Too Many Knives???

not2sharp

Platinum Member
Joined
Jun 29, 1999
Messages
20,794
What did you do when you first realized that you had accumulated more knives then you could possibly use in a lifetime, or even a dozen lifetimes, and how did that change the direction of your interests in knives? To be fair, there are plenty of outdoor's men out there who have manage to spend a lifetime hunting, fishing, hiking and camping with just a single simple knife.

n2s
 
Last edited:
I sell them and throw money at another hobby for a while, then I buy more knives later on. Then I buy more guns, then bicycle stuff, then camera equipment, then ammo, then...
 
I haven't been into knives for very long, roughly around 4 months and I saw how easily one can go overboard. I ended up selling the knives I don't really care for, and kept the ones that are absolutely keepers. Even then I still have 6 folders and 5 fixed blades.

I think it's pretty easy to become a "hoarder" when it comes to knives where people buy them just to buy them. I found a good solution to my problem... I set some criterias for myself: Must be high end, must be rare, I can see it being a keeper. That has kept me from making impulsive/pointless knife purchases. Some people like having 100+ cheap knives.... but WHY? To each their own.
 
I know that I have much more knives, SAKs and multitools than I will ever need. To be honest, there are only a few knives, SAKs and multitools that are in my EDC / hiking / camping rotation. Most of them are only used a couple of times after I bought them and will then probably never see use anymore and have become collection items or will be sold, but that won't stop me from buying more gear. I can still live with that.
 
Having more knives than you need just means that you can start being more picky about the knives you buy.
 
I just kept buying more:thumbup:. But if I do happen to find a custom that meets my every need and desire, I'll sell the rest and buy a handheld spotlight or something:D.
 
Too many knives. I had that problem, then I bought a bigger storage container! aha!

Honestly though, I started trading or selling the ones I didn't want or use. I'm down to just the few folders that I actually carry and use. The ones I'm not afraid to break or lose. And as far as fixed blades go, I'm trying to find the perfect working assortment. I have plenty of Machetes, several good smallish fixed blades, a good saw and hatchet, tomahawks for throwing. I don't need/use an axe. For some reason I have a bunch of fighting knives........................ :D
 
I sold the least liked and consolidated the money into a handful of even more expensive knives.

Wash rinse repeat. In a decade I'll be selling off my most disliked randalls so I can consolidate into.... well, what comes after Randall? You know, those $20,000 knives.
 
I have much more knives then I could use in a lifetime, I also have much more books then I could read in a lifetime, but I'm still buying both of them.
 
I haven't hit the "more than I could use in a lifetime" mark, but I can see it from here :)

I'm actually struggling a little bit right now with the urge to buy stuff I don't need and wouldn't be able to use. For example, KA-BAR makes a great looking fighting bowie... but I highly doubt there's any knife-fighting in my future. Oh oops and I already have a Becker BK-10, which is a fighting knife. So I'm attempting to have some discipline and not buy the KA-BAR bowie. There are other examples.

Realistically, I could pare my collection (which isn't that big, relatively speaking... trying to catch myself early) down to five knives and my tomahawk. I do a lot of outdoor-type stuff now, intend to do more, so my gear does get used.

I think the answer is to put your thinking cap on, decide what's right for you, then hawk whatever you have that you don't want or can't use... which might mean you don't hawk anything :)
 
Having decided that the best knife for a particular job is the one you actually have to hand when it's needed, I started distributing my collection around various locations. So now I have an emergency bag in the car with a Mora, a machete, an axe and firelighting materials. I have a Spydie Grasshopper, a small kitchen knife and a butter knife in my desk at work. I have my knife collection in boxes and bags at home, and then I have some general users scattered around the house and toolshed. I then realised that, far from having too many knives, I actually didn't have enough knives in the right places. So I bought some more.....
 
Too many knives ? :confused:

What did you do when you first realized that you had accumulated more knives then you could possibly use in a lifetime, or even a dozen lifetimes, and how did that change the direction of your interests in knives? To be fair, there are plenty of outdoor's men out there who have manage to spend a lifetime hunting, fishing, hiking and camping with just a single simple knife.

n2s
 
I'm on a self-imposed 'knife-free' diet until the end of the year. I recently found several knives that I am very happy with and acquired a custom that I had long wanted. So I figured it was time to kick back a bit. There are very few knives I still lust after that I can actually afford. Plenty that I cant afford haha.

I havent been able to stop spending though, the money is just going on stuff other than knives... generally speaking though, knives are usually far and away my most expensive purchases.
 
Once my accumulation got up around 500 knives i decided to open a little brick and mortar shop, well in my case wood and mails, but you get the point. I converted an old barn into a knife shop, put up a few signs and am just having fun swapping tails, trading and selling to the local sportsman. I plan on adding a few things like reloading supplies, decoys, traps and such to my inventory. Should be a fun venture, and hopefully supplement my retirement income.
 
I don't know the type of outdoors men you know, but I'm 41 been hunting, fishing and spending as much time as possible out of doors pursuing those past times since I was 9. I wish I could count at how many knives have been lost, stolen, damaged or rusted out. Most everybody I hunt and fish with the same, knives have a way of dissappearing in the mud, muck, water and woods. when a knife is being used to re work a busted raditor house on a mud boat stuck in a ditch in the marsh and it gets bumped by the dog or someone else in the boat, your not finding it. Same thing goes for the cut away knife that usually rides up on the bow so you can cut yourself free from a rig when off shore in case the weather picks up or the rig siren sounds. Moreover your not undoing the cut away knife as you hop from rig to rig all day, so the stainless clip that you use to hold it to the bow rail usually rust out and whamo teh knife goes overboard. I can't tell you how many tips I've snapped while putting in, taking down or moving deer stands and sorry with everything else I carry I'm not carry pry bars and screw drivers, get real.

So that thing about outdoors men going their whole career with one simple knife, then their not doing much hunting or fishing or their not doing it in brackish marsh, swamp, palmetto hardwood bottom or off shore, sorry but their not. I've literally had my bacon saved by a knife on at least 2 occasions that I can vividly remember.

Lastly what if the balloon goes up, no really, the economy collapses for whatever reason, we have a nuclear, chemical or bilogical attack here in con us? Knife companies go under, you go broke, you don't have the money to run down to walmart and buy another one, etc. Your forced to start living off your yard, growing goats, a garden and chickens, ducks, or other fowl. You have to start basically a small urban farm. Your going to NEED knives and the knives you have are going to start really getting used. Think one is going to last you? What if you have a theft, loss, breakage, damaged, etc. Think you may want to have some back ups, what if you have kids and a wife there going need a knife or knives as well.

Do you have one flashlight at the house, what about in your vehicle have one there? I've got extra of everything and buy lots of things in the same make and model so if they all break I can cannibalize them for parts and probably put together a few working pieces. Sorry to vehemently disagree with the OP but I think if your operating in todays society under the misconception that things like a good folding and or fixed blade is aren't really needed or one only needs one to last their entire lifetime is sadly mistaken and really flying by the seat of their pants and hoping that everything is going work itself out.

I was a boy scout so I believe in being prepared, that it is better to have it and not need it then need it and not have it and ultimately that 2 is 1 and 1 is NONE.

To all those here that feel as though they have too many knives, flash lights, tools, etc. please contact me and make arrangements for me to take those UNNEEDED items off of your hands and put them to good use.
 
Back
Top