What knife will be the "next" Randall?

Joined
Feb 6, 2006
Messages
3,007
Obviously, there is not a knife that will take Randall's place and stature in the market, but what I mean is...Is there a knifemaker out there that is looking like it may have the quality and ability to "carve" it's own niche (pardon the pun) and become a part of blade lore?? I am interested in getting in on a few knives from a maker of that caliber before I have to wait 4.5 years to get 'em (and before prices go sky high)! Any good recommendations? This is more fun than picking stocks! I know that different people look for different qualities in a knife, but I'd like to see what the other folks on here think...
 
Well, I went to the Blade Show West several years ago and their are many knife makers out there on par with Randalls but they haven't been in business for 60 odd years. Buy what makes you happy and don't worry about it like your father obviously did with his Randalls. I have knives that may be worthless to some people but they make me happy and they each have a history with me. I plan on writing down the history on each one for my daughter so she'll know what they meant to me when she gets them later in life.
 
I wish I had the history of all my knives, unfortunately for me that history starts with my acquiring them when my father passed prematurely without giving me a rundown. I am fond of the Randall's because those are the ones he always showed me and talked about. So now my hobby is inspecting every last inch of the other knives and trying to identify them (mostly military). I will write down what I know so that my daughter at least has something to go on. The only thing I regret is selling one to pay my dad's expenses. I sold the one that had the most market value in order to retain all of the other ones: the famed V-42 w/ original sheath, mint.

Anyway, what about the Chris Reeve knives? Any good?
 
What knife will be the "next" Randall?

Perhaps Busse; but, it takes more then a good knife. You have to have a solid marketing plan and a first rate customer service operation. Randall not only takes care of its customers, it looks out for anyone who has ever purchased one of their knives. When you can take an order for a knife that is due three years from now and deliver it, as promised, on the exact date committed, all while protecting your market price, then you are ready to move into Randall's space.

n2s
 
I don't think there will a "next" Randall, simply because the period in history and circumstances when the Randall knife made it's reputation will never be repeated.

As we all know, the Randall knife made it's reputation in WWII, then during the Korean War and Viet Nam. The close hand to hand combat of those wars is becoming less and less common with the advances in military technology, and with it, the perceived need for a knife like the Randall. Where hand to hand combat was common in those conflicts, it appears to have been nearly non-existent during the first and second Gulf Wars.

The Randall knife also made it's reputation with sportmen after WWII. Particularly those on safari in Africa, pro hunters & guides, and to a lesser extent in the heyday of wilderness Alaskan and Canadian hunting. Unfortunately the classic African safari and extended packtrain North American wilderness hunting is now nearly extinct.

Also remember that in the period when Randall became recognized as the best knife in the world for military and serious hunting use
(1939- early 1960's), America as a whole recognized and acknowledged knives as everyday use tools. Now society views knives first and foremost as dangerous weapons, not everyday tools.

For example, when I went to kindergarten in 1962, every boy carried a clean cotton hanky and a pocketknife (to this day I don't leave the house without a clean hanky and a pocketknife). A kid carries a pocketknife to kindergarten now gets expelled for bringing a dangerous weapon to school.

I'm sure there are knives being made as good as a Randall, but circumstances and the time we live in conspire against them ever equalling Randall's stature. Nope, Bo Randall came up with his first knife at the right time during the right era, and that time will never happen again...
 
All interesting and valid perspectives. You are right about Randall's place in history and the circumstances that make the knife what it is...I can't say enough about timing and quality! Maybe what I'll do is look into individual customs as a way to bide my time waiting for my Randalls to come in the mail...
 
I really like Busse Combat's knives but i dont think their gona turn into randall as far as the lines go. but they dont sell the models forever so maybe collector value.
 
Back
Top