Who has the best scissors on a MT?

Joined
Nov 27, 2002
Messages
659
I done a search, but came up empty. On the current available multi-tools, who makes the best scissors? I am considering a Swisstool X, SOG Powerlock or Leatherman tool. I would consider others as well, but these seem to be thought of as the best tools around. Any thoughts would be most appreciated.

Richard
 
The best scissors are, without a doubt, on the Swisstool. Second to that is the OLD wave (the new ones are that same stunted ones on the TI), third would be the gerber ones.

J
 
Good question Richard. I'm sure everyone has their own opinion, but scissors are one item that I think all manufacturers (that I'm familiar with) do well on. Anyone who ever needed scissors in a pinch couldn't complain about any of them. ;)
 
JohnJ80 said:
The best scissors are, without a doubt, on the Swisstool. Second to that is the OLD wave (the new ones are that same stunted ones on the TI), third would be the gerber ones.

J

I somewhat agree (but I don't have a swiss tool)
My ordering is:
1. Dedicated scissor-based mini like the SOG Crosscut and the LM Micra and Squirt S4. (all of these are better than the scissors on a full size tool)
2. Victorinox SAKs. (Swisstool is probably here)
3. OLD wave/Gerber
4. SOG Powerlock/New leatherman models.

1 is very good, 2 is good. 3 is acceptable and 4 is quite bad or has certain flaws.
 
klattman said:
I somewhat agree (but I don't have a swiss tool)
My ordering is:
1. Dedicated scissor-based mini like the SOG Crosscut and the LM Micra and Squirt S4. (all of these are better than the scissors on a full size tool)
2. Victorinox SAKs. (Swisstool is probably here)
3. OLD wave/Gerber
4. SOG Powerlock/New leatherman models.

1 is very good, 2 is good. 3 is acceptable and 4 is quite bad or has certain flaws.

You've got this exactly right. I had neglected the "scissors centric" tools like the LM Micra/Squirt S4. The Swisstool ones are just like on the SAK.

I'm really disappointed in the scissors in the new LM models (TI and the New Wave). Really a wasted blade slot as a result.

J
 
The new Swisstool Spirit has a different spring system than the older Swisstools and SAKs. Gone is the old "leaf" style spring. The new spring is like a beam that goes directly into the lower jaw. An engineering marvel.
 
I agree, the dedicated scissor tools are generally the best. The best of these is the Schrade MiniChip, IMHO; they're big and rugged. Next on my list is the SOG CrossCut, followed but the LM Micra and Squirt S4.

My favorite "accessory" scissors are the ones on the old Wave (and Pulse, and PST II); sturdy, long "bite", excellent spring design (lever off backspring, no flimsy leaf spring).

The new LM scissors aren't near as nice. They're a LOT shorter, and lateral pressure to the side the spring is on, can cause the spring to "jump" the blade. However, for their size, they do cut surprisingly well, and the spring isn't a problem if you avoid pressing on the spring side. Still, I wish they'd just put the old Wave/Pulse/PST II scissors in there!

The SwissTool scissors are huge, and cut very well, but I've always hated that damn Victorinox leaf spring! It's just not strong enough, and doesn't open the scissor far enough to make full use of their size. I haven't seen the Spirit yet, though, but from the description, it sounds like they've remedied that weakness.

Gerber/Fiskars scissors are the worst of the major brands, in my experience. They're always too short, too wide, uncomfortable to use, and have NO return spring. The curved cutting edges are supposed to be an advantage, but I prefer to use different edge angles to suit the job: the steeper angle near the pivot for maximum slicing of tough or thick materials, the shallow shearing action near the tip for more delicate work. The Fiskars design takes that away from me.

The scissors on the SOG PowerPlier is like a combination of the Gerber and old Leatherman designs; the blades are medium sized and straight, and the spring is strong, and held captive in a slot to prevent slippage. Action is a bit rough on mine, but then mine has the matte black oxide finish, which isn't exactly smooth.
 
Schrade ToughChip:
I have one of these and the scissors are excellent. Unfortunately all the other tools on it are horrible (locking mechanism is easy to unlock accidentally as well). But, they aren't being made anymore, so...

I think the SOG crosscut is probably the best of that bunch.

I dunno how well the Gerbers cut, I cannot stand Gerbers for other reasons, so I don't own one to compare. You would think the scissors would be the best feature, since they are owned by Fiskars. :rolleyes:

The SOG PowerLock scissors could be SO much better if they were only a bit thicker and stronger, they work well for paper, but that's about it.

The NEW LM scissors are just too darn short, good for trimming your fingernails, but takes forever to cut anything else.


I guess one could buy the LM Charge XTi (Not wasting a blade slot for the scissors) and get a sog crosscut or LM Squirt S4 to go with it.
 
Back
Top