Why Survival? (Long Ramble)

Just a stream of consciousness thang...posted in Ron's forum too. Thoughts?

###

I've been thinking hard about how to articulate something many of us instinctively understand: How do tactical training and survival and other extreme activities all fit together? What is the psychological crossover in the eyes of consumers?

Why the renewed interest in wilderness skills? Why the renewed interest in tactical and martial arts training? What are the psychological links that tie us all together? Is it the just the adrenaline rush? The thrill that comes from risking and winning? Is it the quest for the elusive “enlightenment” that Eastern philosophers and mystics have written about for millennia? What are the social factors that have caused such a resurgence of interest in these subjects? What is the impact on society? Why is the show “Survivor” such a national obsession?

All of this, I believe, traces back to these instinctive human needs:

Self-preservation, and self-fulfillment, accomplished by self-reliance.

Most people today have everything they need for survival. They have food, clothing, and shelter. They are coddled and cuddled and “taken care of,” by service providers, grocery stores, servants, and corporate employers (who end up spitting them out when they are no longer useful – more on that in a bit). They have been busy over the last half-century distracting and indulging themselves with their material wants and desires. A better car, a bigger house, a promotion at a job, fancy restaurants, spas…the list is vastly expansive. But as wide as the list goes, it never runs very deep. And the lack of fulfillment from these shallow pursuits now creates cracks in this material veneer. People get angry when the slightest inconveniences hit them -- when bird droppings hit their cars, when they sue each other for all sorts of minor insults, when things just don’t go exactly their way. Some of us now see through these cracks, awakened to the lack of reality in today’s “real world”. We see that what has been happening “is not necessarily a Good Thing.” So, we have put our hands on the edges of the cracks, and pulled them wider to get a better view of a better way:

Self-reliance.

When America began over 200 years ago, we had a largely agrarian society, and 95% of people were self-employed. They lived close to the land, made their living off the land, and relied on the land for social status (just look at all the huge plantation mansions still standing). They personally made clothing, shelter, and got their food directly from the resources of the land. They forged weapons from the land. There were no organized police forces to protect them; there were no convenience stores on the corner in those days to buy cereal or cold cuts. They took nothing for granted. They did it all themselves:

Self-reliance.

Where has this self-reliance gone? Today, 95% of people in America are employed by someone else – mostly large corporations. They’ve become dependent on these corporations. Many (not all) have been increasingly complacent and lazy because of it, but some of us have become consciously disturbed by the complacency.

We’ve seen an increase in tensions in society today – an ever-present sub-text of anger that often boils over into violence. Many feel betrayed by what they’ve been told while being brought up. “Get a job, and you’ll have security.” The almighty dollar has poisoned us against each other. It went from being a means to being the very end itself. Money is meant for getting other things accomplished. Now other things are accomplished just to get money. And they aren’t always pretty things. For example, business has devolved to the point where big corporations will lay off long-time, loyal employees to just to avoid paying a few dollars in retirement benefits. It has become more important than people and their lives. Money is an artificial representation invented by man. It represents dependence, not independence. Yes, it is necessary to function in today’s society, but let’s put it in its proper place.

As more and more people feel betrayed by the 1950s mentality of dependence, we are seeing certain directions develop. Entrepreneurism is the new term for self-reliance. More and more small businesses are born everyday, often from the minds and hearts of laid-off executives and workers. Big corporations are downsizing. We see employee ownership everywhere: profit-sharing and stock options are required if companies want the best employees. Empowerment is the buzzword of the new century, and it is not a mere trend: it is the result of this reawakening. Americans, and others around the world, are taking back the reins to their lives, and we're cracking the whip! There is an instinctive desire, a new need, to return to self-reliance, and business is where it has started. However, it is even becoming deeper than that. How? One way some of us gain perspective on all this is to train or participate in activities that nurture self-reliance:

The arts and sciences of self-preservation.

Wilderness skills. Martial arts training. Firearms training. Extreme sports. They all are means of self-fulfillment, and self-preservation, via self-reliance. Not crossover activities really: just parts of a whole. That’s why we see so many people interested in all of them, or many of them. With this training, no longer do we have to depend upon others stay alive, and thrive. Knowing we can overcome anything thrown at us by using only our wits and ingenuity -- THAT is true personal power, and self-control. These activities scare the establishment, because it means the masses no longer look to politicians and others as their saviors, or as their overseers -- and most certainly not their keepers.

The sheep have exited the corral!

The “average” person is revitalizing and reinventing him and/or herself through these activities. Training in the arts of self-preservation bolsters the confidence, and renews the spirit. It reinvigorates the zest for life that has been missing since the formative days of our country. It is a return to the “way it was,” when most were self-employed and self-reliant. It is a brand new kind of pioneer mentality, adapted to modern times. We’re seeing a wonderful desire to return to that way of thinking and living: embracing the challenge, and feeling the growth and confidence that naturally result. And so, the now the list of "life priorities" finally deepens, rather than remaining shallow. A sense of personal, individual responsibility increases: to one’s family, friends, society, and one’s self. So, personal responsibility leads to preservation of society and civility -- of each other -- because the anonymous mob mentality that fosters violence and other problems and a return to taking nothing and nobody for granted.

This, I believe, fuels the new interest in survival of all sorts.

Peace,

Brian.
 
I'm not sure where this might fit in, but someone pointed out that in the past, people tried to move to cities to get away from undeveloped country with its lack of creature comforts and lack of people ie. protection. Then, no one really went off to the hills or the wilderness on weekends for recreation since that would have been entirely contrary to what most people wanted.

Today, many of us actively search out the empty places. Possibly this is because our forefathers put us too close to one another in cities. And perhaps we are slowly evolving into a race that survives best and is at its natural healthiest in cities. I know lots of people who really dislike being out of cities. In the meantime, maybe there is something atavistic in our physiologies that makes the rest of us respond positively to unpolluted air and lack of traffic noise and the feel of earth and leaves.
 
A French writer at the turn of the century wrote that the United States would be a great country until its people figured out that they could get something for nothing from their government. That is a very true statment. It seems that the opposite has also happened. The politicians have figured out that personal power could be attained by giving away what's not theirs to give.

What happened to the Constitution, The Bill Of Rights and the founding principles on which this country was founded. In other words personal responsibility and self reliance.

To make this system work everybody has to try the best they can to be self sufficient and to help their neighbor for the common good of the country.

Some people and families do honestly need help, and should be helped. It just seems like most Americans now a days just expect or think it's an entitlement that the government bail them out of the problems they have brought upon themselves.

Between the politicians and people ripping each other off, it's no wonder the general public is a little paranoid.

Sorry to ramble on, but, the Constitution and The Bill Of Rights are 2 of the greatest documents ever written and for me, self reliance is a way to keep in touch with the roots of this country.

By the way, just because your paranoid doesn't mean someone isn't following you.

 
I believe it's the cyclic nature of our world Brian. I compare it to the life cycle of bacteria. Incubation leads to emergence of living bacteria. The bacteria grows and eats and grows and eats, multiplying continuously, exponentially until it reaches a peak and the available food is no longer enough to sustain them all. They begin to die because of the waste produced by the masses of living bacteria and the decomposing of the dead ones. They die more and more rapidly at an ever increasing rate equal to the speed of their previous population explosion. By this time, the waste is an extremely toxic poison. Finally, there are just a few left and those few see the end coming and produce spores to preserve themselves against complete extiction. Then, the cycle repeats itself. We are just larger examples of this life cycle.

As the wide open spaces become fewer and farther between, we yearn for them because we know in our hearts that they won't always be there. Civilization is closing in all around us. The city of Houston, Texas is what now, 30 miles across or larger? Take a trip on the interstate and really look at the countryside and think what it looked like just 20 years ago.

The more people there are in the world, the closer together they are to one another, geographically. The closer people are forced to live to one another, the more space they want. The desire to 'get away from it all' and 'get back to basics' is something that has progressed naturally because of the constraints that society places on us. One day, you live out in the country and are very comfortable. Before you even realize it, there are sub-divisions popping up and soon you're living in a neighborhood with ordinances and rules about how to keep your yard mowed and the like. It's happening right here in Paris, Arkansas. It's happening all over the world. And it will continue to happen without fail. Unrelenting, unstoppable progressive building of more and more living quarters, malls, grocery stores, gas stations, quick marts and endless development for our ever growing population. If you dwell on that train of thought for very long, it can make you a little uneasy.

I believe that technology is the key to our collective unease and frantic life styles. Things that are suppose to make our lives easier wind up making them much more difficult and stressful. We become slaves to our lifestyle choices and locked into empty, meaningless lives. Eventually, some of us break out of that destructive pattern and 'get back to basics' and 'get away from it all'. I'm one of those and I know there are many here who are as well. We make our choices in life and live with the consequences until we make other choices. Cyclic.

Some people really believe that there is no other way to do things than how they've always done them. (Where does bread come from? The supermarket. So does milk and all the other food the vast majority of us consume.) Never take chances that could result in an 'unknown' result. Fear is the key, and it rules the lives of many, many people. I've made my choice and separated myself from the masses and am trying to live as self-sufficiently as I can manage. It's a continual transformation that you really have to 'work' at. Money is the stumbling block. At least it can be if you're not very self-sufficient. I think that if we could do away with today's monetary system it would do wonders for a return to self-reliance. Like you said, money isn't a substantial thing. It's just an idea. It literally isn't worth the paper it's printed on. But, it has the power to corrupt and destroy lives, none the less. I may sound like a radical. I'm not. I'm a realist maybe a little to the extreme. I just try to see the world for what it really is and that's the way I see it.
 
I often go back in time to the thoughts and writings of great American authors. Trying to understand their messages sheads light on our present society, at least for me. Ralph Waldo Emerson, a transcendentalists, expressed these words in 1841 while writing on Self-Reliance.." There is a time in every man's education when he arrives at the conviction that envy is ignorance; that imitation is suicide; that he must take himself for better or for worst as his portion; though the wide universe is full of good, no kernel of nourishing corn can come to him but through his toil bestowed on that plot of ground which is given to him to till....man does not stand in awe of man,...it is easy to see that a greater self-reliance must work a revolution in all the offices and relations of men; in their religon; in their education; in their pursuits; their modes of living; their associations; in their property; in their speculative views." That was the year 1841. If I look at Henry Davis Thoreau's messages delivered to us during the same era ( On Walden Pond ) and consider Earnest Hemingway's writings in " No Man is an Island", I see Brian's thought's and words ring true some 160 years later. For me, survival is simple defined as " not dying," and doing all that it takes, in a humanitarian way, to achieve that goal. To that end, I find truth in Hemmingway,s statement.." No Man Is an Isalnd." Amen, OK?

 
Max, Backpacker, kmclye and FF,

Fantastic posts! I'm constantly amazed at the caliber of people who contribute in this WIlderness Forum, whther on the subject of skills or philosophical thought.

Takao, thanks as well -- looks like my post has been eclipsed by the others here...
smile.gif


~B.
 
Very nice.
wink.gif


------------------
Buck Collectors Club Member # 572
Dedicated ELU
Knifeknut(just ask my wife)
Sebenzanista
 
Self-preservation, self-reliance, self-control, responsibility, self-fulfillment, independence, personal power. What a great list of personal traits everyone should aspire to.

I’d like to ask the board if this is something they practice in their current environment or if they only apply it to some ideal of a simpler life in the woods. Obviously, survival encompasses more than just the wilderness. If these are truly attributes one aspires to then they should be practiced in everything we do.

Interestingly, I struggle with the ideal of self-preservation. Too often, one has to abandon the other traits above when confronted with a situation invoking the need for self-preservation. Oddly enough, if you consistently strive to practice the other ideals, I would dare say self-preservation will be achieved without you ever having to practice it directly. More importantly, life becomes much more simple, which seems to be a common thread among many of us here.

Balance is beautiful.
 
Good afternoon Ginsu. I appreciate the simplicity in your statement Balance Is Beautiful!

This universal axiom holds true : the shortest distance between two points is a straight line. When representing that line as the traits of self-preservation, reliance, control, fulfillment or responsibility, rarely is balance achieved from start to finish. Yet the axiom lives on and the beauty of balance is forever attainable.

I try not to seperate the reality of wilderness from a forest and a crowed elevator stuck between floors one and two....between an angry,charging bruin and an angry stationary mob. Both will require self-preservation sooner than later.

I look into the mirror and I see two ears. I study them and remind myself who and what I am. Unfortunately, honorable traits diminish rapidly in my wilderness when self-preservation collides with the lack of oxygen or the need to survive the agressive actions of a lesser primate. As concern my equal in the primate world, I contiually practice the Golden Rule without expectation of its return. Therein lies my serenity, my chance of a straight line and the hope of balance.
 
This is a very interesting and pertinent thread running here, which cuts to the heart of us as humans. I have, in the last ten years, come to spend a great deal of time in the mountains. I enjoy the seclusion, relaxation, and communion with nature, but these are just the side benefits of my survivalist awakening. My initial excursions to the mountains were propelled by an irresistible urge to be...... less civilized. Many would say that this was the “call of the wild”, and that phrase is quite fitting. I’d spent my life in a place where survival meant learning to do the bidding of others, and developing social interactions. While I was very capable of fitting into modern culture, I was left unfulfilled. An almost genetic outcry surfaced from within myself, demanding that I explore the other side of humanity. This other side of humanity took me to places where one can smell the change in weather, stalk his own meal, and fight for his own existence on a physical plane. I became the predator instead of the prey of other humans.

I have leaned much in this last ten years. I’ve developed certain survivalist skills, learned how to interact with nature without seriously impacting it, become a very proficient fisherman, and grown to understand exactly who I am in relation to the world outside of humanity. I now think of the mountains as going home, instead of running away from home.

We read everyday about how terrible our culture really is. People rape and pillage each other’s lives. They murder for the shear joy of it, and find themselves unable to show remorse for their actions. I truly believe that these hideous actions are their “call of the wild”. These murderers feel the need for the hunt. They require prey. They must hone their survivalist skills and test their meddle, without even understanding why and how to do this properly. The dredges of our society are filled with those who’s instincts run high, but whose morality and understanding run low. These horrific creations turn to hunting the only prey we have left standing in our cities...... Ourselves. This wild nature runs through all our veins, but some are ill equipped to handle predatory urges. The better of us take these feelings to where they count. We take them to the mountains. We go back to our origins and gain wisdom from a lack of society. We understand who we are by distancing ourselves from the flooding opinions of others. We seek the truth within our hearts, shunning the lies that come from others. We crave just a moment to ourselves. We look to God’s creation for advice, instead of man’s pitiful attempts at construction. We seek to know who we really are, which cannot be found in the eyes of others.
 
Wow.
I wish the media would contact one of you guys the next time it needs a reason for/ definiton of, Survivalism!

I can relate to what you said about the hunter turning on his fellow city mates to hunt as prey. At my work we sell knives and other self deffense products and its wierd to see the range of people who feel thay need these 'things' to save them when practically all who come in to buy them lack the skill of how it is used.

In the end, as has been pointed out, all you have is your skill and determination to get things done. I recently had an article published in a magazine and the only thing that got me over the hurdle of being rejected and not published was to apply myself to it and doing the best with what I had.

I am glad to hear that the survival spirit of humanity is alive and well and not tied to some attavistic line of thinking that will wither and die. Please continue!

Jeff Venture
 
Watch Natural Born Killers and read Lord of the Flies. They might give you some isight into the nature of animalist tendencies.
 
Brian,

To me the martial arts are only one component of survival, but, they can teach a person many lessons in becoming a better survivalist. Some of the lessons to be learned besides defence from the martial arts are dedication and a will to always try to achieve more.
 
"True hunting's over, no herds to follow. With no game, men prey on each other."

Jane's Addiction

Actually, the "Savagery of Primitivism" I think is fictional. Natural Born Killers and Lord of the Flies are fiction. Crime has been rare among humans until the development of agriculture and hierarchical societies.
 
Back
Top