Wharncliffe Vs. Other Edge Geometry

Joined
Apr 22, 2005
Messages
238
I know there is probably already a thread like this around, but since I can no longer search on the forums, I figured this would be the next best thing. I was wondering what advantages and disadvantages a wharncliffe blade would have over other styles such as clip and tanto .The only good article I have found was one written by Michael Janich a while ago. What does the Wharncliffe do well? I have heard they are good utility knives and I can see why,but I also see a lot of them being offered as self defense knives and "tactical" knives. Any information is greatly appreciated guys.Thanks.
 
My EDC is a wharncliffe copperlock Case knife. To me it is the perfect blade shape for many reasons. you can use just the tip for fine work. Also if you are cutting a wrapper off of something the back of the blades just slides nicely along and lifts the wrapper as it cuts. It can be used to scrape flat surfaces. They are easy to sharpen.
pic0079ox3.jpg
 
What does the Wharncliffe do well? I have heard they are good utility knives and I can see why,but I also see a lot of them being offered as self defense knives and "tactical" knives. Any information is greatly appreciated guys.Thanks.

I would turn it around slightly, and ask, what doesn't a Wharncliffe do well? And in answer to that, I would primarily say skinning. And it's a lousy shape for a chef's knife or butcher knife. ;-)

As a general purpose or utility blade pattern, I love it. It's probably my favorite overall blade shape because it works so well for the kinds of things I do on a daily basis. In addition to that, it's straight edge makes it easier to sharpen.

Personally, I haven't noticed all that many of them marketed for self defense of "tactical" use, but in all fairness, I'm not a big fan of most knives in that market, so I don't go looking at them much. I would actually think a wharncliffe blade would be rather sub-optimal for SD, though. A wharncliffe makes a poor slashing weapon. It will make fairly shallow slashes, as compared with a knife with more belly. If I had to pick one shape I most associate with self defense and tactical knives, I'd say it's the american tanto (not a big fan of them).

Another place where wharncliffe's are very useful, and very traditional, is for whittling. The flat blade and sharp point allow for excellent detail work. The traditional "whittler" slipjoint pattern generally has a wharncliffe for the main blade. I also have a couple of little custom swood carving knives from Harold Woods that are wharncliffes. Wonderful little knives.
 
Michael Janich says a Warnie is the best slashing shape for a SD knife.

A Yojimbo, Ronin, straight edge razors, a box cutter/utility knife, and warnie Hide Away Knife, and many more all excell at slashing. I think it has something to do with the pounds per inch a warnie puts at the tip of the blade. A blade with a belly has more edge to lessen the pound per inch at the edge.

But, I'm no expert by any means.
 
I keep trying out new knives because none of my Wharnies have opening and locking mechanisms that I like. After a few days of futzing with the other blade shapes I somehow wind up back with a Wharnie in my pocket. I think I need to save up for a custom that'll include everything I'm looking for -- Wharncliffe blade under 3", Axis type lock, thin handle and profile, and very clean lines.
 
Does anyone currently make wharncliff folders like the case copperlock in wudnme's post? Very useful and very elegant.
 
Check the makers section and look at folders for sale. Their are a few guys who make really nice pieces!
 
I wholly recommend the Spyderco Centofante IV as an EDC. Here is a pic of mine in the bush (with a double headed hatchet, and Queen Canoe in D2):
IMG_0156-1.jpg


And a pic of it alone:
Centofante4Open.jpg

With the "poor man's wave" it is a very fast opener and the thin edge cuts very well with little resistance.

Here are a couple more Wharnies I own:
WharncomOpen.jpg

LeekDamascusOpen.jpg

TrapperOpen.jpg

WhittlerOpen.jpg

IMG_0169.jpg



I like them a bit!
 
I've gotta give my full agreement on this one. My Spyderco Centofante 4 is one of my absolute favorite knives. Solid, slick, pretty, and extremely useful. Ever since I picked it up, I find it ending up in my pocket regularly, now matter what new toys I pick up.

I love that second piece from the bottom, too. That's a neat little knife.
 
Back
Top