When asking for a knife recommendation...

Status
Not open for further replies.

JTR357

Gold Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2007
Messages
14,388
Here are some things to consider,when you are asking for a knife recommendation.

1.What will you use it for?
ie:camping,hunting,survival,self-defense,fishing,bush-craft,etc.

2.How much are you willing to spend?What is your budget?
$20,$50,$75,$100,$300?

3.What type of environment will you will be using it in?
ie: tropical,mountainous terrain,desert,salt water,etc.

4.Do you want a folder or a fixed blade?
(a)If you want a folder,what type of lock do you prefer?
(b)Do you want a locking folder,or would you prefer a non-locking folder?
(c)If you prefer fixed blades,what type of sheathing system works for you?

5.What size?Blade,Handle,overall length?

6.What's the most important feature to you?
ie:ergonomics,country of origin,steel type,grind type,handle material,etc

7.Have you researched your local laws,& do you know what is or is not legal to own/carry in your area(or the area you will be using/carrying it)?
(Thanks rubiconss)



A few more things to consider-
1. How long the person has been using/collecting knives - This is helpful because even if someone has the disposable income to buy, say, a Sebenza as his first knife, he'd probably be better off working his way up to a $300-400 knife since that'd allow him to figure out what he likes. He'd also be more likely to be able to appreciate the quality of a CRK or custom if he's had a decent amount of experience with other knives.

2. If the person is relatively new to the knife world, what other knives are in his collection (if it's a small enough number for listing them to be practical!). - This is useful because it would help us suggest knives that complement a person's existing knives. For example, if a person has mostly small, thin-bladed slicers, a larger, harder-use folder might be a good, diversifying addition to his collection.
(Thanks neuron)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here are some common questions I see asked when someone asks for a knife recommendation.
I figured it'd be beneficial to the knife community,if everyone considered these before asking "Which knife should I get?".

Please feel free to add to the list.These are just off the top of my head.

Thanks
 
Last edited:
Has the person researched their Local Laws I think would be important as well.

If they are asking for input, they may be inexperienced and in these days that can be a problem. I know, my wife asked me if I was "carrying" last weekend when we went to NYC. I have a CC permit for Pa.. She didn't know that doesn't fly in NYC (or Federal Buildings i.e. the Post Office) at home.
As we know, the rules vary. Same with knives. Know your Laws where you live AND where you are going.
 
Last edited:
Great post. :thumbup:

A couple other things I'd add are:

1. How long the person has been using/collecting knives - This is helpful because even if someone has the disposable income to buy, say, a Sebenza as his first knife, he'd probably be better off working his way up to a $300-400 knife since that'd allow him to figure out what he likes. He'd also be more likely to be able to appreciate the quality of a CRK or custom if he's had a decent amount of experience with other knives.

2. If the person is relatively new to the knife world, what other knives are in his collection (if it's a small enough number for listing them to be practical!). - This is useful because it would help us suggest knives that complement a person's existing knives. For example, if a person has mostly small, thin-bladed slicers, a larger, harder-use folder might be a good, diversifying addition to his collection.
 
Here are some things to consider,when you are asking for a knife recommendation.

1.What will you use it for?
ie:camping,hunting,survival,self-defense,fishing,bush-craft,etc.

2.How much are you willing to spend?What is your budget?
$20,$50,$75,$100,$300?

3.What type of environment will you will be using it in?
ie: tropical,mountainous terrain,desert,salt water,etc.

4.Do you want a folder or a fixed blade?
(a)If you want a folder,what type of lock do you prefer?
(b)Do you want a locking folder,or would you prefer a non-locking folder?
(c)If you prefer fixed blades,what type of sheathing system works for you?

5.What size?Blade,Handle,overall length?

6.What's the most important feature to you?
ie:ergonomics,country of origin,steel type,grind type,handle material,etc

7.Have you researched your local laws,& do you know what is or is not legal to own/carry in your area(or the area you will be using/carrying it)?

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Here are some common questions I see asked when someone asks for a knife recommendation.
I figured it'd be beneficial to the knife community,if everyone considered these before asking "Which knife should I get?".

Please feel free to add to the list.These are just off the top of my head.

Thanks

But I just want the BEST knife! You know what I mean!
 
This would make a terrific STICKY. Posts like these are extremely helpful.

*hint* *hint*
 
This would make a terrific STICKY. Posts like these are extremely helpful.

*hint* *hint*

I agree. Great advice about local laws. Local meaning city, county as well as state. Where I live you need to consider all three levels.
 
Great idea. But then again, if people used the search function to find this, then most of the time they could have also used the search function to answer their question.
 
Great post. :thumbup:

A couple other things I'd add are:

1. How long the person has been using/collecting knives - This is helpful because even if someone has the disposable income to buy, say, a Sebenza as his first knife, he'd probably be better off working his way up to a $300-400 knife since that'd allow him to figure out what he likes. He'd also be more likely to be able to appreciate the quality of a CRK or custom if he's had a decent amount of experience with other knives.

2. If the person is relatively new to the knife world, what other knives are in his collection (if it's a small enough number for listing them to be practical!). - This is useful because it would help us suggest knives that complement a person's existing knives. For example, if a person has mostly small, thin-bladed slicers, a larger, harder-use folder might be a good, diversifying addition to his collection.

Those two excellent points, added to the ones in the first post, would make an EXCELLENT sticky :thumbup:
 
Thanks for the replies guys.I edited them into the OP.

I need a few more to make it to 10,so keep them coming.
 
Are you left or right handed and is the knife lefty and/or righty friendly for deployment and closing.
 
Thanks for the replies guys.I edited them into the OP.

I need a few more to make it to 10,so keep them coming.

What's so magical about having ten??? it wouldn't make the points more valid.

We don't need another sticky to scroll past. Newbies who would ask probably wouldn't read it first.
 
Unfortunately, the people who most need to read these are the blissninnies who don't.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top