White Box vs Black Box vs Primble vs Schatt & Morgan... 2-, 3-, & 4-blade Sowbelly et

Joined
Dec 19, 2006
Messages
8,210
I received a "white box" Winchester (Queen) sowbelly today and would like to share some photos and comments with you guys. I have a few knives from the "black box" series but this is my first from the "white box" series... I think they call it "Rifle Shield Series". It's also my first 4-blade sowbelly.

white-box-winchester-1.jpg


The date on the back of the tang is 1996. I think the general specifications for the "white box" knives is the same as the older "black box" knives. The "Burnt Orange Bone" isn't as complex as on the old Utica jigged bone that's on the old "black box" knives... and in my opinion, it's not as attractive as the "Pennsylvania Brown Berry Worn Worm Groove Bone" on the knives from Schatt & Morgan Series 18. The shield is sort of fun. The shield does stick out a lot more than the shields on the other knives. I'd prefer the shield to be flush or close to flush... and a "sowbelly shield" (bodice, barbie) would be my preference for this sowbelly pattern.

white-box-winchester-2.jpg


I was expecting that the main blade would be shorter on a 4-blade sowbelly compared two a 3-blade sowbelly but I was pleasantly surprised that they are actually the same length.

white-box-winchester-3.jpg


The main blade on the 4-blade sowbelly is slightly thinner than the main blade on the 3-blade sowbelly. A "catch bit" (learned about these from Ken!) is used to allow the main blade and the spey blade to pass eachother on the 4-blade sowbelly. It's a close fit but Queen did a good job making it work. The blades don't rub unless you fail to lift them straight up.

white-box-winchester-4.jpg


Here's a comparison of the wells of 2-, 3- and 4-blade sowbellies.

white-box-winchester-4a.jpg


Queen also made a 5-blade sowbelly but I don't presently have one to include in the photo. Here's an old photo for comparison.

IMG_6841.jpg


There are some differences between the Queen-made sowbellies. The placement of the nail nick and the shape of the blade is slightly different on the 4-blade sowbelly. I like the blade shape the best on the 4-blade. The long pull on the Schatt & Morgan sowbelly is also pretty cool. I do prefer the carbon steel on the Winchester sowbelly over the 420HC on the Schatt & Morgan sowbelly.

white-box-winchester-5.jpg


The blade shape and nail nick placement is also similar to this vintage sowbelly...

white-box-winchester-6.jpg


It's also similar to the shape of the blade on my Ryu sowbelly. :) :) :)

This is where I start meandering (or did it happen earlier?!) :)

I think this 4-blade sowbelly or one like it might be fun to modify into a two blade sowbelly similar to this premium double end jack.

img644.jpg


It's a project that I've spoken about with one of the talented members of Bladeforums. Originally, I had thought that it may be possible to use the main blade and the sheepfoot blade but now that I've had a close look at the well I think it will only work with the main blade and the spey blade like the old Remington. I think it will be a fun project for the future.
 
Last edited:
Jake.......

Great post as always...you're right something about that S&M bone..so rich in color..................and I like the idea of the main and sheepfoot
 
The S&M Series 18 knife is very subtle and very nice with the same bone jigging/pattern as my S&M Series 18 Railsplitter. Very nice knives across the board - 4 Aces.:thumbup:
 
Last edited:
I do really like the main blade shape on the "white box" sowbelly and the four blades look well placed for use.
 
All super nice sowbelleys there Jake:thumbup:; thanks for sharing! My S&M's shield matches up with the rest of the F&F of the knife, which is the most flush shield I've seen from a factory!
 
Here's my 3 3/4' 5 blade Queen Sowbelly. Photobucket seems to have changed how to link to pictures so i hope this works;

customs001-17.jpg


O.K., working. more pics:

customs002-18.jpg


Sorry about the reflection:

customs003-13.jpg


This is how i carry it:

customs004-11.jpg


Moore Maker 1999/1095 steel

roland
 
Jake - Will you check and see if the shield on the S&M is pinned. Thanks.
 
Thank you, guys. Peter, Excellent fit and finish of the series 18 Schatt and Morgan! Roland, I need one of those! It looks like it has a better fit and finish than the 5-blade from Schatt and Morgan series 20... I also like the punch on the Moore Maker. Ed, I don't so. The shields are pinned on my '89 and '91 Winchesters amd '89 Primble but not on the '96 rifle series Winchester or the '08 Schatt & Morgan. I also checked a few other patterns and the '88 Winchester bull-head and '96 Winchester congress have pinned shields.
 
Last edited:
Nice thread Jake! All of those look great. But that 2 blade single spring old
Remington Sowbelly is one of the best ever...imho. Thanks for sharing.

Jason
 
Great thread Jake, you have certainly stirred something in me with the Sowbelly, the above examples are beautiful.. I have never seen a "white box" edition knife, Love the colour of the burnt orange Bone.
That lovely old Remington..have you ever put up a thread or anything Jake?...I would love to see more of that, but dont let me take anything away the that premium double ended jack that is stunning!
Roland my friend, that queen made Sow is as Jake describes it.... always a pleasure looking at your wonderful knives. :thumbup:
 
Thank you, guys.

Duncan, There are a few photos of the Remington in the old knives thread: http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/527126-quot-Old-Knives-quot?p=10389451#post10389451 Ken Erickson has kindly agreed to pattern the knife. :)

I spent a few minutes sharpening each of the blades and toted the 4-blade Winchester today. The thickness of the 4-blade is about the same as the 3-blade so there's not really any noticeable difference in bulk. The 5-blade Schatt & Morgan from series 20 is noticeably thicker.

The blades are slightly thinner but they're sturdy enough. The thinness also sort of helps to make up for the grinds which are above average but not as good as the grinds on vintage knives.
 
Thank you, guys.

Duncan, There are a few photos of the Remington in the old knives thread: http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/527126-quot-Old-Knives-quot?p=10389451#post10389451 Ken Erickson has kindly agreed to pattern the knife. :)

I spent a few minutes sharpening each of the blades and toted the 4-blade Winchester today. The thickness of the 4-blade is about the same as the 3-blade so there's not really any noticeable difference in bulk. The 5-blade Schatt & Morgan from series 20 is noticeably thicker.

The blades are slightly thinner but they're sturdy enough. The thinness also sort of helps to make up for the grinds which are above average but not as good as the grinds on vintage knives.

Oh my! ...well Jake, you can tell I didnt get ANY sleep last night..Im at home crook as a dog, and I honestly thought the Remington was a different knife to the equal ender lol, I apologise as I do remember being quite struck with the two bladed Sowbelly when you put the older thread up, and still today - everytime I see that knife I yearn to own one like that...simply a gorgeous knife!
I am feeling rather embarrassed about my silly mistake, my apologies for wasting your time Jake, time to get a few more hours sleep hopefully.
 
Ed I'm carry my S&M this week so I just opened all the blades and I can't see a pin on mine. If' it is pinned then they covered it, if that's posible. I'm thinking it's not pinned.
 
Back
Top