I have polished a few edges up to 2000 grit on sand paper just for shits and grins but 600 grt.diamond then a crock stick work for me.
As long as the edge wants to grab my thumb as I lightly drag it over the edge then I'm happy.
Novelty edges are fun to mess around with and a joy to use in certain circumstances.
I usually prefer a moderately polished toothy edge on most of my knifes. In other words, skipping grits when sharpening. I usually go from medium to ultra fine then sometimes strop.
I much prefer a bit of toothiness in my edges especially for EDCs or working knives ... have a few nicer what some would call "gentleman knives" but are only carried rarely and admittedly more for the aesthetics than use.
A little tooth keeps the edge usable longer ... a finely polished or mirrored edge is great for push cuts but dulls much quicker in my experience ... but a toothy edge stays sharper and more usable much longer. IMHO
Why not have both? I own a number of knives that I have put a beautiful polish on the bevels and then go back at a slightly wider angle and put a 600 grit microbevel on. It’s not visibly toothy but it sure as hell bites!
I generally sharpen to a 600 or 1200 grit diamond followed by a strop for GP cutlery -- including scissors.
woodworking tools get a little more attention paid to the polishing/stropping, which lets me minimize sanding/scraping.
kitchen knives mostly get hit with a cheap 3/8" white crock stick or a smooth steel.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.