What is the purpose of the "half stop"?

Joined
Sep 21, 2010
Messages
2,957
I just got a Grandaddy type big bold Case Barlow at a knife show. Love it with only one single exception. Since I am new to traditionals I would prefer the one smooth opening move I am used to. Why is there a half stop designed for this blade?? It opens about half way and then you need a second pull on the blade. There must be a reason. Anyone know what it is?

Thanks.

I otherwise am delighted with this knife. It has the qualities I admire like being big and heavy duty.
 
Two things to metion.... first half stop are designed to protect from closing the blade while using the knife. That´s the main reason, imo.

The second thing - we had this topic almost several times. I don´t want to get offending or aggressive - but when you´re using the searching function and just type in there "half stop" you´ll get about 40 results of threads almost made about that.

I´m sure, you´ll find much more information in these threads about the reason of a half stop.

I hope that helps a little ;)
 
I'm not sure, but I always thought it was somewhat of a safety feature. Gives you a chance to get your fingers out of the way before snapping all the way shut.
 
totally the opposite, love to have half stops on knives. Safety feature would be my guess.

Russell
 
This question really does seem to come up frequently, and I always try to include this link in my reply (excerpt quoted below; probably the most informative I've read on the subject, from member 'zerogee' :thumbup: ):

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/799363-Half-stop

Many people will tell you that it's for safety and all that, but really, originally, it had to do more with ease of construction and reliability. For a very long time, blades - particularly the tangs - were filed to match hardened patterns. It's a heck of a lot easier to file a square tang profile (the half stop is the flat end of the tang) than a rounded one (actually the profile isn't quite square, but we'll ignore that for now). Also, for a long time the old mark of quality construction was the "clean and square" joint - basically the square tang was matched to a square bolster, essentially filling the joint, even when closed. This meant that if you dropped your knife in the dirt, the dirt didn't get into and around the joint to foul up the mechanism. (Remington "discovered" this early last century. :rolleyes: )

A square tang is largely self cleaning -- the corners sweep debris either toward the end of the knife or back into the body - either way, the debris gets moved out from under the tang/joint mechanism where it can then be removed. Properly cleaning up an old, gunked up knife and getting all the crud out of the mechanism is a lot easier with one that has square tangs.

Also, a square tang causes less wear and tear on the spring over time - assuming the corners of the square tang were rounded a tiny bit in construction. The corners sweep back and forth along a length of the spring in operation. spreading the wear evenly along that length. A round or cam end tang concentrates the wear in a much smaller area of the spring - becoming a problem when proper maintenance and oiling is neglected.


David
 
David,

Thank you.

If one accepts that it is easier to manufacture with a flat on the tang end, why do you suppose the CHINA knives tend not to exhibit that feature? Because blades are all just stamped out these days?
 
David,

Thank you.

If one accepts that it is easier to manufacture with a flat on the tang end, why do you suppose the CHINA knives tend not to exhibit that feature? Because blades are all just stamped out these days?

(Pure speculation, but...)

I suppose mass-production techniques may have something to do with it (stamped or CNC-machined), although there are many who don't care for half-stops/square tangs, and mfrs. might be catering to that preference too. For non-knife nuts (most knife users), a half-stop may seem awkward or even scary to handle. Lots of people have been bitten by them forcefully snapping shut, including me. A round/cammed tang is usually more predictable in how it opens & closes. :)


David
 
Two things to metion.... first half stop are designed to protect from closing the blade while using the knife. That´s the main reason, imo.

The second thing - we had this topic almost several times. I don´t want to get offending or aggressive - but when you´re using the searching function and just type in there "half stop" you´ll get about 40 results of threads almost made about that.

I´m sure, you´ll find much more information in these threads about the reason of a half stop.

I hope that helps a little ;)

That does help. You are also correct that I should have used the search function here in the forum.
 
Back
Top