Which custom maker?

Joined
Feb 24, 1999
Messages
368
I'm looking for a knife maker to create a custom knife for me...actually, for my wife. Here's the situation:

(Tom, Dave...anyone else from the Club here, if you spill the beans you will eat hot death. Be warned!
wink.gif
)

Okay, the wife in question is a martial artist (as opposed to a marital artist, as I misspelled it the first time- she's that, too), and assuming she passed her recent testing, is about to become a black belt candidate. This gives me a several months to a year or so time to get her a suitable gift for her (hopeful) promotion to black belt. Once students become black belt they are expected to have their own knife with which to perform the blade forms. How very fortunate.
smile.gif


The 'official' knife is basically a no-frills fixed-blade tanto, and this creation would need to stick to the standard diminsions.

Beyond that there is some room for 'play'. As far as handle material goes, I would prefer to stick to something functional and (alas) boring, like a nice grippy G-10. The blade, however, is where I would like some originality/quality/flair...possibly damascus steel in a nice pattern? Or, a more 'traditional' approach of highly polished steel with a hamon?

I'm a traditionalist in general, but lets face it, modern martial arts are a hodge-podge of east-meets-west from the beginning, so I don't see the need to adhere to *strict* tanto-style blade tradition.

Also, it would be nice to include our club logo and my family coat-of-arms in the knife at some point, either etched/engraved on the blade, or perhaps on the furniture. I can provide line-art renderings of these designs (they're both pretty simple).

Time and budget concerns...I hate to say cost is no object. Cost is ALWAYS an object...but I have always been prepared to pay more for quality. And the EARLIEST I would possibly 'need' this knife would be late in the year (November)...and that is extremely unlikely.

So, custom knife afficionados...any suggestions as to which custom knife maker I should employ?

------------------
"A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects." -Robert Heinlein
 
Bill Siegle makes some very tough tantos (differentially tempered 5160)...not too fancy, but I bet he would put on some nice scales, etc. for you.
 
I am not sure what Mike Snody offers for add ons but he sure makes great Japanese style knives. You may want to contact him and see what he can do. He does not have a web site yet but you will find a lot on him in these forums.
Good luck finding a knife for your wife.

Keith.
 
Snody is a good one to check.

See also RJ Martin and Don Polzien.
http://www.martinsite.com/
http://www.blindinglightknives.com/

See their work on Les Robertson's page:
http://www.robertsoncustomcutlery.com

RJ Martin is coming off a significant finger injury that required some surgery. He may be pretty backlogged now and is a full-time engineer for Sikorski and part time maker to start. An issue, if timing is important.

Wally Hayes seems to have a lot of satisfied customers and from what I hear, does excellent work (I haven't seen in person):
http://www.hayesknives.com/japan.html

Mortgage your house and then go see Scott Slobodian's work... I've seen his stuff at two shows, and man, it is SO beautiful and tastefully done. Just phenomenal, I simply don't have the resources to own, admire, and then admire and NOT USE his work. Sigh. Some day... when I master the stock market:
http://www.slobodianswords.com/

Scott's work really accentuates how overpriced Hartsfield and Piorek (below) look. Go see his web page and see his work in person before you launch any ascii flames in my direction.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Phill Hartsfield is VERY overpriced for the quality of work you get.

I think that James Piorek's (blade rigger) blade & handle work is good but not anything particularly amazing at the price, however his carry systems are excellent and very innovative if that is important to you, but his prices are VERY high also. Worth a look... but good luck getting anything custom in a hurry.
http://www.bladerigger.com/home.html

(I call it like I see it folks, torch me with ascii text as you see fit if it makes you feel better.)


[This message has been edited by rdangerer (edited 02-20-2001).]
 
Don't make a decision until you visit Neil Blackwood's site- www.blackwoodknives.com Some beautiful combinations of hi-tech materials and traditional cord-wrapping!
smile.gif
Also- a little outside of the tanto category but something that would look wicked doing weapons forms are Jerry Hossom's knives! www.hossom.com
smile.gif


[This message has been edited by richard rosvall (edited 02-20-2001).]
 
I guess I can't really help in terms of more contemporary things...the makers that have been listed here are more oriented towards that goal...so if that's what yer going for, I don't think you'll be disappointed.

Shinryû.
 
If you want a well made, sturdy knife, at a good price, try the Jones Brothers. You can email Barry at jknives@gamewood.net
He can direct you to pics of their work as well as answer questions.
 
Thank you VERY much for all of the replies...if anyone has more ideas, keep 'em coming
smile.gif


After looking at the different options it dawned on me that the official knife is actually an 'american tanto' style, as epitomized by the solidly built but utterly overhyped Cold Steel line (I get ill just looking at their catalogue)...look at standard 'tanto series' knives. In general form it would have to be pretty much like that.

I LOVE Hayes damascus tanto...right now he is leading the pack.
biggrin.gif


Thanks again,
Mike

------------------
"A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects." -Robert Heinlein
 
I think that a Mike Snody karma kubikiri or bushido would make an excellent blade. Also, check out Steve Corkum's Shobu or custom maker Gary Bradburn. I do not have first hand knowledge, but it appears that Gary can make a nice traditional knife at a good price.
The Wally Hayes Typhoon damascus is a very small neck knife. It has a wonderful blade.

Good luck!
 
Gotta put in another vote for the Jones Brothers.They make an excellent product at a good price. More importantly for you, they are very flexible in finishing a knife just the way you want it.
David
 
I agree with the Jones Brothers' recommendations for this one. Barry and Phil do great work at very reasonable prices. They know the meaning of "sharp" and, they back their stuff up!

------------------

Tom Anderson
Hand Crafted Knives
 
Two maker to look at are Lynn griffith and Steve Corum.

Lynn uses a sand blasted G-10 handle on his knives, and any material you want, if you catch him in the right mood. I once asked for a knife made from D-2, but he declined because of how hard it is to work. i didn't blame him. The knife I was asking about turned out to be almost impossible to mke from D-2 because of the grind I wanted. I would have cost me over a grand, so I dropped the project. Lynn uses ATS-34 most of the time. he is very easy to work with and listens to his customers. His prices are fantastic for the quality of knife you end up getting. Here's the URL:


http://www.angelfire.com/on2/griffithknives/index.html

I don't know much about Corkum, but his knives look great. They are advertised all the time in the back of BLADE. BLADE did a great article not long ago. Corkum's knives are more money than Griffith's, but they are also a little fancier. Most have cord wrapped handles.

Good luck!.
 
Back
Top