Why have a glass breaker on a knife?

DRider

DRider

Joined
Jan 8, 2005
Messages
597
Seems to me, if you are not in a professional capacity having to break windows fairly often (like someone in the military or someone who responds to car accidents) then in the rare emergency, you could just stab your knife into the window. Wouldn't the fact that your knife has a little sharp tip made of hardened steel work just as well as a glassbreaker?
 
DRider said:
Wouldn't the fact that your knife has a little sharp tip made of hardened steel work just as well as a glassbreaker?
Click to expand...

No, it will more often than not break the tip of your blade.

Glass breakers are thick for a reason.
 
Plus glass is normally hardened and can be quite tough to break (it's not as easy as you see in movies), couple that with the smooth (therefore slippery) surface of glass and it means that it's quite easy to slip and hurt yourself if you use the blade
 
Last edited:
You'd be better off leaving the knife closed and just hitting the glass with the handle or flipper.
 
I think a glass breaker is a great feature in case of an emergency. Like say you get into an accident or you arrive at a nasty one before the Paramedics and the victim is in immediate danger. There is also the fact that if something is designed for a job it will almost always do that job better than something designed for something else and then there is the fact that there is very little chance of injuring yourself with the glass breaker.
 
bobby.t said:
You'd be better off leaving the knife closed and just hitting the glass with the handle or flipper.
Click to expand...

Using a point would be far better and even if you did break the tip if the situation calls for it then who cares if it saves your life.
 
johnu2 said:
The lock would fail before the tip broke in my opinion
Click to expand...

Agreed. Remember that glass is HARD! In an emergency I might try this with a sturdy fixed blade with a thick point, like my (Camillus made) Recon Tanto, but I wouldn't try it with a folder. I like having fingers.
 
I think having a glass breaker is a fantastic idea and adds an additional use to folding knives other than cutting.

There have documented rescue cases where people have tried to poke the knife point into the window to break it. In these cases, the point, pivot, blade break, hand slips or the blade slips because the force is not at a perfect right angle. It will probably totally impractical and dangerous to do such a thing with a knife.

A small glass breaker on the otherhand can tackle most automobile windows (laminated or not) and create the cracks and the opening you need to open the window.

If you keep a knife in the car its a great idea to have a knife with a cutting hook (for seat belts) and a glass breaker. So for rescue purposes such a feature is a life saver.

Thanks to all those manufacturers that decided to include such a feature.
 
just do what 90% of the car theives I arrested in the past did, use a spark plug to break the glass. Works everytime in seconds.....
 
We've discussed this on the forum before.I have the best Benchmade seatbelt cutter and a automatic center punch to break the glass [always use the corner of the side windows]
 
Depends on which kind of glass. Tempered stuff can be made to shatter pretty easily. Typical windshield glass is specifically made not to shatter, and can be really tough to break through. There's a neat Victorinox Rescue Tool video showing the difference between a windshield and a side window on a car.

just do what 90% of the car theives I arrested in the past did, use a spark plug to break the glass. Works everytime in seconds.....
Click to expand...

Yes. Do a youtube search, you'll find several videos of folks breaking glass easily with a spark plug insulator. Specifically, the porcelain, much harder than glass. Tempered glass acts like it's under tension, very tough, but once breached, the whole thing disintegrates.

Knife based glass breakers seem to be a small, pointed piece of hardened metal. Probably harder than the typical knife blade.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top