Which DC motor for a grinder?

Joined
Apr 4, 2001
Messages
1,803
I'm going to pick up a Rob Frink grinder but would like suggestions on what to get for a motor. What should I be looking for in the way of brands/models and cotrollers (for variable speed)?
I have no knowledge of the various types of motors out there.
Thanks for any help.
 
mr frink would be a good one to ask. www.harberfrieght.com has cheap ac, at this price if you get a few years out of it your fine. tru-grit has the baldor 1 1/2 hp v/s which is the caddillac motor like the one on my hardcore grinder. good luck
 
TM, This grinder comes setup for a pulley configuration. You can use a AC motor with pulleys to acheive vari-speed and it is cheaper. I would use nothing smaller than a 1 1/2 HP motor. Here is a place to get a good used or new motor, www.dealerselectric.com. If you decide to go with the DC motor and controller setup, the same people can help you out. The RPM on the motor should be in the 1700 t0 2000 range for the AC setup. Hope this gives you a starting point.
KEN (WWJD)
 
:confused: When I click on the dealerselectric site I get a company called Chris Cross Foods.
Tom
 
I bought a Frink grinder a few months ago. Ended up with a new 1hp Baldor DC motor that I purchased off EBAY for about $150.00 and a DC variable control unit (new) also off ebay for 75.00. With just about zero electrical skill I managed to wire it all up to 220 with out a single problem, although I did just sit there thinking it all out repeatedly. I would have liked a 2hp but could not get one at a cheap enough price. Be persistant with EBAy and you will save a pile. A 1 hp works good enough, and may even be a slight advantage to getting used to the grinder.

It is a great grinder. My quality has definetly improved.
 
Surplus center has a v/s 1/12 hp for 126 and the v/s control with heat sink for 136 so for around 250 you could have a great set up
for ROB'S grinder.there number is 1-800-488-3407
 
Do not know what the problem is with that dealerselectric site. I got a message, no longer on file. they have a 800 number. Here is another good resource, www.vfds.com or www.automationstore.com. I beleive both have controllers and motors or can match up what you are missing.
KEN (WWJD)
 
Went and priced a new Baldor DC 1&1/2hp TEFC motor today. Going price was $800 for the motor and $200 for the controller. Then I would need to wire my shop (garage) for 230v 3phase. Yeow! I'm sure this was a bit high but I was paying to talk face to face with a human that could answer my questions.
A new 110v 1 phase Baldor @ 1&1/2hp was $180. This isn't going to be that hard of a choice.

Rob Frink sent me an email showing a pully step system on his grinder set up. Using a little manual effort to change speeds via moving the belt over a notch on the pully setup, I'll save a $grand. Guess that's the way I'll go. A dial to control the speed would be the cats ass, but a thousand bucks will buy a lot of steel and belts.
 
Tracy,

$180 for a 1.5 hp baldor is a low price on a new motor. One thing to look for....get a 1725 rpm motor. $180 is a low price and I'm thinking they quoted you for a 3650 rpm motor. The 1725 motors are typically $30-50 more than the same hp in the high speed frame size.

For this grinder, you'll be very happy with the slower motor and the step pulley setup that I described will give you a belt speed choice of 3600 ft/min, 1700 ft/min, 850 ft/min.

If you use a 3650 rpm motor, it gets tough to slow the grinder down to 800-900 ft/min with out bringing out the tool box:( .

Sincerely,

Rob
 
i have a coote set up this way. it works fine. i use it slack for handles now, i wait tell i have two or three handles to be sculpted, and work them down through the grits to gether this cuts down on the pulley changes,
 
Theres more to motor shoppin than pointen and sayen 'gimme one of those'...

When visiting a couple of the other local motor stores there is one universal. Ask for a 1&1/2 DC variable controlled motor and you get a blank look at first and then some comment about how expensive it is going to be. Then you get into a discussion about 220v, amp pull, 1 phase or 3 phase. This is all, of course, while your eyes glaze over.

Here's what I've found out so far for the benefit of those that will go through this later. A plain ol' 1hp 110v motor will need a 20amp circut and they run around $100 to $150 depending on the brand. You can find them for much less with off brands.
Moving up to 1&1/2hp 110v, the motor guru's say a 30amp circut is better but you might get by with a 20amp circut if your breaker isn't too fussy. Throw in GFI (ground fault protection) outlet or breaker and probability goes up you will need a 30amp circut. That's all pretty easy really.

Looking for a variable speed motor gets you referred to the shop expert. A DC variable 1&1/2hp is going to (usually) require 220v circut. Amps never came up but the assumption is that the typical 220v circut will handle the amps required. A new Baldor 1&1/2hp DC motor costs $800 (at least from the one little shop I got a quote from), a controller will cost you another $200. This, apparantly, is an unusually high horsepower DC motor to sell for the typical non-industrial dealer. Several wanted to talk me down in horsepower. (I
gritted my teeth and held my ground though)

A couple of the motor guys reccomended sucking it up and running 220v into my shop (my garage) and getting a more efficient 220v motor. Probably not bad advice but you can get by with 110v if you need to. One guy said just use a cord from my electric dryer outlet to the garage. I explained that the wife only appreciates so much of my eccentricities as it is and messing with her dryer outlet wouldn't put me on her popular list. He knowingly understood this. I didn't ask why.

Background tidbit on:
Household current coming into the typical house is 1 phase. In *some cases* you can get 3 phase brought into your house but only with a 4 or 5 thousand dollar bill. Probably best to save that for beer money.
Background tidbit off:

There's hope. There is something called a VFD controller or Variable Frequency D-sumpinorother. This pricey little box takes in your 220v 1 phase power, converts it to 220v 3phase and spits it back out the other side to your motor. While the power is getting converted in the box, you can, via touch pad with LED readout, adjust the frequency to control your motor speed up and down. Cool beans. Two different boxes I priced, Delta and Megatron, were $450 and $425. The 1&1/2hp motor now drops to around $150. Both boxes had several vent holes and a small cooling fan so you would have to mount the box away from the grinder to keep metal filings from getting inside and shorting out your $450 beauty, but this isn't a big problem, just something to be aware of.

The subject of torque comes up and here is where I heard conflicting information. A DC variable motor allows you to dial up or down around 30% of the base speed with out a lot of loss in torque, after that it drops off rapidly. A VFD setup maintains your torque through a much broader band with less loss in torque. I didn't feel real good about either statement but I didn't know enough about the whole thing to do more than nod my head. Maybe someone can give us the real skinny on this part of it.
 
dont let them sell you their rederick, i get by fine in my garage with household wireing. i do have a surge protector to the grinder. these are about 10 to 20 bucks. tru-grit had a sale of the baldor 1 1/2 for $495.00 dont know if john is still running that.
 
Back
Top