Tidioute Exec Whittler - New collector fit and finish question (with pics)

Joined
May 13, 2014
Messages
205
So I've just begun my collection of traditional folders and I ordered this knife late last week. It arrived today but I noticed the small gap as seen below on initial inspection. I love the knife overall, but I wasn't sure if this was a "common" issue on fit and finish with executive knives or if I should request an exchange if possible? Just looking for feedback on what my General expectations should be for fit and finish when ordering online when it comes to GEC/Tidioute/Northfield. Thanks in advance.

03171509442_zpswu2vj0ma.jpg


0317150942a2_zpsa7oeoagd.jpg
 
In my experience that gap is pretty normal. The wedge ends and there's naturally going to be a gap between there and where the springs are squeezed together at the bolster. I'm not saying it's impossible to get rid of that gap, but on a production knife it's totally expected. Looks to me like you have a beautiful knife there.
 
The alternative to that small gap is having a spacer/wedge that tapers to an even finer point as it fits between the liners. This is possible to make, but as I have experienced on older whittler patterns, that tapering wedge can slice your finger open pretty good if it protrudes even a tiny bit below the springs. The GEC spring wedge looks like a good compromise. Nice knife by the way.
 
Yep, that gap is normal, with a wedge like that. Can't get around it. Nothing wrong with that one, lovely knife! :thumbup:
 
Think how flimsy the wedge would have to be to eliminate that gap... Symptom of the design, it seems to me.
 
Appreciate all the feedback gentlemen. It is a beauty of a knife, and I love the wharencliffe blade, I just wanted to make sure it was correct being my first purchase of this model. Thanks again.
 
That looks completely normal to me. In regards to GEC's fit and finish, they typically don't have very large gaps. I don't think I have any with visible gaps (other than the split spring whittlers) unless you hold them up to a light source. Even then, it's just slivers of light. I do have some that I would call watertight but the norm is to have very slight gaps visible only through light.

The springs are almost always flush in open and closed positions, but usually a little off at half stop. The mirror finish on the Northfields always has scratches and it is very common to have scuff marks on the bolsters/end caps. Blades are usually very close to centered. Sometimes it's necessary to flush the joints first. I've had a few that seemed like they had lazy springs at first only to get very snappy after working some mineral oil in.

When you consider the whole package, I think they do an outstanding job. Remember that these are hand assembled and finished on a production line, so they don't receive the same attention as a custom, but they are still very well done. Plus, no two are precisely the same.
 
Back
Top