Why are Chris Reeves' knives the best folder knives, i.e. the Umnumzaan?

Joined
Jan 9, 2010
Messages
43
I noticed the Umnumzaan usesCPM S30V stainless steel. Isn't VG-10 the best steel?

Why else are Chris Reeves better than Benchmade, Spyderco, and all the other premium folding knife brands other than being more rare?

I am interested in buying an Umnumzaan, but just want to get your opinions in why it is worth $400?:thumbup:
 
You may want to do a search for topics like this. Everyone is going to have an opinion on this and what you are going to see as the common theme is that the fit and finish of the Chris Reeve folders is among the best in the business. People will argue until the end of time about whether or not it is worth the price, and it will continue to be a completely subjective decision. I personally think they are well worth the money. Ill save you some time and tell you to go ahead and buy one. If you do not like it, you will lose next to nothing selling it on the secondary market.

ETA: I see you are looking at the Umnumzaan. Fantastic knife. Smooth, Smooth, Smooth. Excellent EDC knife. Did I mention Smooth?
 
Google it and watch videos and read reveiws. Sometimes it just takes holding one and using one to appreciate it.
 
I waited quite awhile to get my umnumzaan, ( got mine in a trade in the end ). Once I had it in hand, I wondered why I did not get one the moment it came out. Ever since I got it, my sebbie has been a safe queen; and I love my regular sebenza. If you keep an eye out, you can get one for $350 NIB from someone that may not like it or need cash. Its basically an upgraded sebenza. Its a great knife and I highly recommend it. What are you waiting for ??
 
S30V was developed with CRK's input, so it would make sense for him to use it.
 
VG-10 and S30V are similar steels on terms of toughness and edge retention. You're unlikely to notice a difference unless you go looking for one. There is no 'best steel.'
VG-10 is a Japanese steel, and S30V is a newer American powder steel. Both are technologically advanced and chemically complex, but are both more similar to each other than either steel is to say, 1095.

'Why they are worth it' is a sensitive question around here. People cite the knife's design and ergonomics, and I agree, but ultimately this is a matter of user preference. People cite the superior materials - S30V, phosphor-bronze and aerospace-grade titanium - but these materials all appear on knives from those other brands that you mention, Benchmade, Spyderco, etc. I can't say that Reeve knives are better, though I personally believe so. In my strict opinion, there are two things that make Reeve's knives as good as they are: the fit and finish, which is top-tier, and all the little hand-fitted details that go into every knife. Things like the pivot-bushing system on the Sebenza, or the perforated washers on the Umnumzaan, and a half-dozen other little details that I won't bother listing. Things that improve the function, and slow the wearing of the knife to an almost unnoticeable rate. At that level of fit and finish - which is close to within several thousandths of an inch - most of those things have to be done by hand, and aren't typically seen in knives from other companies. It's that hand-finished, hand-loved attention to detail that to me, makes Reeve's knives worth the price.

Lately the CRK owners on this board have been dealing with the exact same questions over and over, from people who are skeptical about CRKs and the price/value ratio.

All we ever say, albeit awkwardly and in many more words than this, is that we believe Reeve's knives are worth the price. Some people accept the advice, and some people keep arguing. Some people pull the trigger and buy a CRK, and some do not. Of those who do, most (in my experience) are impressed, and some are not.

Don't get me wrong, you ask a reasonable question, but very often such things have quickly degenerated into flame wars and pointlss, endless arguments. For that reason, I'm trying to be frank and delicate, to defuse those things before they happen.

If you like knives, and you have sufficient disposable income to spend on one of Reeve's pieces, I and others would suggest you go for it. The best case scenario is that the design, the F&F, and overall quality blow you away. The worst case scenario is that you are underwhelmed, in which case you can turn around and sell the knife for only slightly less than what you bought it for. One of the nice things about Reeve knives - and in my opinion, a testament to his design philosophy - is that they don't depreciate that much. People who spend $385 on a Sebenza, only to decide they don't like it, have been able to sell it for $300-$340.
Whether you like it or not - call me naive, but I'm betting you will - you will definitely stop wondering whether they're for you or not.
If you decide not to go for a Reeve knife, then the other brands that you mentioned, Benchmade, Spyderco, Kershaw and others, have produced outstanding knives as well, and will likely suit you just fine.
Good luck.
 
Last edited:
This is a well respected BladeForum.

I respect your opinions, and by in large, Chris Reeves knives have a very high rating with the majority of our members.

I can say just by looking at the Umnumzaan on the Chris Reeves site, it looks extremely well made.

I am a collector/hobbyist, and I am willing to pay for top quality. I am fascinated by the workmanship in the top folding knives. I have a large collection including many high quality knives, but not a Chris Reeves.

Thanks for all your input, without you I would have never found the Chris Reeves Knives website and never would have the pleasure of owning an Umnumzaan!:thumbup:

Thanks to all!!

~Jack
 
This is a well respected BladeForum.

I respect your opinions, and by in large, Chris Reeves knives have a very high rating with the majority of our members.

I can say just by looking at the Umnumzaan on the Chris Reeves site, it looks extremely well made.

I am a collector/hobbyist, and I am willing to pay for top quality. I am fascinated by the workmanship in the top folding knives. I have a large collection including many high quality knives, but not a Chris Reeves.

Thanks for all your input, without you I would have never found the Chris Reeves Knives website and never would have the pleasure of owning an Umnumzaan!:thumbup:

Thanks to all!!

~Jack

Thanks, Thats what we are here for. When you get your Umnumzaan, let us know what you think of it !!!
 
I'm glad you made the choice :thumbup:

If you're technically or creatively inclined, you ought to notice something new about the knife, every time you pick it up for the first little while - something subtle, but clearly deliberate, that makes it a better knife. A game can be made of looking for such things.

One thing I neglected to mention in my previous post: I have knives of all different brands, many of which outnumber my CRKs. Columbia River, Kershaw etc. I love all those knives and use them often, but I use all of them under the expectation that I'll likely last longer than they do. Not so CRK. Between the tough, slow-wearing design, and the warranty and refurbishing services that CRK offers, they are the only knives that feel confident I can use, and hard, yet still expect to give to my grandkids one day. In that sense, they are more than knives. They are investments.

I really hope they strike a chord with you, and you enjoy them :)
 
Last edited:
I think you will be very happy with your new knife. Let us know what you think :thumbup:
 
its such a nice knife, & i was worried i couldnt open it left handed,but it opens fine for me.so smooth & quiet,too,& cuts through anything with ease.real nice blade grind.you wont regret buying it.
 
There we go again...:rolleyes:

LOL. "Why buy a CRK" has to be the most commonly asked question on bladeforums. It looks like the OP was satisfied with the answers. I've spent a lot of money looking for something less expensive that would satisfy me. Now I am selling the less expensive knives and will be buying a Sebenza once I have the money set aside. I would have saved a lot of time and money if I had just bought a Sebenza the first time.
 
LOL. "Why buy a CRK" has to be the most commonly asked question on bladeforums. It looks like the OP was satisfied with the answers. I've spent a lot of money looking for something less expensive that would satisfy me. Now I am selling the less expensive knives and will be buying a Sebenza once I have the money set aside. I would have saved a lot of time and money if I had just bought a Sebenza the first time.

You'll start eyeing other knives after you get the Sebenza. I thought I was done with knives after my 21, but then I saw the Spyderco Military and Paramilitary, then I see the new Benchmade Sibert MPR, then the new Emerson CQC7 in stonewash, then the...
 
Back
Top