AlphalphaPB, like I said, "I'm CLUMSY, and I'm looking for a beater."
Up until I bought my G-Shock, the watch I wore to work, hiking, etc, was a automatic black face/black bezel Omega Seamaster Professional (new style SMP, Ref. 2054.50.00, not the classic James Bond SMP). I've worn it every day since November 20, 2000. It's a great watch, very sturdy, very comfortable, very functional, etc. I have to look professional at work. (my avatar is NOT me) The Omega works for me. The bracelet's pretty scratched up, as I USE my SMP. It's a tool. I USE my tools. My SMP is a great tool. So is my Strider AR. Another story...
I bought the G-Shock to hike with, to bike with, to DESTROY. It's comfortable, it's cheap, and it's VERY expendable. It's a beater. The mineral crystal will scratch easier than synthetic sapphire. I don't care. If I frag it, I'll throw down another $59.93 + tax for another one. My G-Shock is a tool.
"1. The displays might be nifty looking, but often they are just too small and cluttered to let me efficiently read the time. Yes, the watch is huge, but the letters are usually very small. I don't need 3 different spinning dials as a visual indicator of seconds passing."
I agree. My previous beater, a Timex "Humvee", has a bigger, easier to read display. However, the watch is very uncomfortable, and feels fragile. All four buttons are exposed. The button for the light is at the upper left, which is VERY awkward for me. The light button on the G-Shock is placed perfectly.
The G-Shock will do.