Who's got a Grail Story to share?

Joined
Mar 1, 2008
Messages
4,559
Some of us have spent a lot of time searching for A "Grail." Not the knife you saw a pic of and bought within a week. Not one you bought and swore off others. I am talking about that knife that has eluded you for years! That one low production number knife to complete a set.

The one that caught your eye, but you are always late to the party or couldn't afford it at the time. But you kept dreaming, searching, and hoping. After looking far and wide for what seams like an eternity and then.....IT happens! You stumble upon a table at a knife or gun show. You open a 4sale forum, or are surfing on a random knife website and there it is, THE GRAIL!!!

That knife that has escaped your capture for so long is finally there and staring you straight in the face. You try to play it cool, like when you are dealt pocket aces at the poker table, but your insides are screaming "I need my precious!" Then you negotiate with the dealer or you click the add to cart button or enter an extremely high bid and, it happens. Its finally yours.

All that time searching and dreaming has come to an end. You are finally going home or going crazy waiting on the mail for it to arrive. It finally shows up and it is everything you have always wanted. It's never leaving your little hoard of knives. This is what this thread is all about :)

Now, we have two rules in this thread that can not be broken to post a story.

1. You must currently own the knife. I know, it should be a given but if you dont have it still, it ain't your grail!

2. You must share at least one Picture in your original post telling us the story behind the knife.

That's it. Simple ain't it? :)

I look forward to reading these riveting tales of knife satisfaction!

-----------------------------------

My story:

I started hanging around on the porch in early 2012. It's easy to remember because not shortly after I took up a chair here, GEC was having a new pattern release. I had been reading for a few weeks, learning what I could. Admiring all these old knives posted on these pages. Learning about this new company that was producing high quality reproductions of old patterns, my interest was piqued. Then along came the buzz of this #79, the montana whittler. Coming from modern folders the micarta version looked great and I ordered it.

I loved the knife! It felt great in hand, road in my pocket well enough and it cut everything I threw at it. I posted about it and showed it off often. Then one day I got a PM from @Modoc ED asking me for my address and a little note saying dont ask questions. A few days later I open the package and to my surprise I was looking at a red boned, northfield version of the #79. I was shocked, elated and overjoyed. It planted the seed of the generosity of this forum. I love to do the same now to folks, thanks ED for that life lesson of community around here.

Back then collecting was not only off limits because of my new family, but also just not interesting. I used every knife, tried frame after frame and let go of any I didn't like for whatever reason. I didn't keep doubles and because I had the red bone, I sold my first. It's gone to two fellow members and I couldnt be happier it has found a great home with Rockon75 Rockon75

Anyways, my taste were constantly changing. I started longing for slimmer knives, easier to carry. I also started trending towards knives that had one blade with a belly and the other straight. Almost a year later GEC released the #79 whittlers thinner brother. A single spring knife with spear main blade and a small coping secondary. I ogled at all the dealer pics and finally settled on a unique Mexican bocote wood version. When it arrived it was the wrong one. I still loved the pattern itself but I returned it. I was experimenting and since I got to check it out already, I ordered something different. Can I go back and smack myself?

In january of each year GEC releases production totals for the previous year. When I read the 2013 list, I saw it for the first time. In the tidioute line, they released a micarta version. 5 of them to be exact! The hunt was on, I had to have this knife, my grail was born! I searched constantly. Never a mention. Never a picture, nothing ever! I have never seen it and never heard a peep that anyone owned it. They got snatched up in the background without a public whisper.

I was lucky enough that @paulhilborn noticed my sig line and sold me a red bone single spring. It was an amazing knife but at that point in my life I was needing funds and unfortunately had to get rid of it. The itch grew stronger.

About two weeks ago I took a stroll over to the bay to have a look around. I brouse it every once in awhile, but this time was different. This time, it was there!

Needless to say, at long last, it is in my possession and it is everything I built it up to be. When I opened the tube for the first time my senses had a party. That new oil smell just sucks you right in, it hits your nose with that oh so familiar scent. You run your fingers over those smooth, buffed covers. Your eyes are wide and focused exploring every detail. The blades sit just right. The transition from shiny bolster to those glorious covers is crisp and even. Your fingers grow impatient and you have to open the blades, inspect those grinds. Hows the action? Firm, snappy, loud, just right! My senses are pleased.

This knife is the culmination of my love for traditionals. It hits all the spots! It was my grail, now it's my Favorite. The search is finally over and I have it. Never thought I would see the day but boy am I basking in it.

I am sure some other grail will work itself into my life eventually but for now I am content. Hopefully some time in the future, I will have another story to add to this thread. After all, the hunt is half the fun!

Thanks for sticking out my long winded experience! I look forward to reading your grail stories, what makes it special to you and why you had to have it.


ufzHnCA.jpg
 
In 2014 I became interested in collecting knives in general and Barlows specifically . After a lot of looking , searching , shopping or whatever you want to call it , I decided that I really wanted a Barlow with Desert Ironwood or Amboyna handles for various reasons . The only company that I could find that did or would make them like that was Taylors Eye Witness and they were just cost prohibitive for me at the time . Finally in 2018 CK announced that he was having an SFO of 77 Barlows with one of the options as Desert Ironwood . For those of you who went through that , you probably can still feel the ups and downs that we went through . I ended up with what my Grail was at that time . I carry it from time to time but it is basically a Safe Queen and is always carried in a slip . I have a couple other knives that I have for scratching up .



Of course after you get The One , you have another one to call your Grail and I had one in mind and that was to get an American Made Lambfoot knife and you all know what happened then . In 2019 these happened .


But Wait : There is Always Another One right .
2 weeks before Christmas , after all the Christmas shopping was done , SWMBO looked at me and asked what did I want . Well for 2 or 3 years I had been eying an Arno Bernard fixed blade in Wart Hog Ivory . She made it happen .



Now , believe it or not , I have no Grail left , but I expect that it will only be a Temporary Condition .

Harry
 
Last edited:
Here's one I wrote about a couple of years ago -

Fifteen years ago Camillus collaborated with knifemaker Jerry Fisk on a line of knives they called OVB, "Our Very Best." Unlike the usual fare we see served in these parts, these knives were not folders, but rather fixed blades. Think bowies and hunters. Being a young man at the time, I was not willing to pay the then asking price for a knife that would see little use. Besides, I had better things to spend my money on, namely pretty girls and cheap alcohol. I could never quite get the image of those knives out of my mind though. They remained tucked away, filed under my "would be nice to have list."

I finally picked one up. A Camillus OVB "Fisk" Southwest Bowie in curly maple. At nearly 17" long, with a > 11" blade, holding it sends tingles down my spine. I can almost feel the spirit of James Bowie when she's in my hand. I still don't have much use for this knife, but I wanted her and she brings a smile to my face. These days that's enough.

To give a sense of scale, I placed the bowie next to a Camillus Sailor's knife. The Sailor's knife is not a small slipjoint at ~ 4 1/4" closed. It's still dwarfed by Blondie.

23913641137_59445e82bd_b.jpg


Here is what I think is an old catalog page of the Southwest.

24905187138_691af4a260_o.jpg

 
I have accumulated a lot of knives over the past 10-12 years, but the only real collection I have is of the Great Eastern pattern #5383__ Cuban Stockman. In 2007 they made 7 different handle materials in Tidioute guise, plus 14 different Northfields. In 2008 there were 12 more Tidioutes, 7 stainless GECs, and 2 more Northfields. 2011 completed the offerings so far, with 3 more Tidioutes and 7 more Northfields for a total of 52 different handle releases. By the end of 2017 I had acquired 49 of the 52 different releases, and the only ones left were the 2008 Northfield Burnt Stag, the 2008 Tidioute Good & Plenty and the 2011 Northfield Black Stag. They only made 6, 2, and 2 of each, respectively.

Early in 2018 one of the 2008 Burnt Stags came up for auction on the 'bay, but it was a 1 of 1 Proto. Needless to say, I was pretty stoked to grab it. I noted it's progress in the bidding each night until with just a few minutes to go it was at $150 or so. Terrific, as I knew they were super scarce and might go for over $200, which was VERY high for any GEC at that time, and the Cubans never brought really big money. Finally, with just seconds left in the auction I bid a CRAZY high bid of $350 just to make absolutely sure I would win it. Just two more ticks of the clock and the auction was over, with a winning bid of . . . . $855! I was literally in shock, and felt like I had swallowed a quick acting poison. Impossibly to my thinking, that winning bid meant that at least two people had bid well over $800. At that point I was sure I had no chance to ever complete the collection.

Wonderfully, in January of 2019 another one of the '08 Burnt Stags came up for auction again, this time one of the five regular, non-proto models. Again I bid $350 at the last moment and was finally rewarded, with a winning bid of $225. I may never even have a chance at the two remaining ultra-rare Cubans, but getting a successful second chance at the 1 of 6 Burnt Stag makes it my grail so far.

85GJtd7.jpg
 
Barlows with special blades always tickled my fancy. Having collected Schrade Cut Cos for many years, I was always on the lookout, especially for a Spey blade! More than 10 years after it became an idea, (and several years ago!) I finally found one in decent "collectible" condition! It eventually inspired a TC Barlow with a Spey, and yes I still have it!!:cool:
Schrade made few it seems!!:rolleyes:
SCC Spey 1.jpg SCC Spey 2.jpg SCC Spey 3.jpg SCC Spey 4.jpg SCC Spey 5.jpg SCC Spey 6.jpg
It doesn't take much to make me feel proud and happy!!:D
 
I'm not sure if this is going to be a boring story in comparison to some of the grails here and I've told it before but I got into the whole knife thing looking for the 'one'. The pocket knife that would live in my pocket for a decade or decades. Whether in the city, in the countryside, at prayer or at rest. Due to carry laws in the country I live in and the ones I travel to slipjoints were practically mandated and to be honest, they fit my style and image, I'm a pipe smoker and Single Malt man after all. :)

I went through the usual processes. From the Case Sodbuster and Opinel to Queen, GEC, Buck, Northwoods, CSC and beyond to modern slipjoints with the Lionsteel offerings. Every traditional blade shape and style. Multiple blades and single blades. Cheap steel and super steel. I learned quickly that I didn't like carbon steel, that I had to drop ship my knives for reprofiling as a given and that a FFG TBE blade was wonderful to use but not all that easy to find out of the factory, that I didn't like crinked or off centre blades and a whole bunch of other preferences tuned by real world use.

Once when doing a search online an image popped up of my grail knife. Spear and Pen, opposite sides, single spring and perfect length. Only problem was that it was discontinued. Oh and it came from a manufacturer I'd so far discounted as supremely boring and having very soft steel. It was a Victorinox Settler. I bought a Vic Pruner on trial as a 'close as I could manage' solution and carried it for a year falling in love with the quality of the SAK and learning that whatever the steel could do in tests, I loved using and sharpening was so easy. It kept slicing long after it should have stopped cutting cleanly. Then someone on a forum suggested that if I wanted a Settler, why didn't I just make one? I have the manual skill set of a drunken elephant in a wheelchair but I took a second hand Spartan, a local machine shop and a ball peen hammer and simply removed the opener layer. For $9 plus a bit of labour for drilling out the pins, I had made my grail. The one I wanted. No it's not as pretty or exciting as a beautiful GEC but it is the 'one'.

sakedcnew_1.jpg


I'd like some Gabon Ebony scales for it but otherwise, it's the perfect quintessential pocket knife.
 
I have been playing knives over 35 years. Blade show in early 2000’s met Tim Britton. Saw an ad later for a teardrop in mammoth. Took years to have $300 for one knife together. I found a Marbles fixed blade at an antique store for $20. Not really into fixed blades. Took it to Blade a few years back, sold it for $300, went to Tims table and ordered and paid for my knife. I received it quicker than I thought I would have, still love it!
DEamVgD.jpg
 
I'm not sure what it was about the "Platypus" that piqued my interest. I saw this knife pattern, made by Terry Primos, and thought I just had to have one. As a side note, the Platypus name came from a comment Terry's wife made regarding its appearance.

Terry was a an ABS Bladesmith that had the privilege of being mentored by Jerry Fisk. He had quite a following and I purchased a couple of his knives, but no Platypus. I kept my eye open to all the knife websites I knew of, where I'd seen Terry's knives sold. No Platypus. At the same time I got on Terry's waiting list, because it seemed like the odds of me finding a Platypus were pretty slim. This was around 2005, I think.

Time dragged on, sans Platypus. Then my dreams of acquiring one of these knives were shattered. I found out in October of 2006 that Terry was giving up his knife making. He wasn't able to catch up on his waiting list before he pulled the plug. I was Platypusless (is that a word?).

Fast forward to 6 or 7 years later, I think. While browsing the Exchange what to my wandering eyes did appear? A Platypus! Thomason was selling his! I pulled the trigger so fast, I'm not sure I even noticed the price!

When I had it in hand it was everything I thought it would be! A wonderful piece of work by a true craftsman!

My Platypus, hand forged 1084 with a ss guard and Curly Maple handle. Wonderful chatoyance!

Here's my precious! Pic taken today, while the snow piles up outside my office window.
YWcmAfh.jpg

Pic taken in 2013. Probably shortly after I got the knife.
IMG_20130410_111655_982.jpg


Great idea for a thread, Jeff!
 
Platypusless, it's a word now, love it Gary and a wonderful knife indeed.

All of the stories shared so far are a joy to read! I am glad to see everyone playing along. The idea came to me as I waited patiently for mine to arrive in the mail and I started my draft about two weeks ago. Looking forward to more tales of the grails :)

Rockon75 Rockon75 so happy to see that guy, always puts a smile on my face :) it looks well loved my friend. Thanks for the pic!
 
I bought my first Buck knife in 69-70 from the PX. Over the years I have accumulated quite a few.
I'll try not to make this much of a shaggy dog story.
In 2005, Thompson Center Arms added TC No 15, Buck Nessmuk to their collectibles. I didn't see it until the edition was sold out and the few that were for sale were way over(one here on the Bucks For Sale, $500.00) the issue price of $161.95. I loved the shape and history of the knife and being by Buck made it a must have. I had been running labrador retrievers in field trials and had a lot invested in that venture so had to shelve it(buying the 'muk) until I got out of the field trial game.

Three or four years ago I saw one had sold on the bay and it rekindled my desire for this knife. I remembered someone posted on the Buck Forum about a BF member's ability to dig out obscure Bucks so I messaged him. He got back to me with a link to a thread in another forum where a fellow was asking about the value of the Thompson Center No 15 Buck Nessmuk...I was so excited that I didn't notice that it was a two year old post! I joined the forum messaged him and ask if he still had it and if he was willing to sell. I even told him of the price the one had sold for! He lived in Canada, so after many messages, emails and help from one of the BF mods(who lives there) with shipping and money exchanges with/from Canada, the knife #146 of 150, I have wanted for years is now with me.
001.JPG

002.JPG

005.JPG

004.JPG

003.JPG
 
I was given my first knife by my grandfather when I was 7. It was a well used Queen Steel bone handled single blade barlow. I carry it for years and finally retired it as the blade was nicked up and the bone scales were badly cracked. I still have it as my family treasure, but I always wanted another like it. I've carried a variety of Queen barlows over the years. While cruising ebay on day a few months ago, there it was. A perfect match for the one granddad gave me! Bid and won! Now at 75 years old, I've come full circle. A Queen Steel bone handled single blade barlow!







Rich
 
I bought my first Buck knife in 69-70 from the PX. Over the years I have accumulated quite a few.
I'll try not to make this much of a shaggy dog story.
In 2005, Thompson Center Arms added TC No 15, Buck Nessmuk to their collectibles. I didn't see it until the edition was sold out and the few that were for sale were way over(one here on the Bucks For Sale, $500.00) the issue price of $161.95. I loved the shape and history of the knife and being by Buck made it a must have. I had been running labrador retrievers in field trials and had a lot invested in that venture so had to shelve it(buying the 'muk) until I got out of the field trial game.

Three or four years ago I saw one had sold on the bay and it rekindled my desire for this knife. I remembered someone posted on the Buck Forum about a BF member's ability to dig out obscure Bucks so I messaged him. He got back to me with a link to a thread in another forum where a fellow was asking about the value of the Thompson Center No 15 Buck Nessmuk...I was so excited that I didn't notice that it was a two year old post! I joined the forum messaged him and ask if he still had it and if he was willing to sell. I even told him of the price the one had sold for! He lived in Canada, so after many messages, emails and help from one of the BF mods(who lives there) with shipping and money exchanges with/from Canada, the knife #146 of 150, I have wanted for years is now with me.
001.JPG

002.JPG

005.JPG

004.JPG

003.JPG
That's a great story and a great looking Muk!
 
But Wait : There is Always Another One right.

2 weeks before Christmas , after all the Christmas shopping was done , SWMBO looked at me and asked what did I want . Well for 2 or 3 years I had been eying an Arno Bernard fixed blade in Wart Hog Ivory . She made it happen .



Now , believe it or not , I have no Grail left , but I expect that it will only be a Temporary Condition .
I will probably get a wart hog ivory. I picked up a giraffe bone AB Squirrel a couple weeks ago. I don't really have any grail knives since I don't collect and seek out old stuff. Hiatuses in knife buying are generally short lived for me too.

Added: I was never really hung up on elephant ivory for knife handles. But with the restriction business on the trade over the last few years I wanted something in elephant ivory just to have. This was back when KSF would periodically have a few of their Northwoods done in Elephant ivory. So, I got a Madison Barlow (single blade) in elephant ivory back when they were offered. It was never a knife to use but I just like getting it out and fondling it. Is it a grail? Perhaps as I really like the Madison Barlow and elephant ivory to boot! Added a picture of the ivory Madison Barlow below.
DSC03569ed.jpg

So, the Wart hog ivory is something that appeals to me just to have and I don't honestly know if I would use it, but I would certainly enjoy owning such.
 
Last edited:
I was given my first knife by my grandfather when I was 7. It was a well used Queen Steel bone handled single blade barlow. I carry it for years and finally retired it as the blade was nicked up and the bone scales were badly cracked. I still have it as my family treasure, but I always wanted another like it. I've carried a variety of Queen barlows over the years. While cruising ebay on day a few months ago, there it was. A perfect match for the one granddad gave me! Bid and won! Now at 75 years old, I've come full circle. A Queen Steel bone handled single blade barlow!







Rich
That's a nice story and one I can relate to. My first good knife was a Case Barlow back during my sub-teen years. I don't even remember the precise scales but I believe it was sawcut bone. Anyway last year at the Dalton GA knife show I found one of about the same vintage that was in good shape and at a price I was willing to pay. Got it. Like my previous post, this was a nostalgia thing for me like you and not one I really intend to use but I could easily enough.
IMG_4823ed.jpg
 
Last edited:
Good idea for a thread.....

I had a few Case slipjoints (Blue stockmans) to begin. My first GEC was a #23 Pioneer with stag that I bought here on BF. I happen to be carrying that same #23 today. I was blown away by the fit, finish and overall construction of the knife.

Deciding that I needed another GEC, I found a Blue #53 cuban on the bay and bid a high to me $100 for it. Won the auction for I think $90. Score. My GEC Blue Stockman turned out to be a 1 of 35 Watersnakes. I decided not to use it and my slide down the slippery slope had begun.

49501933558_828ff6128b_w_d.jpg


It wasn't hard to find a few more Watersnakes at a vendor site. I just kept putting off the purchase. After all one of them was $150 in 2010. They were unreasonably priced. I passed. They sold.

The hunt began. I scoured knife sites until I located the #73 Watersnakes several years later on the bay. It was a perfectly reasonable $70.

49501933693_1253bd2c57_w_d.jpg


A few more years and I found a new to ebay seller who had some very nice #53/54's on sale. A few messages exchanged and indeed the missing piece was on it's way to me for $10 more than he paid for it.

My grail knife was the #54 Watersnakes HJ 1 of 5.

49501933608_480644c1e4_w_d.jpg


Of course on the way to the complete set I bought too many knives and made a few friends along the way .....

Here's 1 of 5 possible complete Watersnakes sets from 2008 ....

49501933378_0487f31a2c_w_d.jpg


Thanks for reading my story.

Mark
 
Here's one I wrote about a couple of years ago -

Fifteen years ago Camillus collaborated with knifemaker Jerry Fisk on a line of knives they called OVB, "Our Very Best." Unlike the usual fare we see served in these parts, these knives were not folders, but rather fixed blades. Think bowies and hunters. Being a young man at the time, I was not willing to pay the then asking price for a knife that would see little use. Besides, I had better things to spend my money on, namely pretty girls and cheap alcohol. I could never quite get the image of those knives out of my mind though. They remained tucked away, filed under my "would be nice to have list."

I finally picked one up. A Camillus OVB "Fisk" Southwest Bowie in curly maple. At nearly 17" long, with a > 11" blade, holding it sends tingles down my spine. I can almost feel the spirit of James Bowie when she's in my hand. I still don't have much use for this knife, but I wanted her and she brings a smile to my face. These days that's enough.

To give a sense of scale, I placed the bowie next to a Camillus Sailor's knife. The Sailor's knife is not a small slipjoint at ~ 4 1/4" closed. It's still dwarfed by Blondie.

23913641137_59445e82bd_b.jpg


Here is what I think is an old catalog page of the Southwest.

24905187138_691af4a260_o.jpg

Christian, I meant to comment on your post earlier. I just love the OVB Bowie! Jerry Fisk designed a superb knife there, and Camillus' execution was really excellent! I've been tempted many times over the years, but I've managed to refrain from pulling the trigger. Thanks for reminding me. I think?
Congrats on tracking down that fine knife!
 
Barlows with special blades always tickled my fancy. Having collected Schrade Cut Cos for many years, I was always on the lookout, especially for a Spey blade! More than 10 years after it became an idea, (and several years ago!) I finally found one in decent "collectible" condition! It eventually inspired a TC Barlow with a Spey, and yes I still have it!!:cool:
Schrade made few it seems!!:rolleyes:
View attachment 1279081 View attachment 1279082 View attachment 1279083 View attachment 1279084 View attachment 1279085 View attachment 1279086
It doesn't take much to make me feel proud and happy!!:D

That was an ebay win right? I still regret not bidding on one 4 or so years ago :)
 
Back
Top