what is a tactical knife?

Joined
Jun 3, 2012
Messages
1,118
I see a bunch of threads like "what are some good tactical knives?"

My question is what exactly is a tactical knife? Can't almost any knife be used in a tactical situation if needed? Obviously I'm not talking about butter knives here, but can't you use anything from a little Case knife, to a skinner, to a Cold Steel Espada XL, and even a SY 1311 in a tactical application?
 
all you'll be getting are 'expert' opinions. mine is "a knife with several desirable features as dictated by one's role."
 
It's been brought up before many times. It's a buzzword that has been used to an extent that it is next to meaningless now.

Newbies seem to often use it in the mall ninja sense, and it doesn't get used often by anyone on the forum for a longer duration.
 
A tactical knife is a totally black knife, with a partially serrated edge. Basically it is blacked out, so the victim cannot see which way the blade is coming at him/her at night. It is plain edge to start with to make a nice piercing cut and the serrations take care of the vital organs like a chainsaw. It must be tactically employed in all situations it is used. Whether it be stabbing someone or cutting string. The draw must be fast, smooth, and achieve maximum scariness.
 
a tactical knife is a totally black knife, with a partially serrated edge. Basically it is blacked out, so the victim cannot see which way the blade is coming at him/her at night. It is plain edge to start with to make a nice piercing cut and the serrations take care of the vital organs like a chainsaw. It must be tactically employed in all situations it is used. Whether it be stabbing someone or cutting string. The draw must be fast, smooth, and achieve maximum scariness.

lmfao!!!!!
 
A overused marketing term to make niave buyers feel like Rambo when they carry it.
 
For examples of this, please refer the Cold Steel web site or Busse subforum :)
 
A overused marketing term to make niave buyers feel like Rambo when they carry it.

True, but you can still use it on the forums in a mature way. For example I'd define a "tactical" knife as:

One handed opening (if a folder)
Made with micarta/G10/metal handles, no wood
Solid/beefy (not a gentlemans folder/buck)

Basically some of the more modern designs. No traditionals, no SAKs. Yes, mall ninjas give the word a bad name, and the advertising is way overboard from some companies. But tactical can mean anything from a Sebenza to a Cold Steel to an XM-24.
 
True, but you can still use it on the forums in a mature way. For example I'd define a "tactical" knife as:

One handed opening (if a folder)
Made with micarta/G10/metal handles, no wood
Solid/beefy (not a gentlemans folder/buck)

Basically some of the more modern designs. No traditionals, no SAKs. Yes, mall ninjas give the word a bad name, and the advertising is way overboard from some companies. But tactical can mean anything from a Sebenza to a Cold Steel to an XM-24.


Native Americans fighting the good old USA would aggue about what makes tactical. Romans, Celtics, and even US fighters would laugh at such a definition.
 
-One-handed opening
-Fast deployment
-Larger-sized blade
-Synthetic handle material
-Pocket clip
-Toughness and durability
-Grippy handle
 
I guess I think of it as more of an aesthetic term than anything meaningful about the design. The Spyderco Military is the example that I always think of. It was purpose designed as a duty knife, I never really think of it as a tactical knife because of the polished blade, slim profile and overall design cues. The Benchmade Adamas is also a duty knife, but with the thick blacked out blade, beefy handle and (subjectively) aggressive looks I definitely think of it as a tactical blade. I can't precisely define which features make me think 'tactical' but it's not a term I think about for use, only for looks.
 
most of this i got from mr. kevin maclung of mad dog knives:

1. blade must be rust-resistant
2. must be easy to sharpen, clean, and sterilize on the field; whether for food prep or emergency surgery.
3. blade long enough to reach vitals in the torso.
4. slim enough to reach vitals in the head and neck
5. sharp enough to inflict a wide gash during a slash.
6. strong enough for heavy use (rope cutting, camp use, woodcrafting, etc.)
7. ergonomic grip that ensures hand safety during hard/sudden use.
8. handle must fully insulate the user's bare hand when cutting live wires
9. handle and sheath should be resistant to (most) corrosive substances and heat.
***
 
Number 8 in Hank's list rules out all full tang fixed blades and an awful lot of folders. Metal assembly screws through metal liners will provide a conductive path to the blade.
 
As mentioned, the term tactical is thrown around a lot as synonymous with modern as seen in the above example by corwise. However I believe that definition of tactical is incorrect. Tactical knives are knives meant for fighting or self defense. Take Emersons for example. Emerson designed those knives first and foremost as weapons. They are designed to slash and stab when needed as a backup weapon or even a backup to your backup. Sure, they can be used for utility tasks, but that's not their purpose and there are usually better tools for the job. The spyderco civilian is another perfect example of a tactical knife, it is meant to slash huge gashes in anything it touches and that's about it.

On the flip side you have companies like strider who's knives are often referred to as tactical but where really designed strictly for utility and would truthfully make a quite poor fighting knife. Hinderers designs are another example of this. Hinderer designs knives as tools first, not weapons, yet the Hinderer knives and Hinderer designed Zt's are many times referred to as tactical.

Now on the far end of the spectrum is tacticool, which is the trend that gives modern knives a bad name in my opinion. Mall ninjas and keyboard commandos love these knives, they're big, black, jagged, over designed aggressive looking knives that are usually opened and used in such a fashion that scares the bejesus out of just about everyone around them. In reality the problem is the owners but the owner's choice in knives typically gives other knives with similar features a bad name.

So, in short, the only knives that are actually tactical knives are the ones whose sole purpose is to be used as a weapon or as self defense.
 
I employ buttery tactics 101 each morning with my toast.

Butter knife, it's tactical.
 
Tactical = tactile. Tactile, here, means easy to manipulate. If you can pierce armor and dig a hole with it unscathed, studies show it gives male owners boners as well, so that's been thrown into the mix, and is now standard equip. (however not a defining aspect).
 
Tactical is LEO/military practical. G10 or other high traction handle material, as opposed to wood or bone. Thumbstuds, plate, hole, or flipper nub as opposed to a nail nick. Blades generally 1/8" or thicker for "hard use" whereas traditionals tend to be much thinner.
 
Native Americans fighting the good old USA would aggue about what makes tactical. Romans, Celtics, and even US fighters would laugh at such a definition.

Every historical group you mentioned leapt at the chance to upgrade to better weapon/tool designs and materials, every chance they got. I'm quite certain they would have happily traded in their stone/flint/bronze for what we would consider "mediocre" steel, given a choice - oh wait... they did! :)

I only know a handful of US combat vets from the last decade or so, but every one of them carried either a folder very much as corwise described, or a multi-tool - or both. Fixed blades with 4-5" blades seem third in popularity among active troops, and anything larger than a K-bar/USMC pattern is relatively rare.
 
Back
Top