Went to the cutlery shop today...

Joined
Jan 23, 2011
Messages
4,399
...to check out some slippies. It was my first visit to this shop, and I should have anticipated my disappointment. It was filled with tacticool stuff. There were a few from Case, Boker and Bear & Son. It was my firsthand look at the Case peanut and mini copperhead. Those guys are tiny! My 91mm SAK is a giant compared to these. I was considering a peanut or buck 309 as an EDC, but this has given me pause.

I think a good traditional slip joint is more robustly built than an SAK (brass vs aluminum liners, bolstered vs. un-bolstered), so I will still get one. I have a 4 blade congress from Camillus from when I was a kid, but it's got too many blades for me.
 
You have my deepest sympathies. I can only imagine what it would be like to visit a cutlery shop and not find anything you like. Very disappointing.

Did you see something that you might go back and get?
 
Nah, I was largely being ignored. Shop owners were talking about football with one of their "regular" customers. Actually, I was trying not to buy stuff, so that was OK. I'm not working, on a tight budget.

I just took a picture of a 309, scaled it using GIMP to 3" length, and now it looks actual size. I compared it to my other knives (Vic classic, Tinker, Cam congress) and I have a good idea of the size.
 
Hi,

That's unfortunate that this shop doesn't carry much to interest you. But at least they have something if they have few Case or Bokers on the shelf. Even a bear or two is OK.

And don't sell them little Peanuts short, they cut way above their size!:D Did they have anything nice in Stockman or Trapper?

Dale
 
I'm sure they had a stockman or two; some knives were folded up. These were the $80+ models with the fancy scales, so it was above my pay scale. I dunno, I didn't get a great vibe in the shop. Most people go there to get their knives sharpened, otherwise you know the owners. I'm not a great for chit chat, so I saw what I needed to see, and moved on.
 
Most of the times I've gone into a cutlery shop, I've been disappointed with both the selection and inattention of the staff/owners. Sorry to hear that your experience was roughly the same.

Edited to add that I left you a visitor message.
 
JC, I left you a VM in response. Thanks.

BTW, my intent was not to speak poorly of the shop. It was nice to see the actual knives. Nothing online can give you that. I think shop owners don't want to be too pushy, but a little "let me know if you need some help" would have been nice.
 
Last edited:
That's sad. Our only knife store here in San Antonio are the same way. You would think a city with a metropolitan area of almost 1.3 million could do better than 1 store, but nope. And it isn't even a dedicated cutlery shop as it is 3/4 guns and 1/4 knives. They get a fine old collection in on consignment on occasion, but the prices are so high they are ridiculous. They have one person that is knowledgeable about cutlery, but all the others would much rather be playing with the guns and gear. Some knives are pretty nice, but paying full suggested retail for a new knife, or retail plus is a bit silly to me.

Every once in a while a new store will open in a mall and it specializes in mall ninja gear like throwing stars, martial arts type knives, and Klingon battle gear. They do the Pacific Rim proud.

My best bet here when I want to see knives in person is the gun shows. Used and new, most are priced higher than they should be, but usually not by much. I will pay a bit more to get what I want and something I can put my hands on. I can go there and if both my favorite guys are there I can look at a couple of thousand knives. Most don't hold any interest, but at the last show I found an old Kabar Barlow that was in like new shape, and I was really pleased to get it.

Boy how I yearn for the days when I went to the old hardware store and worked my way though the display cases to get the best knives. My favorite old hardware store started with Sabre (considered Japanese junk!) but they were really affordable. They wobbled between Sabre and the old, old Imperial line that had plastic scales and stamped hollow bolsters. Then with a bit more cash, you moved to the Schrade case. Nice knives, but not the top of the hill. Then the largest walnut display had a light shining over the glass front with gold leaf writing: CASE.

These were knives I had to save to buy, but worth every penny. Everyone knew you couldn't go wrong with CASE. But still, not the lofty atmosphere of the top of the hill.

That was reserved for PUMA. These knives came all the way from Europe, made by ancient craftsmen toiling away at old dim lit workbenches that fitted and finished until these knives were perfect. They were made from and exotic steel noted as "Solingen Cutlery Steel" on the blade itself. All their knives had stag handles. All their knives were ground a little more flat to make them better cutters. All of them had different blade shapes that defined their European heritage. And all of them were EXPENSIVE.

Sadly I was never able to afford any of them, but I always started at that display before going over to the CASE display. I was lucky enough to find a "knife guy" in the store that would let a kid handle and look at all the knives I wanted when I was a kid.

Boy I miss those days.

OTOH, there are a few great vendors that frequent here and are approved/member vendors on Bladeforums. I have used a few, and all have been no less than great. A couple have excellent selections of traditional steels, styles, and makers. If you can scale off the knives you are looking at to get an idea of size (as in your hand when comparing to another knife that size), you might want to give them a try. I found my favorite guy right here on this forum.

Robert
 
Last edited:
...to check out some slippies. It was my first visit to this shop, and I should have anticipated my disappointment. It was filled with tacticool stuff. There were a few from Case, Boker and Bear & Son. It was my firsthand look at the Case peanut and mini copperhead. Those guys are tiny! My 91mm SAK is a giant compared to these. I was considering a peanut or buck 309 as an EDC, but this has given me pause.


Don't let the small size of the mini copperhead, peanut, and Buck 309 fool you. They will slice open a UPS box or plastic blister package as neat as you like. But until you need a knife, they vanish in a pocket like they're not even there.

Carl.
 
i went into the gp knives store in Illinois. It was great. As far as traditional goes, they had case, queen, buck, GEC and more. very neat, organized, and professional store. as far as your own experience goes.. I think the benchmades and spydercos are the money makers, not the case pocket knives.. even though though i would prefer a case knife over a tacticool folder anyday.
 
look for the reason why you want a traditional slipjoint. I live in the 14th largest city in the country and I suffer the same. There is no traditional slipjoint to be bought here and that's just fine with me. We are different and that's great! There are great slipjoint retailers here on BF. Check them out! Don't be discouraged. Local gun and knife shows may give you an opportunity to handle a few and find a good dealer here on BF!
 
Back
Top