What does banning really do, anyway?

Well, maybe.... Whether The_BillyTran is the same Billy Tran who was banned or not, though, he is not currently doing anything to get himself banned again -- just making appropriate posts in the Whine & Cheese forum (appropriate for that forum, that is -- and the posts that got the original Billy Tran banned would not have been objected to if they'd been posted in that forum).

There are others like that, people who've been banned and come back later and behaved themselves and they're not a problem any more. There are others who've come back after being banned and continued to be a problem. Every forum on the net has trolls from time to time and sometimes you have to complain to their ISP and get their account closed, and sometimes you have to do that more than once; some are so stupid they come back again after they get a new ISP and insist on getting that account yanked too. Have you heard the riddle, "What's the difference between Spamford Wallace and Saddam Hussein? Saddam Hussein has an internet account."
 
I was not aware ISPs would cancel accounts due to the complaints of third parties over matters of decorum. I can certainly understand it if people are communicating threats or committing other illegal activities but was unaware that AOL, ATT etc would give up revenue over someone being a pest or obnoxious.

While I am certainly not condoning the rather simpleminded and moronic posting going on right now, I would be shocked to learn that big mercenary corporations would give up one buck of revenue because someone was acting like an imbecile. Just curious.....do ISPs really care about trolling?
 
i dont think they will stop your service unless your threatening, etc - after all you have your rights of freedom of speech, etc - i would have to hear it from AOL/etc before i would believe they would -i dont agree w/it either, but i dont hink any one is gonna lose an ISP over this (ie cussing etc)i mean really, who cares what the jack ass says, i still dont understand what torqued him off so - i must be missing something...and ya never know, he might be some 17 yr old hacker and were all gonna get viruses lol - maybe thats why sparks PC bombed???

sifu
 
Well, he wouldn't lose his account for posting one troll or spam, but yes, ISPs have to stop their customers from persistent abuse or they'll get the IDP (Internet Death Penalty). Anarchy works! No system administrator can be forced to accept messages from a spam haven or any ISP that isn't cooperative about dealing with abusers. Giant corporations have much more to lose than small local ISPs and they are not all interested in risking getting their entire clientele barred from the net (or even small parts of the net) to protect the "rights" of one spammer or troll. They could lose a lot more than the $20 a month they get from him....

The usual procedure is to send an email to the sysadmin, who will issue a warning on the first complaint -- if it's a forum like this one (or an irc channel or a usenet group) he'll just tell the troll not to post there any more or he'll lose his account. That's usually sufficient, but if the troll persists he'll lose his account there, or if the sysadmin is uncooperative his whole ISP will have to be banned from Bladeforums. I don't think we've ever had to do that here, but it happens. That would mean any customers of that ISP that want to go to Bladeforums and no doubt other parts of the net too will have to change ISPs -- getting banned from Bladeforums alone probably wouldn't lose an ISP much business, but when a sysadmin tolerates abusers they get the system banned from one part of the net after another.... Spam havens can make money for a while because they charge the spammers a lot more than $20 a month, but they soon find they can't even get a local connection so they don't have any net access at all.

Occasionally there's a problem because you can't get hold of a sysadmin right away. I once had to ban an entire large university from an IRC channel for two days before the sysadmin finally responded and dealt with the problem -- just one troll, but she got all her friends to let her use their accounts and/or jump into the flame war on her behalf and every time I banned her she'd pop up with a new identity every few minutes. Fortunately we didn't have any other regulars from that university.... Then she moved to accounts at another college nearby (apparently she had friends there too) but I got hold of the sysadmin there right away and that was the end of that.

Take a look at the "Terms of Use" at your ISP....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top