What makes a knife not concealed?

Joined
Jan 11, 2012
Messages
1,143
I live in California, and concealing a fixed blade is illegal here. And I was wondering what makes a knife "not concealed." Does a pocket clip count? How about a lanyard? Or a necklace attached to a necklace knife showing?

What makes a knife not concealed?
 
Here's my translation of CA law regarding fixed blades. It must be openly carried on your waist. A fixed blade in a sheath, around your neck with only the lanyard showing would be considered concealed carry IIRC.
 
Most case law I have read on the matter suggests that the object must be clearly identifiable as a knife by a casual observer. It is worth noting that many cases suggest that a knife carried in a way that a cop can pick out, but a civilian would miss entirely, still counts as concealed because cops are "specially trained" to identify weapons. Pocket clip showing is a huge gray area (though only really applicable to folders) and I would never trust it as any sort of standard. Some cases have ruled a visible pocket clip as concealed because the body of the knife was so hidden it was not identifiable as a knife to a non-trained person. On the other hand, pocket clips are routinely used in New York cases as unlawful open carry (open carry is not permitted in NYC, but concealed is).
 
I live in California, and concealing a fixed blade is illegal here. And I was wondering what makes a knife "not concealed." Does a pocket clip count? How about a lanyard? Or a necklace attached to a necklace knife showing?

What makes a knife not concealed?

My interpretation of the statutes (which may not be consensus) is that a fixed-blade must be carried fully-exposed, except for the sheath-covered part, and worn from the waist. No neck knives, fixed pocket knives, boot knives. I would be very leery to allow even a jacket to cover part of the handle.

Is this "right"? Of course not, but my aim is to keep you out of trouble, not argue the idiocy of California "law." In some rural counties, like mine, you'd likely get absolutely no trouble with any reasonable fixed-blade carry, but in LA, SF, and other urban counties? You just might.
 
Back
Top