Use or ‘Baby’ a brand new knife that might be sold?

nbp

Gold Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2016
Messages
650
Sometimes when trying a new (and especially when expensive) knife that I’m not sure I am going to like enough to keep longterm, I tend to baby it, perhaps just fondling and examining it at home for a bit, with the hopes that if I decide I don’t love it I can sell it and recoup (most of) my money. I don’t do shelf queens, so either I keep it and use it, or I will sell it. However, sometimes I have decided to sell it as it isn’t really for me, but then I am surprised how much value the knife has “lost” despite being essentially brand new. Then I think, well if it is going to lose a quarter or more of its value while still in pristine condition, I should have just used it for real and not worried about marks or scuffs. What was the point of keeping it like new in the examination phase?

How do you approach this situation? I know there will always be some value lost in buying something preowned but sometimes the expected markdown on a Like New item seems a bit unrealistic.
 
I buy knives I like. I haven't sold or traded since I relocated away from a great knife club - 18 years back. They move in and can never leave till I do! Hotel California.
Yea, I've sold most of the ones that aren't around for the long haul. The rest I trade towards something I know I'll like or I give away to friends and family.
 
Can't know if you like a knife or not until you use it.
This.
There's no way to know how well the knife is designed until you use it.
You can ooo and AAHH about lockup and fit and finish. But you need to use it to see how well it really works. That also means you need to put your own edge on it.

Note: I don't sell my knives.
 
Can't know if you like a knife or not until you use it.
I certainly take your point, but sometimes you just know. It looked great in pics and videos but you get it and the way the handle fits your hand, the lock style, the clip placement, the size, the weight, the whatever… it isn’t right. This is a community that obsesses over the minutiae - it is inevitable that some knives you will know quickly are not going to make it into rotation. Some apparently decide to keep every knife, even if it isn’t going to be used, but that isn’t me.
 
I certainly take your point, but sometimes you just know. It looked great in pics and videos but you get it and the way the handle fits your hand, the lock style, the clip placement, the size, the weight, the whatever… it isn’t right. This is a community that obsesses over the minutiae - it is inevitable that some knives you will know quickly are not going to make it into rotation. Some apparently decide to keep every knife, even if it isn’t going to be used, but that isn’t me.
We are saying the same thing.
 
Fun (and possibly not relevant) anecdote: I only have one knife I can never part with, and it’s because I promised my wife I won’t sell it. I have a habit of sabotaging myself (believing I don’t deserve nice things), and she’s much smarter than me, so we made a pact.

My wife is a foot shorter than me and possibly one-third my weight, but I’m scared if I break that pact, she’ll break me.
 
Fun (and possibly not relevant) anecdote: I only have one knife I can never part with, and it’s because I promised my wife I won’t sell it. I have a habit of sabotaging myself (believing I don’t deserve nice things), and she’s much smarter than me, so we made a pact.

My wife is a foot shorter than me and possibly one-third my weight, but I’m scared if I break that pact, she’ll break me.
Even at a foot shorter, that still makes her taller than most guys here. I'd tread lightly as well buddy!
 
Back
Top