic Course at FT. Benning. So my first purchase was to fill a specific need. I bought a hollow handle survival knife with serrated top edge from Robert Parrish. The cost of this knife in 1983 was $175.00. Why do I remember the cost so well, two reasons. First, I had never spent more than $40 for a knife before and secondly, my lovely wifes voice still ringing in my ear, "You SPENT HOW MUCH". Being a newlywed, I had not yet come to appreciate the fact that the apartment should have things like furniture, washer/dryer, etc. As I spent 7 months of my first 12 at Ft. Campbell, I really had not grown accustom to furniture, a washer/dryer, a shower, a bed, hot food, well you get the idea.

Fortunatley, I got to use all the Army's "toys for boys", M-16, M203, LAW's, Dragons, TOW's, Mortar's, Howitzer's, etc. Strangely though, I was always more drawn to my knife.
It was shortly after I purhased my first custom knife, a fellow Lieutenant, now Major Fletche Crews, informed of something I had never heard of before, The BLADE SHOW! Never, make the Blade Show your fisrt knife show.

I like many of you, was forced to hide my new knives from my wife. I would slowly bring them out, one every couple of weeks. Usually, I would show here as I was headed to a 2 week deployment. By the time I got back she wasnt nearly as upset.

But the habbit grew, with no end in sight. Once again a Crews gets involved. This time it was Fletcher's wife Karla who uttered that fateful sentence, "If you were a dealer, you could right all of your expenses off." Being a grunt and not really understand what she was talking about, I got a business license. All, I knew was that this was an excuse to buy more knives.

We obviously know the end to this story, I got out of the Army almost 4 years ago. I went into the Individual Ready Reserve, was promoted to Major and I resigned my commission in December.

So to say that custom knives is my profession is an understatment. It is my passion. I want others to gain the same enjoyment I do from this wonderful hobby. This also explains, in part, why I try to defend and define what is and what is not a custom knife. The other part has to with being an Infantryman, we love to argue! As the saying goes "Aruging with a Infantryman is like wrestling with a pig, everyone gets dirty but the pig loves it"!

I have been fortunate to buy and sell well over 1 Million Dollars worth of custom knives. Additionall, I have looked at Millions more. While I make no claim to know everything about cutsom knives, I have a pretty good start. I have judged at custom knife showes, I have designed custom knives that have won numerous awards, my custom knife displays have won numerous awarded. With my Bob Neal, my partner in LDC Custom Knives we accomplished what no else ever did. Design and sell a set of knives by 10 different custom knifemakers. To date the only ones to duplicate this feat, are Bob and I. By the way, the cover of the next issue of Tactical Knives will feature knives for the 3rd LDC series. The F5 Series, 5 different fixed blades! Hell, we've even promoted a couple of custom knife shows.

I write all this to show you that I am not a casual observer. I am into custom knvies about as much as one can be without being a knifemaker! No, I have never tried it, nor do I want to. I have no mechanical aptitude and the last thing the custom knife market needs is knifemaker with no talent.

If you read all this, you are obviously into custom knives. I appreciate it and look forward to helping further the appreciation of custom knives for many years to come.




------------------
Les Robertson
Robertson's Custom Cutlery
http://www.robertsoncustomcutlery.com/rcc/makers.shtml
It is easier to get things done with a kind word and a knife, than with a kind word alone!


 
Great commentary Les.

I, too, got into knives while in the Army. Even as a intel analyst, spent more than my fair share in the field as a TDY augmentee. Not enough of us to go around. Really began to appreciate being able to cut what ever I had to easily, under adverse conditions and almost exclusively one handed. Custom knives were an outgrowth of that need and also that they are cool toys I could store in the barracks as opposed to firearms, which were relegated to a safe off post. Most frustrating thing was to having a concealed carry permit in Georgia, but having to drop your weapon off before going on post.

As for a fixed blade, a Mad Dog ATAK2, whether or not custom (hand ground at least) was a constant companion, and earned its price tag many times over. Same can be said for my Lightfoot folder. Not only that, I turned a lot of folks on to knives. Can't quite describe the feeling of depalletizing HUMMVEE's in record time. When the chips are down, you want the best tool possible. Superior function is what led me to drop the pitiful paycheck enlisted folks receive on custom blades. They were and are worth every penny.

[This message has been edited by chrisJohn (edited 17 January 1999).]
 
There seems to be a trend starting here. I am yet another who started his love for knives while in the Army. I still remember the "you spent HOW MUCH??" as if it was yesterday. Then again, I believe I spent more on the divorce. Nowadays, my NEW wife and I travel to the shows together. She believes 200-300 is a great price on a custom. And no, her sister is married. It tends to keep you just a little more "honest" when she is there with you. Otherwise, I don't think we would have the house, the washing machine or the furniture. There is something about a custom knife that feels "good". The problem is, that there is another that feels a "little better", and so on. Next thing you know, you have more knives than the Knife shop does. And you still want more...My wife was shocked to find out that my vacation will be at exactly the same time as the Blade Show in Atlanta...hmm, coincidence??
 
Les, good treatise on custom knives. It answered a lot of questions. When I looked in the dictionary and saw the definition for "custom" as "made to order" the term just didn't seem to fit perfectly but you have explained the difference very well. I own some factory knives, some customs, and some in that nebulous category containing Randalls, Chris Reeve, etc. I've owned true customs but didn't see any advantage over the above.

My love for knives started as a kid when my grandfather taught me to cut meat in his custom meat cutting operation. He taught me to sharpen knives and take care of them. My love for them grew when I joined the Army but I must confess, I was one of those Company Commanders who put the skids on troops in the barracks having all manner of sharp objects in their rooms. I just saw way too many bad things happen to soldiers when drinking in their rooms and figured adding knives (other than ordinary pocket knives) to the equation was not in their best interest. I had to court martial a soldier for stabbing his German girlfriend while off post with her. He used a combat knife he kept at her place to puncture her thigh--not life threatening but try to explain that to her parents and the Polizei! The day General Al Haig had an RPG fired at his staff car and all of U.S. Army, Europe went on alert, I didn't care what kind of knife my troops had on their belts as they manned the rock wall around our Kazerne in Augsburg. Well, I can see the dichotomy when people at my pay grade (05) are not bothered by the knife on their belt but enlisted soldiers have to conform to a less than well thought out SOP. I salute you guys with stripes on your sleeves (collars)--those of you who are the sharp end of the lance!
 
Hope you make bird COL there Bruce! Few field grade officers have as much common sense that you just demonstrated.

The Army could be a great place. One of the hardest things I ever did was going through the hastle applying for OCS, making the cut, and realizing that I would never be promoted beyond CPT and any postitive impact would be severely limited. All branches need people who subscribe to truly be an officer and a gentleman. Somewhere that has been lost by a large majority of enlisted, NCOs, and Officers.

Okay, I have deviated enough from the forum topic.
smile.gif



 
When I first came to this forum I thought anything that a maker made was custom.
When I first heard someone say "if it wasnt made to order it isnt custom" I was offended.

Now having heard the arguments and the statements and having tried it myself I must say that in my world, if you dont have it made a certain way, to your specs, it isnt a custom. Its handmade.

------------------

Mouse Assassins inc.

 
Back
Top