Go with the 1095 if that is whats in the damascus. Makes for a much easier weld. Weld like materials if possible.
If you have access to a TIG or MIG outfit, the job will go a lot easier. You can burn the tang up in a hurry using a stick machine.
Make a keyed splice. Put the male end on the blade side and the female on the tang extension. Cut the male end first. Scribe that on the extension and file to fit.
I cut the female side of the splice with a right angle grinder, then finish out with files.
Take the time to produce a tight joint. If you do, you can clamp the blade in a vise, attach the tang, it should fit snug, put a tack bead at the top, turn the blade over and tack the joint at the bottom. You can now lay the piece on a ground and tig one side then the other. You can make a joint you can't see, using this technique.
good luck, Fred