Why (and how) do you collect knives

Joined
Apr 26, 2019
Messages
35
Why do you collect knives? Is it for the craftsmanship? The utility? Do you just like having something to collect?

And additionally, ho do you collect them? Do you collect only one brand, metal, blade-style, etc. or do you just collect whatever knife strikes your fancy?

I'm rather new to the knife world, and I'm still trying to figure out what I want the scope of my collection to be so, I thought I may as well ask you guys what your collections are like!

(P.S. I'm new here so apologies if this thread idea has been done to death. Pleas feel free to ignore if it has! :p)
 
Why?
I've got the sickness, and I've got it bad.

How?
Just whatever seems cool. Big fan of weird opening mechanisms and designs, so I have a lot of CRKTs, but they are by no means all that I buy.

Oh and welcome to the forums, prepare your wallet. Please post some pictures of your collection in the Collection thread.
 
After the hammer/bludgeon, the knife is man's oldest tool, there's an appreciation for the history, and the evolution of the idea, of a personal cutting tool. I appreciate fine craftsmanship, in the case of handmade knives. I like quality materials and good machining, in the case of production knives. I also like having things that no one else I know has. Or, in the case of handmade knives, something that nobody else has. Exclusivity. Custom means having a knife made to your specifications and/or design, not necessarily just picking from a list of options. And I like the looks on the faces of friends when they see what I am carrying today. Tomorrow it may be something completely different.

And because The Badassery, the shelf above my computer, would not be nearly as impressive with a bunch of Beanie Babies.

Among other reasons....
 
Last edited:
Oh and welcome to the forums, prepare your wallet. Please post some pictures of your collection in the Collection thread.
Thanks! I put a picture of my humble collection in the thread you mentioned ;)

And I like the looks on the faces of friends when see what I am carrying today. Tomorrow it may be something completely different.
I can definitely understand this. Waking up and picking what knife to carry today does seem quite cool to me.
 
Last edited:
I'm another pocket knife "accumulator". I've always liked knives. I've carried one on a daily basis as a handy tool to have in my pocket for some six decades.

These days I buy whatever knife interests me. I like to try different styles, patterns, and blade steels. I have a fair number of modern knives. I have a LOT of traditional pocket knives.
 
Trial and error most of my life.

Hahahahaha! A fellow bumbling cutler!

I've neither rhyme nor reason when it comes to amassing knives. I get what I like.

Why knives? I have no idea. I don't have fangs or claws, so they come in handy.

I try to buy quality, and I give away a ton of knives to friends, family, co-workers...

It's better than a meth habit, and I have that on good authority.
 
Actually a topic I love.

I did a lot of the trial and error, buying whatever I liked the looks of, starting with cheap crappy knives. Eventually I started to spend a bit more.

I now no longer just buy things because I like the looks of them. I did that a lot and ended up with a lot of knives I had no real affinity for and would never end up using. Now, I have several "collecting criteria" as well as some "deal breaker criteria" and try to buy (or not buy) only within this defined range, as it gives my collection specificity and continuity, and knives following these criteria are the ones most likely to stick around at this point. If I buy outside these criteria, I usually end up regretting the knife and sell it.

I buy only a few brands/makers at this point (the majority of my knives are made by 4 makers, with a few odds and ends thrown in that fit my "criteria"), and generally more on the expensive/custom side. I have no interest in accumulation per se so I don't need a bunch of budget friendly users - I just need a few, since if I lose one or whatever I can just get another. I am no longer fascinated enough with just "knives" in general to buy lots of stuff to test out. I use my users, and try to plan my next important acquisition responsibly. Generally, I like bolstered micarta folders, bolstered CF folders, micarta handled fixed blades, fancy OTF's, and specific CRK stuff (which actually run against my general dislike of full Ti handled knives).

So I have been working on a fewer/better plan and am paring down to just pieces that are great (to me). I am down to 50'ish knives, but out of denial and not wanting to know the total bill on those I do not add it up.

As I've gotten a bit "better" at it, I enjoy it more - more focus, more hunting, and less regret and knives to sell at a loss.
 
Cool I was lookin’ for a thread to post this into instead of startin’ a new thread.

Why do I collect/accumulate knives?

Somebody asked me "the" question we as knife people are always asked and after answering his question I thought this was the best answer I've come up with in 40+ years so I thought I'd share.

Why do I collect/accumulate knives? Wow! If I could answer that effectively I'd save myself a lot of money on therapy.

I guest I'd have to break it out into a couple different areas.

1) Historical
2) Functionality
3) Aesthetics
4) Emotional

Historically: It's man's 3rd oldest tool preceded by his brain and a rock/hammer first. There's something about a tool that can trace it's roots back a half a million years. There's a lot of history between that first piece of chipped rock early man picked up realizing it made separating things, (skin from meat/flesh from bone, branches from trees and even trees from their earthen trap) and today's modern edged tools that allowed us to conquer our environment.

Here's an old 1800s Josef Sziraki Pearl Lobster I happened across in a box lot at an estate sale.

cn5Ynkw.jpg


Functionality: There's no such thing as that "one" knife, if that were true there'd be no reason for places like this, we'd all have the same knife and we'd use it for everything, end of discussion. There's a problem though, there's no such thing as that one perfect knife. That's why we have different patterns, some blade shapes and geometries are better at certain tasks than others and that's why I collect. One knife will never serve all my needs perfectly so I'll spend the rest of my life trying and searching for the best compromise or the exact/best tool for the specific job.

When it comes to functionality you can build a collection on Swiss Army Knives alone. One of the first to try to fit as many functions into a pocket knife as possible and certainly still tryin'.

zQDeyhg.jpg


Aesthetics: Pretty self explanatory, I love a beautiful handcrafted knife, when the cutler's hit his stride and everything comes together to create a functional piece of art/jewelry.and what person doesn't like surrounding themselves with beautiful things right? :)

Some knives I collect because they look cool while being knives too.

DtNDa9t.jpg


Emotional: This covers everything from knives my Old Man and grandfather carried to gifts from friends whether it's a $5 yard sales knife or a custom a friend's made for or given me, this is the hardest category to explain, Knives just speak to me, some of my most prized knives are crazy Franklin Mint knives given to me by well meaning family and friends. The fact that they took the time to get me something they know so little about means a lot so I have a few "novelty" knives and even a few gems they got lucky with.

I have many knives that fit into this category from my Old Man's hunting knives form 45 years ago and my grandfather's pocket knife from a hundred years ago or like this gift from a friend because he knew I liked knives.

np2uHuh.jpg
 
I buy until the Wife (#3) complains... then I get a new wife... o_O
More expensive than a new knife, but a good move. ;) I collect whatever is new, different (getting difficult after 450++:rolleyes:) and interesting. The variety available is astounding. :eek: Sharing info and opinions on BF is part of the fun. :thumbsup:
 
Cool I was lookin’ for a thread to post this into instead of startin’ a new thread.

Why do I collect/accumulate knives?

Somebody asked me "the" question we as knife people are always asked and after answering his question I thought this was the best answer I've come up with in 40+ years so I thought I'd share.

Why do I collect/accumulate knives? Wow! If I could answer that effectively I'd save myself a lot of money on therapy.

I guest I'd have to break it out into a couple different areas.

1) Historical
2) Functionality
3) Aesthetics
4) Emotional

Historically: It's man's 3rd oldest tool preceded by his brain and a rock/hammer first. There's something about a tool that can trace it's roots back a half a million years. There's a lot of history between that first piece of chipped rock early man picked up realizing it made separating things, (skin from meat/flesh from bone, branches from trees and even trees from their earthen trap) and today's modern edged tools that allowed us to conquer our environment.

Here's an old 1800s Josef Sziraki Pearl Lobster I happened across in a box lot at an estate sale.

cn5Ynkw.jpg


Functionality: There's no such thing as that "one" knife, if that were true there'd be no reason for places like this, we'd all have the same knife and we'd use it for everything, end of discussion. There's a problem though, there's no such thing as that one perfect knife. That's why we have different patterns, some blade shapes and geometries are better at certain tasks than others and that's why I collect. One knife will never serve all my needs perfectly so I'll spend the rest of my life trying and searching for the best compromise or the exact/best tool for the specific job.

When it comes to functionality you can build a collection on Swiss Army Knives alone. One of the first to try to fit as many functions into a pocket knife as possible and certainly still tryin'.

zQDeyhg.jpg


Aesthetics: Pretty self explanatory, I love a beautiful handcrafted knife, when the cutler's hit his stride and everything comes together to create a functional piece of art/jewelry.and what person doesn't like surrounding themselves with beautiful things right? :)

Some knives I collect because they look cool while being knives too.

DtNDa9t.jpg


Emotional: This covers everything from knives my Old Man and grandfather carried to gifts from friends whether it's a $5 yard sales knife or a custom a friend's made for or given me, this is the hardest category to explain, Knives just speak to me, some of my most prized knives are crazy Franklin Mint knives given to me by well meaning family and friends. The fact that they took the time to get me something they know so little about means a lot so I have a few "novelty" knives and even a few gems they got lucky with.

I have many knives that fit into this category from my Old Man's hunting knives form 45 years ago and my grandfather's pocket knife from a hundred years ago or like this gift from a friend because he knew I liked knives.

np2uHuh.jpg
This is a very well put together post and I completely agree with all your points!

Personally I only want to buy knives I know I'll use, and I have a rule that if I wouldn't use the knife it's not for me, but maybe that'll change. Maybe the deeper I get into this hobby the more I'll find myself wanting knives just for the art/beauty of them and never use them. Only time will tell... :p

Edit: After reading the "Curse of the Safe Queen" thread I think I've solidified my stance. I will only look to buy knives I have no fear in using, and will make darn sure I use any knife I buy! ;)
 
Last edited:
FlamingMoe FlamingMoe Welcome to BFC!

This topic pops up now and again, but it’s probably not beat to death.

Why?
-I appreciate well crafted mechanical items.
-Utility & preparedness.
-They’re just cool!
-It’s a guy thing (no offense to the ladies!)

How?
-Trial & error to a degree.
-I’ve become partial to Spyderco, ZT, and CRK.
-I’ve made a decision to avoid “premium” Chinese-made knives for the time being. Some of them are pretty neat, but in that price range I generally find other knives more appealing.
-I was an active purchaser on the exchange for about 2 years.
-Now I mostly look for deals or incentives from retailers. I don’t find them often, but that’s fine as my acquisition has slowed dramatically. I can be patient.
-Sometimes I buy knives for gifts. When I buy one for a specific person, I might buy an extra or two for future gifting.
 
I love knives is correct. I love guitars, paintings, cars & trucks, women..to some degree, scotch....and dogs.
These are a few of my favorite things.
They just are. Here is what knives do for me the others can't.
They seem to be impervious to time to me, if treated well (Remember, this is about knives not women. My 17 yo daughter loves knives as well by the way.). My nice ones, even my semi nice ones, I think are going to last a long time. Maybe longer than what is discussed here. Here people talk about a lifetime or more. I personally think a ti/super steel or many other combinations could last hundreds and maybe thousands of years (remember, we are talking knives, not guitars. I get great joy from my Martin, Tele, and Gibson, but they will only last 200 maybe 300 years before they fall to pieces or change to be quite useless.).
My Grandfather bought me a new knife every year from the time I was about 5 or 6. He let me pick. I always got the same Case knife. Biggest single blade they made at the time. I either lost them, or my mother secreted them away. Wish I still just had one of them...so there's that. My Grandfather showed me what they were for and what they weren't. The right tool for the job.
I am in the car business.
I have had over 1000 cars. Seriously. Still love cars. It's a true waste of money. We all still have them...and 500-1000 dollar cell phones. That justifies parts of this.
Painting is my true passion. I do watercolors on the best paper with the best paint I can get. I learned very early painters top out well after their dead and gone. I've seen paintings hundreds of years old and appreciate them to no end. Don't know how long they will last. Few 1000's years? Knives. Longer I think.
I've had two instances where I needed a knife due to vehicle crashes. It was a time when I didn't carry one EDC. That never happened again. If you see me, I have a knife on me. Except on a plane or a courthouse ect...
Scotch will kill you, dogs are awesome but not perfect.
I have only one knife I will never use, it belongs in a museum and will one day. The rest of my knives have specific purposes and are used.
If someone messes with my family or me and I can't get to my gun....my knife is there. That is not popular to discuss here and I get that. It's still a fact IMHO. I was cut once and I ran away, after a punch. I had a knife on me. No one wins a knife fight...the guy who bleeds out last I guess.
Good luck with knives. Don't get more addicted than your wallet can bear. Lifes too short to have a crappy knife, guitar, car woman or anything else. Remember they are just things...like Van Gogh's.
 
Cool I was lookin’ for a thread to post this into instead of startin’ a new thread.

Why do I collect/accumulate knives?

Somebody asked me "the" question we as knife people are always asked and after answering his question I thought this was the best answer I've come up with in 40+ years so I thought I'd share.

Why do I collect/accumulate knives? Wow! If I could answer that effectively I'd save myself a lot of money on therapy.

I guest I'd have to break it out into a couple different areas.

1) Historical
2) Functionality
3) Aesthetics
4) Emotional

Historically: It's man's 3rd oldest tool preceded by his brain and a rock/hammer first. There's something about a tool that can trace it's roots back a half a million years. There's a lot of history between that first piece of chipped rock early man picked up realizing it made separating things, (skin from meat/flesh from bone, branches from trees and even trees from their earthen trap) and today's modern edged tools that allowed us to conquer our environment.

Here's an old 1800s Josef Sziraki Pearl Lobster I happened across in a box lot at an estate sale.

cn5Ynkw.jpg


Functionality: There's no such thing as that "one" knife, if that were true there'd be no reason for places like this, we'd all have the same knife and we'd use it for everything, end of discussion. There's a problem though, there's no such thing as that one perfect knife. That's why we have different patterns, some blade shapes and geometries are better at certain tasks than others and that's why I collect. One knife will never serve all my needs perfectly so I'll spend the rest of my life trying and searching for the best compromise or the exact/best tool for the specific job.

When it comes to functionality you can build a collection on Swiss Army Knives alone. One of the first to try to fit as many functions into a pocket knife as possible and certainly still tryin'.

zQDeyhg.jpg


Aesthetics: Pretty self explanatory, I love a beautiful handcrafted knife, when the cutler's hit his stride and everything comes together to create a functional piece of art/jewelry.and what person doesn't like surrounding themselves with beautiful things right? :)

Some knives I collect because they look cool while being knives too.

DtNDa9t.jpg


Emotional: This covers everything from knives my Old Man and grandfather carried to gifts from friends whether it's a $5 yard sales knife or a custom a friend's made for or given me, this is the hardest category to explain, Knives just speak to me, some of my most prized knives are crazy Franklin Mint knives given to me by well meaning family and friends. The fact that they took the time to get me something they know so little about means a lot so I have a few "novelty" knives and even a few gems they got lucky with.

I have many knives that fit into this category from my Old Man's hunting knives form 45 years ago and my grandfather's pocket knife from a hundred years ago or like this gift from a friend because he knew I liked knives.

np2uHuh.jpg

Ted, is that a built-in fishhook sharpener on that KA-BAR? Pretty damn cool. :thumbsup:
 
Yea it is, the scales are gorgeous but they’re celluloid. I’m just waiting for the inevitable meltdown that accompanies celluloid. In the meantime I take a lot of pics.
 
Back
Top