- Joined
- Sep 26, 2008
- Messages
- 8,160
I’ve been wondering about this subject for a while now and thought I’d throw it out here.
Why are Buck collectors different than most other types of collectors? From my experience with my small gun collection, having an original gun refurbished, refinished and things like that, ruins the collector value of it. Why doesn't the same apply to Buck knives?
Example, I have my Dad’s sweet little Winchester model 62A purchased before 1954, probably in the late 40’s that was given to me by my Mom after Dad passed away. It’s well used and although it’s in pretty good shape, we decided to see about having it restored to as new condition. I took it to an old time gunsmith and Winchester collector, but he said no way, and to leave it as is. Not that I’d ever sell it, but he told me it would cut the value in half if I had it “restored”.
I also see on the pawn shop and picker shows on TV, where original is best and refurbished or restored nearly always brings a lower price. One exception to that seems to be auto's but that's a different story I think.
Why is it different with Buck knives?? It seems as though the norm when someone finds a vintage or antique Buck in somewhat less than pristine condition and shows it off here, the first (or maybe the second) thing recommended is a trip to Buck for a spa job which doesn't seem to affect it's value and may even increase it for some.
I’m not sure that I understand the difference between Bucks and other collectables. Any thoughts??
Why are Buck collectors different than most other types of collectors? From my experience with my small gun collection, having an original gun refurbished, refinished and things like that, ruins the collector value of it. Why doesn't the same apply to Buck knives?
Example, I have my Dad’s sweet little Winchester model 62A purchased before 1954, probably in the late 40’s that was given to me by my Mom after Dad passed away. It’s well used and although it’s in pretty good shape, we decided to see about having it restored to as new condition. I took it to an old time gunsmith and Winchester collector, but he said no way, and to leave it as is. Not that I’d ever sell it, but he told me it would cut the value in half if I had it “restored”.
I also see on the pawn shop and picker shows on TV, where original is best and refurbished or restored nearly always brings a lower price. One exception to that seems to be auto's but that's a different story I think.
Why is it different with Buck knives?? It seems as though the norm when someone finds a vintage or antique Buck in somewhat less than pristine condition and shows it off here, the first (or maybe the second) thing recommended is a trip to Buck for a spa job which doesn't seem to affect it's value and may even increase it for some.
I’m not sure that I understand the difference between Bucks and other collectables. Any thoughts??

Last edited: