wheres BM lackin now?

Joined
Jan 16, 2001
Messages
156
alrihgt.. after my AFCK problem, ive decided to replace it with the same model. Now when i bought it i originally i wasnt aware of any QC problems with benchmade. I had to order the one i want from work, but what kind of QC problems should i look for when it comes in? and will BM fix them if there are any?
 
A post in the current thread on the same page as this "benchmade or spyderco" has this statement. It appears to concisely list the primary problems Benchmade buyers have found with knives of late: " . . .the AFCK WAS one of the best, but times change and they suffer from a number of production and design niggles. Blade play, wobble and liner rub. Oh and the blade comes of centre and the liner flexes. Otherwise a fine knife." Well, guess this wasn't quite complete. There have been negative comments about uneven grind lines as well.

Of course, there are going to be at least some, if not many, who'll tell you that BM is the best, that they own a dozen of 'em and have nary a quibble with one.

As always, the answer, whenever possible, is to go to a show or brick and mortar and handle the knives you're interested in. You may totally change your mind, or have your highest hopes realized. (Then, if you can, try to buy from an internet dealer who'll check out the knife for you, and not send you one that goes straight back to Oregon.) You will find that many on-line dealers don't deal with Benchmade because of what I've read labelled as "draconian" rules about prices their dealers may charge, etc.

Rotsa ruck!
biggrin.gif



------------------
Asi es la vida

Bugs
 
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by Bugs3x:
Of course, there are going to be at least some, if not many, who'll tell you that BM is the best, that they own a dozen of 'em and have nary a quibble with one.</font>

Yep, and there'll be tons of MT, Spyderco, Emerson, etc. fans that'll say the same thing when those brands are questioned. Doesn't mean they're liars. Just drawing from their own personal experience, which differs from one to the next.

Regarding the idea that times have changed for the worse for BM-I have to disagree with that sentiment, as my experience with BM, though limited, spans about six years. IMO, their quality has increased steadily over that time period. My most recent acquisitions (four Axis locks-one sold, one given as a gift) showed excellent fit/finish, and three of them even had good edges (believe it or not!).
For some reason, people seem to think that one bad apple somehow affects an entire product line. Go figure.
Also, I have yet to see a major online dealer that doesn't carry Benchmade.

Since I've discovered the Sebenza and custom knives, I may never buy another BM, but that doesn't change the fact that they make fine knives-though, like every manufacturer, they let a bad one slip every once in a while (luckily I've only heard about it, and not had to tell about it
smile.gif
). There will always be someone with something positive, OR something negative to say.
The bottom line is BM leads the industry. BM sells. BM doesn't do those things because their products suck.

I totally agree that you should handle a knife prior to ordering one, to make sure it suits you, if possible, and if you have concerns about quality, have the online dealer inspect the knife prior to shipping it (that can go for any manufacturer). Nothing wrong with stacking the odds in your favor + you can always send it back.
 
I have to agree with OwenM on this one. My last BM, a very recent purchase, was excellent in all departments except for the uneven grind on the edge. But I can say the same for the last two customs I bought as well.

------------------
Hoodoo

I get some pleasure from finding a relentlessly peaceful use for a combative looking knife.
JKM
 
I personally never had "terrible" problems with any of my Benchmades, once or twice I sent a knife in for a quck repair to the lock, because I was unable to release it without breaking my thumb
smile.gif
However, Benchmade always corrected the problem very quickly and the knives were great when received back.

Overall, I've been very please with my purchases from them.


------------------
Crimson Horizon
Nothing but edge baby...
dark.nemesis@home.com
 
Back
Top