What would you say is the best piggy back or companion knife to go with a chopper ?

Joined
Dec 6, 2011
Messages
1,301
Ok , so here's what happened . I WAS more of a "one knife to do it all" guy till I got a chopper and tried it out . I like it ! :D Anyway , so now I have a Dogfather as my chopper and would like oppinions about what you guys with more Busse and Busse kin experience think is the best smaller knife for bushcraft .

My Dogfather with it's saber grind is a chopping and splitting beast , so I have that covered . I guess what I really want to know is what you all consider a great bushcraft knife for carving trap triggers , feather sticks , cooking tools or what have you .


............................................
HOLD MY BEER AND WATCH THIS !
 
Last edited:
I would probably go with a SAR5. I don't like the huge front guard on small knives, and the SAR5 finds an elegant way around that while still maintaining the trademark talon hole. I also like that I can get my fingers right up against the edge of the SAR 5, with its dropped heel, and how the edge is forward of the handle so it's more in line with your knuckles than with your palm. The MUK is close, but I'm not used to that huge belly.

An anorexic BOSS street would be pretty nice, too, if I could get used to the guard. It's a pretty proven design for small knives, and you'll find a similar one on Fallkniven F1s and Bark River Bravo 1s and Gunnys, all pretty well-known knives.
 
I have a SAR 3 piggyback on my FFBM. Works well for flinging sparks from firesteel, and not too bad when it comes to feathersticks. It works well for me and I like it. A Game Warden is another choice. I kinda like the MBC, but it seems too small for a proper piggyback knife, it's small and slender so it would be good for small delicate tasks, but I think it lacks the qualities of a "small bushcrafter" (just my opinion, I'm by no means an expert and I'm not smart enough to make it sound like I'm one on the interweb super highway), but fits well in the pocket.

The Scrapyard 311 doesn't look too bad, strip the coating and you'd probably have a nice slicer. Swamp Rat (one of these days), will comes out with their version of the SAR 3 with the hump in the middle, like the Rodent 4 and 9.


Or..you could go the awesome route. Get a Gladius or a MOAB and use the Dogfather as the piggyback for small tasks :D
 
I hate to buck the Busse trend of recommendations, but I would probably use the Bark River Bravo-1, Bravo-2 or Fallkniven S1. I was thinking this exact same question after receiving a CG-Fusion Battle Mistress. The FBM will be the chopper while one listed above will do the lighter duty stuff, like shaving, batoning and whatnot.
 
Given that you are pairing with a DogFather I would find an SS4. Fantastic combo.
 
CABS, or BAD depending on my mood.

I often carry the B11 with the CABS and the Muck attached on a baldric rig.
 
If you're thinking of "piggybackin' ", I would go with a light one.
Basic 4, anorexic.
 
Magnum Bear Cub great for all that fine work.
 
Heresy perhaps to post this on the Busse forum but in addition to the Basic 4 LE and the Magnum Bear Cub, there is a whole line of Beckers that would do well; all the way from a BK13 to a BK2 depending on how large you want the knife to be

Lots of choices out there; enjoy.
 
I piggybacked a Scrapivore with my 711. I can pretty much do everthing with my 711 including small work if i choke up on the blade, but i like having a small skeletonized blade like the Scrapivore for dressing game or cutting up food.

I'd like to match up an RMD with my Rucki once my kydex sheaths get here! :cool:
 
IMO, It's hard to beat a CABS as a great companion knife.
 
Last edited:
i don't have any hands-on experience with any busse [or kin] blades yet so i'm not familiar with their blade thicknesses which imo should be a major factor when considering a small, piggy back companion blade.... you specifically mentioned bushcraft duty and since you've already made your choice to field carry 2 blades [as opposed to three separate crossover duty blades or a 'single do-it-all' one], and have the h/d chopper choice made already, imo you'll want to use a relatively thin blade for the 2nd, small - piggy back - knife choice...

most active bushcrafters go with a convex grind large chopper [or more typically, a quality half-axe - wetterlings or gransfors bruks are popular and among the best] for heavy wood chopping/cutting and a much thinner small blade for all around camp duty such as game dressing, food prep, fire starting/prep, etc... scandi or hollow grind for the small knife... you'll want the small blade to be light as well for extended fatigue-free use....

many hard core bushcrafters tend to ridicule dudes who choose a king size, thick blade as 'rambo wannabes' but that's because they're usually quite proficient with using a small, thin blade for all but the heaviest tasks around camp/fiield, through a lot of long term practice.... to most practicing bushcrafters, just about any blade that's thicker than 1/8" and longer than 4" is an excess.... more often than not, a bushcrafter's combo of choice is a compact axe and a small thin blade combo; often the small knife even without a full hilt [e,g, cheap moras are quite popular], rather than a huge chopper knife/smaller knife combo....

however, an axe is awkward to 'wear' so it's usually relegated to being strapped to a pack or another carry method outside of a person.... therefore, if you like to have both blades strapped and always on you, a large, heavy chopper knife insteadd of an axe is a better choice, as long as it's truly tough and proficient at chopping...

someone mentioned barkie's bravo 1 as a good choice for a second blade/companion... i would respectfully disagree, i own a bravo 1 [in 3v] and although its blade is less than 4.5" it is a hefty one and while an excellent choice for a compact/light single all around bushcraft/field/camp blade, its far less than an ideal one as a small companion to the big blade for all smaller chores...it's a pretty thick convex grind too so not as practical for precise carving, cutting and slicing that food prep sometimes calls for for example....
as far as barkies go, the gunny is thinner and a much better choice than bravo 1 despite both being very similar in size and virtually identical in design/shape... i own a day hiker 2 as far as other bark river knives are concerned , and that's a very nice, sturdy bushcraft blade for just about all lighter duty camp/field chores, including skinning/dressing game, carving/drilling a bow drill, etc., yet tough/thick enough to substitute in some heavier use.... hell, you can easily baton with it as long as the diameter of wood is kept proportional to its blade length....aurora is their another badass knife, around bravo 1's dimensions but thinner blade....
mid and larger beckers are also too thick for small, piggyback choice imo....

bottom line, as long as you can alway ensure of having both blades secure on you and ready to use, i personally would choose the second, smaller one to be no thicker than 1/8", under 5" in length and as light as possible with simultaneously very little compromise in strength dept.... full hilt preferrably and a thinner, more precise grind than a convex for intricate slicing of soft stuff like fruit, veggies, fish, et al.... because you won't need it to perform any heavy duty wood-cutting tasks anyway....
i'd use these criteria as fundamental starting point when chosing a companion, 2nd blade for bushcraft duty, whatever the brand/make of choice.... once ya have the various makes/models narrowed down to this factor then it's personal preference with regards to a particular model...

others might disagree of course, that is simply my opinion,albeit formed after indulging my interest in survival/bushcraft skills and subsequent long time study of various sources pertaining to it... not actual practical experience however....
jerzy...
 
Last edited:
I kinda like this set.

001-1.jpg
 
Back
Top