Wicked edge or edge pro?

[Big Papa]

What works best for traditional folders?

 

[steeljunky154]

For me the edge pro because you can sharpen a wider variety of knifes. it is hard to sharpen a fillet knife on the wicked edge because there is nothing to keep it from flexing. it is extremely hard to get a full flat ground blade even on both sides because the vise has nothing flat to clamp on.

 

[Sadden]

The EPP is my choice. If you do a search theres a myriad of threads on the subject.

The EP is more versatile and currently has a wider selection of aftermarket stones. Everything aftermarket for the EP is sgnificantly cheaper than the WE. The EP also makes an easier transiion to freehand.

If you arent confidant in your ability to hold a blade stable on the blade table than get the WE , otherwise just get an EP.

 

[KnottyEagle]

For me the edge pro because you can sharpen a wider variety of knifes. it is hard to sharpen a fillet knife on the wicked edge because there is nothing to keep it from flexing. it is extremely hard to get a full flat ground blade even on both sides because the vise has nothing flat to clamp on.

These are false. There's a little hole in the front of where the clamps are that a little rod goes into with a slit cut through the middle for fillet knives. The WE is fully capable of clamping FFG blades. I've done it a few times and Clay has a video demonstrating how to do it.

[video=youtube_share;17rDq-yiMIU]http://youtu.be/17rDq-yiMIU[/video]

 

[Krav]

For me the edge pro because you can sharpen a wider variety of knifes. it is hard to sharpen a fillet knife on the wicked edge because there is nothing to keep it from flexing. it is extremely hard to get a full flat ground blade even on both sides because the vise has nothing flat to clamp on.

My WE came with this piece to hold longer knives in place.

 

[wvdavidr]

I'm going to vote "Edge Pro." Clay's technique for clamping an FFG blade is easier said (shown) than done. I can't get a piece of anything to hold one well- it's hard to describe, but there's not much room for leather, chamois, etc.. FFG's are easy with the Edge Pro.

Good sharpening,
Dave

 

[bigshoe83]

I have the Wicked Edge and love it. I can't comment on the edge pro as I have never used one but have several spyderco ffg blades and have had no issues getting them polished up nicely. From watching videos on the edge pro the only negative I could see may be not being able to hold the blade in the exact same spot the whole time while sharpening and flipping the knife over therefore changing your angle of attack. Just a theory as I have never used one.

 

[whp]

I have the Wicked Edge and love it. I can't comment on the edge pro as I have never used one but have several spyderco ffg blades and have had no issues getting them polished up nicely. From watching videos on the edge pro the only negative I could see may be not being able to hold the blade in the exact same spot the whole time while sharpening and flipping the knife over therefore changing your angle of attack. Just a theory as I have never used one.

Having used both I find the sharpening angles on the Wicked Edge are more consistently precise for the reason mentioned. Also the stones never need flattening and seem to be more durable. This from a guy who is by no means an expert but still manages to get excellent edges with the WE. Shorter learning curve and a longer wait time , but still worth the extra money.

 

[KnottyEagle]

I'm going to vote "Edge Pro." Clay's technique for clamping an FFG blade is easier said (shown) than done. I can't get a piece of anything to hold one well- it's hard to describe, but there's not much room for leather, chamois, etc.. FFG's are easy with the Edge Pro.

Good sharpening,
Dave

It's actually not that hard. Takes about 5 minutes and you can do it with regular tape.

 

[TalentedMrRipley]

Owning both I would recommend the Wicked Edge. I found that smaller knives are harder on the Edge Pro. I didn't like having to move the knife and the stone simultaneously. The angle is more precise on the WE and I've had no issue clamping fully flat ground knives. Even something as large my Cold Steel Kukri.

I also prefer sharpening both sides at the same time. There are more stones for the Edge Pro right now. But I think that's changing. And yes they are more expensive but usually you are purchasing twice as many so the price is understandable. Of the current production guided angle systems I believe the Wicked Edge is the best. Its the most accurate and repeatable and because you do both sides simultaneously its also faster. Which ever you decide on check out Oldawan, Bob stocks and sells both. I bought my WE from him at a gun show a couple years ago.

 

[Gerard Breuker]

While I like everything about my WE I find it is rather difficult to go into low angles on traditional folders as the blades are usually rather small. Even with the riser block that is part of the upgrade kit. Still have to buy the low angle adapter though.

 

[bonky]

I've owned and used a WE for a few years now, and it's a very good tool. As mentioned by others, it comes with a tool for longer blades to prevent flexing, although I've never used mine. I simply sharpie the blade and do it in sections for blades that are long/flexible, I find it easier for me to maintain a consistent angle over the length of the blade. The bulk of my sharpening has been on traditional folders, and for that task it's the best I've ever used.

I cannot speak for the Apex Pro myself, although many others I trust can, and they recommend it highly.

I think you would do very well with either one.