This is all such a matter of personal preference I can only offer my own experience and opinion. Years ago I bought a Supertool and found it almost ideal. It's only drawbacks were an awkward blade closing procedure, the plier handle edges would dig into the hand when cranking down hard on something and no scissors. The blade closing I got used to, a Micra served for scissors, and a folded handkerchief in the palm worked to pad the handle for those hard use times.
What I like most was the selection of locking tools, robust constructiion and bulletproof simplicity. At 9 ounces it was hardly noticeable on the belt, although not comfortable in the pocket. Actually, I think most Leathermen carry better by belt. For example, despite its smaller size and 5 ounce weight, I prefered belt carry for my PST because there are sharp edges that could abrade pockets. OTOH, my son will carry his in pocket only.
That ST/Micra combo served so well that I was not interested in the ST 200 when it was introduced because it was not a sufficient improvement, and the Wave, despite one hand blade opening convenience, had too many tools that didn't lock, a deal breaker for me. Last April I acquired an ST 200 at a giveaway price and must admit the rounded handles and lock release levers were a greater improvement than I would have thought.
While the Surge seems to be an attractive rep[lacement, it is just a little too large, heavy, complex and expensive compared to the STs and unless you really need one hand blade accessibility, not much more useful.
The Charge Ti ($60 on sale at Sharper Image, how could I turn it down?) which I have been EDCing for a couple of months, is great for pocketability with the accessory clip, all tools lock, but it has IMHO a neary useless small screwdriver, the other drivers are stubby and it lacks an awl ( I want it Awl!

). I am still evaluating it as a possible EDC replacement and confess I love the one hand blade opening feature, but when I think a serious tool might be needed I still reach for a Supertool (If I KNOW a tool will be needed, of course, I take the tool box).
As a balance of weght, utility and price, the Supertools are still my top choice in the honking big multitool category. There are still some available as new stock here and there. But it's your choice and whatever it is, you're right.