Who only buys recommended knives?

Joined
Apr 15, 2008
Messages
3,010
So many posts here ask 'what knife do I buy?' I wonder how many of you will only buy a knife that is recommended by other folks here?

I buy knives based on what I like, so the whole 'which knife?' Posts seem silly to me, but I see so many, I just wonder if you only buy based on them.
 
I like the "recommend?" threads because people mention knives I've never heard of, so I get to Googling and eventually the credit card gets whipped out and I end up with even more knives for my already overflowing collection :D
 
I don't mind reading those posts, as on occasion I'll see knives brought up that I'm not real familiar with. So it's good from that stand point, as Cosmonaut mentioned.

To me, I think most of the time though, as expected, the person doing the recommend probably just suggests their brand of choice. But I myself wouldn't buy a knife strictly on a forum recommend. Just as a starting point for research.

But yeah, there do seem to be a lot of those type of threads.
 
The only annoyance for me is "Recommend?" threads usually start and end with the OP's mind pretty much set, and rarely do they listen to the actual advice given. Usually if I make a "Recommend?" thread, my mind is truly open to the advice and opinion of those on the forums. If your mind is already set, what's the point of asking other peoples opinions and advice?
 
I enjoy the "Should I buy knife A or B?", which is answered with knives c-z, and the OP goes with a totally different knife. Commit, people!
 
It's hard to buy a recommended knife because recommendations never meet the original request. Someone will ask for recommendations on a $50 fixed blade under 6" and replies will be a $500 folder, a Busse chopper, and a firearm.
 
I enjoy the "Should I buy knife A or B?", which is answered with knives c-z, and the OP goes with a totally different knife. Commit, people!

No kidding. That's why I scan the threads like that, but don't reply.

Thread topic:
"Hey guys, I am looking for a 3 1/2" bladed folder with just one blade (non coated, no serrations please!) that has a better than average steel and is under $100 that I can use at work."

Answers:
"Get a Sebbie and be done with it!"

"A folding knife is a broken knife... why do you want that?"

"I like AUS8 and it serves me well, but then I am not a snob."

"What kind of work do you do? I am a mechanic and rarely get a chance to use a knife."

"I only buy American!"

"I had a terrible experience with XXXXX's customer service and will never buy another back pack from them again."

"Buy a SAK Forester, be ready for anything, and you can coat the blades when ready."

"You can get the XXXXX knife, and although it is coated, you can scrape it all off with minimal damage to the blade, or buy a $15 bottle of stripper, some gloves and a chemical mask and strip it yourself."

"I'm with you. Folks that don't like serrations don't understand how to use them!"

OP:

"I am looking at a tomahawk now, one that has a small saw in the handle. Anyone use one of these? They look like the exact thing I need."

Robert
 
The knives that I have impulse purchased over the years have never really satisfied me in the long run. I now prefer to do more research before purchasing, and reviews and recommendations based on personal experience are the best way to find what you need to know.
 
The only annoyance for me is "Recommend?" threads usually start and end with the OP's mind pretty much set, and rarely do they listen to the actual advice given. Usually if I make a "Recommend?" thread, my mind is truly open to the advice and opinion of those on the forums. If your mind is already set, what's the point of asking other peoples opinions and advice?

The point is seeking validation. I know it's a pretty common desire in us humans to want to know we made a good choice, but sheesh. If you've already made up your mind, why go through that whole grueling process? Just post the knife you bought and see if it gets shot with flamethrowers or receives praise.

Hell I think some guys on here don't even fart without asking if it's a good idea first.
 
The point is seeking validation. I know it's a pretty common desire in us humans to want to know we made a good choice, but sheesh. If you've already made up your mind, why go through that whole grueling process? Just post the knife you bought and see if it gets shot with flamethrowers or receives praise.

Hell I think some guys on here don't even fart without asking if it's a good idea first.

Yup, then after they order the knife they post another thread asking for opinions on the knife they just bought before they even have it. They don't actually want opinions, they are once again just seeking validation.
 
I guess since I don't have any customs yet, I only buy recommended knives, lol.

I don't throw out threads for people to tell me what to buy, but I certainly browse them for new suggestions of stuff to check out. Then I also scour the boards for reviews when I find something I'm interested in. You've got to do what you can to get a feel for them when 90% of the time you can't hold it before you buy it.
 
"Recommends" are good for discovering new knives. That's about it. I buy what I like.
 
No kidding. That's why I scan the threads like that, but don't reply.

Thread topic:
"Hey guys, I am looking for a 3 1/2" bladed folder with just one blade (non coated, no serrations please!) that has a better than average steel and is under $100 that I can use at work."

Answers:
"Get a Sebbie and be done with it!"

"A folding knife is a broken knife... why do you want that?"

"I like AUS8 and it serves me well, but then I am not a snob."

"What kind of work do you do? I am a mechanic and rarely get a chance to use a knife."

"I only buy American!"

"I had a terrible experience with XXXXX's customer service and will never buy another back pack from them again."

"Buy a SAK Forester, be ready for anything, and you can coat the blades when ready."

"You can get the XXXXX knife, and although it is coated, you can scrape it all off with minimal damage to the blade, or buy a $15 bottle of stripper, some gloves and a chemical mask and strip it yourself."

"I'm with you. Folks that don't like serrations don't understand how to use them!"

OP:

"I am looking at a tomahawk now, one that has a small saw in the handle. Anyone use one of these? They look like the exact thing I need."

Robert

That's exactly what I see when I read those posts- too funny.

I scan the threads for the read and to see if something pops up that I've never heard of. I'll never understand why people really ask though as it's usually about knives in the sub $50 arena and never ask wether they should buy the Sawby, the Raymond, or the Rassenti where the cost of buying the second or third place knife makes it prohibitive.
 
I actually bought one on a recommendation. The BRKT Bravo Necker 2, it is one of the best small fixed blades I've ever used. I didn't start the thread asking, but it kept coming up in a certain persons pictures here and in various handle materials, so one day I said, "why not give it a try?". Glad I did. Same thing happened with a simple Ontario Rat folder, I even bought one for my wife.
 
What irks me is when the OP doesn't answer questions aiming to narrow the search

or when OP posts and disappears, coming back over a week later saying they found something completely unrelated to the post that they like
 
In South Africa we only have a very limited choice as to what production knives are available.

I do look at what is recommended, but I only buy what I like and is currently available at a reasonable price, (our money is not worth very much at all).

There are many South African Custom makers who produce quality knives, but I cannot afford to buy these LOL.
 
CapitalizedLiving and midnight flyer hit the nail on the head - too funny :D

Definitely a lot of threads seeking recommendations or people seeking opinions on the knife they just purchased. As someone mentioned, they are mostly seeking validation. Knife purchases tend to be plagued by buyer's remorse. For the few guys who are specific with what they need, stick around to answer questions, and then follow through by researching and purchasing one of the recommendations - bravo sir.
 
Definitely a lot of threads seeking recommendations or people seeking opinions on the knife they just purchased. As someone mentioned, they are mostly seeking validation. Knife purchases tend to be plagued by buyer's remorse.

I think some of the purchasers need to be "propped up" after they get their new wonder knife. Their lives didn't really change any; their hair is still thinning, they can't hike any further than they used to, splitting wood isn't nearly as fast as with an axe, the knife is a little bigger than you thought, no one else seems to be "aroused" like you are when you pull your knife out (in fact the all famous nemesis of BF, the dreaded "sheeple" may even make fun of how much you spent), the knife isn't perfect like every single other person you read about that has that knife and in fact has a couple of nagging problems just short of causing you to send it back, and you can't find enough useful things to use the knife on to qualify buying it.

Sure, you can pull that handsome big boy out of your pocket and open your mail, cut a string, and yup, cut that sandwich right in two at lunch. No more messy letter openers, simply pulling a string, or using a plastic knife for your lunch. And yet, it still seems unsatisfying. You have to think sometimes... "man... did I really need S30V or Elmax to cut up an apple or my son's shoe lace?".

Worse, while fondling your new 8" bladed log splitting ultimate survival knife, you see on the news where a 9 year old Boy Scout lived in the woods with one piece of gum, some Pop Tarts, and drank stream water and ate a few bugs until he was found. No knife needed. But, you get some happiness out of knowing that if you were lost, you could have made a shelter. Then you think to yourself you need to put "practice shelter making" on your to do list. Then you read on the subject a bit and realize that having a great knife has almost nothing to do with survival and rescue. Nuts.

Finally, you realize how little you actually use your knife. Sure you substitute it for tasks that might be well suited to other tools (like the guys that go to restaurants and use their knives to cut their meat) and you do open those heavily taped FedEx boxes, but over all, you find yourself being careful with the new knife. So when it goes woods walking, or camping you carefully use it so it doesn't have to go to the spa. After you get it good and dirty, you take some quick pics for BF, then run in and clean it up as quickly as possible. After all, it cost more than any of the other knives you have and you can't risk any damage to it! This was a big decision; when could you afford another one? So you carry your old knives too, for those dirty tasks that might come up.

Then when carrying your old knives, you realize that all knives do pretty much the same thing... ouch...

Robert
 
Last edited:
Sometimes this board is like a Becker, ZT, Spyderco echo chamber for recommendations.
 
Back
Top