Utah hiker stranded with broken leg for four nights

Joined
Apr 3, 2010
Messages
317
I've seen this type of story posted here in the past and we always learn something from them. She survived, barely, so it's a good ending. But I think a basic kit would have made this a very different experience.


http://www.nrtoday.com/article/20120429/APA/1204290819

A hiker who endured four days with a broken leg and no food and shelter in the remote southern Utah high desert says her faith and medical background helped her pull through the ordeal.

Victoria Grover, 59, a physician assistant from Wade, Maine, was recovering in a Utah hospital after being rescued Saturday in a rugged section of Dixie National Forest, north of the town of Escalante.

Grover set out on a short day hike Tuesday from Hell's Backbone Road, and broke her leg on the return hike while jumping off a 4-foot ledge about two miles from the trailhead. She then holed up along a creek at an elevation of about 4,500 feet.

"I prayed a lot and derived comfort from it," the Mormon church member told reporters on Sunday. "I thought God would do everything possible to help me overcome my stupidity. I learned from my mother that things can always be worse."

Grover said while she experienced hunger and severe pain, the worst part of the ordeal was the boredom and freezing nighttime temperatures she confronted.

The veteran outdoor enthusiast survived by sleeping in shade during the day and staying awake while curled up in a poncho at night. The poncho helped save her life by serving as a wind breaker, she said, adding it was the only extra warm clothing she carried.

"The hunger is something that comes in waves. You get hungry and want to eat everything and then it goes away," Grover said. "The worst thing is the cold. It never warmed up except for a few hours in the afternoon."

By the final day, she was suffering from hypothermia after shivering uncontrollably for several days.

"The last night I stopped shivering and that's one of the early signs of hypothermia. The last night was the worst," Grover said.

A cold front pushed overnight temperatures to the low to mid 30s throughout most of her ordeal, said Mike Ahlstrom, a member of the Garfield County sheriff's search and rescue team. Daytime highs were in the 50s and low 60s.

A backpacker died of hypothermia in the same area after becoming stranded two years ago, Ahlstrom said.

"What a relief and how excited we were to find her alive," he told The Associated Press. "She was in amazing condition for spending four days without food."

Authorities were able to locate her through a rental car agreement found in her room at a guest ranch where she was staying. The establishment notified the sheriff's office when she failed to check out Thursday as scheduled. Grover didn't leave an itinerary of her hike behind.

While Grover had only intended to do about a six-mile roundtrip hike, Ahlstrom said, it was challenging because it was on an unmarked, unmaintained trail over rugged terrain featuring slot canyons and pine- and juniper-covered ridges.

Ironically, Grover was revisiting country she first saw while taking a Brigham Young University survival course 40 years ago. "I knew what I had to do to survive," she said, because of her outdoors and medical experience.

But the boredom was "incredible," and she played mind games and recited poetry to help pass the time until rescuers arrived.

Dr. Daniel Allen said he expects her to make a full recovery after she underwent surgery Saturday at Valley View Medical Center in Cedar City.

"I'm sure she'll be hiking again," Allen said, adding the fact she has diabetes had no impact whatsoever on her blood sugar or accident.

She finally enjoyed her first meal Saturday night.

"Before that, I was dreaming of oranges, which is one of my favorite foods," she said. "But there are people who can go for weeks and weeks without food in this world. We have it easy in America."
 
Grover didn't leave an itinerary of her hike --------------

That is something I'll wager she never does again

She is lucky
 
"The last night I stopped shivering and that's one of the early signs of hypothermia. The last night was the worst," Grover said.
Lesson one: Shivering is the first sign of hypothermia. Lesson two: You can't always count on medical professionals in a first responder role. My buddy and I have both experienced medical professionals(nurses and doctors) drop the ball on even the most basic of things like controlling shock.
 
Lesson one: Shivering is the first sign of hypothermia...

Wrong. When shivering stops without warmth it is the first sign of hypothermia. Shivering is a body's natural defense against core temperature drop. People who are cold but not hypothermic shiver.
 
I love hiking and backpacking in the remote areas of Utah and I did a good amount of it before I was married. I've been on at least 2 trails that I didn't complete because I thought there was too much risk of falling and injuring something. In one situation I was backpacking down a small canyon to the shore of Lake Powell, intending to spend the night there and hike back the next day. I came to a big chokestone in the canyon and resulting pouroff and decided it was too risky to try to jump down from there or climb the cliffs and go around it so I went back to my car and went on to somewhere else.

Like I said this was over 15 years ago and I was single so I didn't worry so much about myself. If I did that nowadays I would consider even carrying a sat phone with me.
 
Wrong. When shivering stops without warmth it is the first sign of hypothermia. Shivering is a body's natural defense against core temperature drop. People who are cold but not hypothermic shiver.

Ignoring my SAR training even a quick google search shows that shivering is the first sign. Whatever you want to call it, when you start to shiver you're on your way.
 
Soooo, she had taken a survival course in the same area once, but didn't have any fire making tools on her at all.:confused:

Faith in God is a fine thing, but on a cold night with a broken leg, I'd prefer a nice fire kit. At least a Bic lighter.
 
A dilemma! With a broken leg on a cold night, should she use that wood for a splint and a crutch, or build a fire ...

Yes, she should have had a bit more kit, it doesn't weigh all that much to add a sweater, rations, fire starters. I'm glad she did so well.
 
Ignoring my SAR training even a quick google search shows that shivering is the first sign. Whatever you want to call it, when you start to shiver you're on your way.

Yea, I think you're right, the state of hypothermia is just losing body heat faster than you can replace it, people suffer from initial stages of hypothermia far more often than they likely realize. I think the shivering stops in the late stages of hypothermia; that's when you know you're in trouble. If anyone wants to modify or add to my post though, feel free to do so.
 
I'm guessing she was also drinking untreated water from the creek. That could have really turned on her in four days, so lucky again?

I'm going to add one of those space blankets that weigh nothing to my pack after reading this.
 
She shouldn't have jumped off of a 4' height. I jumped off of a probably 2' diameter spruce tree I had to climb over about 2 years ago and tore something that gave me foot pain for nearly a year.
 
She shouldn't have jumped off of a 4' height. I jumped off of a probably 2' diameter spruce tree I had to climb over about 2 years ago and tore something that gave me foot pain for nearly a year.

Could this be the "Bear Grylls factor?" :D I thought the same thing when I read it. Who jumps off a 4' ledge, alone, in the middle of nowhere, without telling someone where you're going? Glad she's okay though.
 
Yeah Shotgun I'm usually extra careful when I'm alone. Also like you say I usually give an itenary and approx time of return.

A while back I went on a solo hike. I decided to go back a difft way than I told my wife before I left. So I left a note in the shelter just in case.

When a bunch of us returned there a year later the note was still there. Was shocked nobody had used it as a fire starter.
 
This comports with what I have been taught.

Stage 1
Body temperature drops by 1-2°C (1.8-3.6°F) below normal temperature (35-37°C or 95-98.6°F). Mild to strong shivering occurs.[1][2] The victim is unable to perform complex tasks with the hands; the hands become numb. Blood vessels in the outer extremities constrict, lessening heat loss to the outside air. Breathing becomes quick and shallow. Goose bumps form, raising body hair on end in an attempt to create an insulating layer of air around the body (which is of limited use in humans due to lack of sufficient hair, but useful in other species). Victim may feel sick to their stomach, and very tired. Often, a person will experience a warm sensation, as if they have recovered, but they are in fact heading into Stage 2. Another test to see if the person is entering stage 2 is if they are unable to touch their thumb with their little finger; this is the first stage of muscles not working. They might start to have trouble seeing.
 
What a nightmare. Glad she made it though!

It's so important to be prepared for medical emergencies in the wilderness and unfortunately, many people are not. I recently read Medicine for The Outdoors, it's a handbook filled with everything you could possibly need to know about medical emergencies in the outdoors. I definitely recommend that anyone who camps and hikes reads this book--even pack it with you.
 
Back
Top