Wife wants a Subaru Tribeca

shootist16

knife law moderator
Moderator
Joined
Dec 25, 1998
Messages
7,394
As noted in this thread:

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=403701&highlight=forester

I took my wife to test drive a Subaru Forester. She saw the Tribeca and wanted to test drive it as well. Well... she wants one. I'll have to admit that I would never have test drove it if she hadn't wanted to. I just didn't appreciate the style. I really like the interior. The exterior is growing on me. One of the guys I work with was saying that 250-hp 3.0-liter boxer engine and 219 lb-ft of torque at 4,200 rpm is too wimpy. Anyways what do you guys think of them?

Here is a link to Subaru's Tribeca page for those that aren't familiar:

http://www.subaru.com/shop/model_consideration.jsp?model=B9_TRIBECA
 
If you guys like the vehicle, buy it. I don't see you having any problems with it, and that engine will be MORE than enough, powerwise. Subaru's 4 cylinder engines usually have enough power, so this will work out well, IMHO.
 
I don't think that you can ever have too much hp....:D I'd agre with the styling; it just doesn't do much for me. I friend of mine has a Tribeca and he can't say enough about it. You may want to consider a Forrester XT; lots of space with a fair amount of hp. I have a WRX which was great when I was living in Colorado; the full time AWD is nice, but probably not necessary out here in California.

Mike
 
If you're towing a boat, I'd stay away from it. The subaru 6 cylinder's don't have a great reputation for performance (unlike subbie 4 cylinder turbos). For driving, its probably fine. Nobody ever is unhappy with a subbie in the long run. At that size and with the 6cy., I'd consider the Honda Pilot.
 
Check out the new Toyota Rav 4 (V6) too. My wife and I just got one. LOADS of power. 0-60: 6.3 seconds (motor trend), 6.7 seconds (CU). 269HP 3.5. Cheaper. Same towing cap. (3500lbs), Better MPG. Doesnt need premium fuel. (we've been getting 20-21mpg in mixed driving with my lead foot.) More cargo volume (38.5 versus 36 for the Subaru). Its quite a bit bigger than past Rav generations. I was suprised.

http://www.toyota.com/rav4/index.html?s_van=GM_TN_RAV4_INDEX

FYI- Here's Consumer Reports write-up on the Subby:

Highs: Ride, handling, quietness, fit and finish.
Lows: Acceleration, transmission, cramped second- and third-row seats, child-seat placement.

Subaru's first midsize SUV is a comfortable, quiet vehicle. The Tribeca has a very good ride and is fairly agile, thanks to its standard electronic stability control. The cabin is well constructed and nicely finished. Seven passengers can fit in the Tribeca in a pinch, but the second row is cramped, and the optional third row is strictly for small children. The engine struggles to keep the Tribeca moving. The transmission is reluctant to downshift and often hunts for the right gear. This results in disappointing fuel economy.

THE DRIVING EXPERIENCE

The Tribeca is good at absorbing bumps and road imperfections. The ride is comfortable and steady. Road and wind noise are subdued, but engine drone is noticeable. Body lean is controlled in corners, and the steering is well-weighted and responsive, with good feedback. At its handling limits, the Tribeca is stable and secure, with the ESC helping to keep it on course. The Tribeca posted a relatively high speed in our avoidance maneuver. The smooth 250-hp, 3.0- liter six-cylinder engine provided fairly slow acceleration and has to work hard to maintain speed. Expect 16 mpg overall on premium fuel. The five-speed automatic transmission is smooth, but it's slow to respond and has to shift often to maintain speed. The Tribeca pulled our test trailer with 3,500 pounds -- its limit -- to 60 mph in 20.8 seconds. Overall braking performance is very good. The low-beam headlights illuminate only a short distance.

INSIDE THE CABIN

The high-quality trim in the Tribeca fits well. The lack of a telescoping steering wheel, however, makes it hard to find a good driving position. Thick roof pillars and small rear windows compromise side and rear visibility. A back-up camera would help but is not offered. The power front seats are firm and comfortable, with good thigh support. The second row is cramped, and the third row is barely tolerable. Getting in and out of the front seats is easy, but the tight rear leg room makes it harder in the second row. Third-row access is extremely difficult. Most controls are easy to use, but the fuel and temperature gauges are easily obstructed by the driver's hands. The navigation screen has a handy touch-screen display, but it's a long reach. Cabin storage is moderate. We measured 36 cubic feet of storage space with the seats folded, which is about the same as the smaller Subaru Forester. A temporary spare tire is mounted below the vehicle.

SAFETY NOTES

Seatback-mounted side-impact air bags and curtain-style head-protection air bags that extend to protect the first- and second-row passengers are both standard on the Tribeca. They supplement required front-impact air bags and three-point seatbelts in each of the seven seating positions. A driver's seat position sensor, belt usage sensors for the front belts and an occupant detection sensor in the passenger seat influence the appropriate level of deployment of the front air bags. The occupant detection system monitors the passenger's weight and seatbelt tension and will automatically disable the front air bags if it determines a child is seated there. The front- and second-row outboard belts have adjustable upper anchor positions for an improved fit. The front seatbelts are also equipped with pretensioners to reduce belt slack in a crash. Some may find buckling the second-row belts a bit awkward with the flexible and short buckle attachment. There are adjustable and locking head restraints in all seating positions. The front restraints are tall enough even when fully lowered to reduce head travel and whiplash injury, but the rear restraints must all be raised for sufficient protection. Daytime running lights are standard. Driving with kids: For a vehicle that offers the flexibility of three rows of seating and the potential for larger families, the fact that Subaru does recommend child seat installation in the second-row center or third-row seats of the Tribeca is surprising. Some rear-facing infant seats may also be susceptible to tilt when installed in the second-row outboard seats. Despite the recommendation there are tether strap attachment anchors for all three seconnd-row seats on the seatbacks and for each third-row seat on the cargo area sill. There are LATCH anchors in the second-row outboard seats and though recessed they are shallow enough to allow relatively easy access.

RELIABILITY

We expect reliability to be better than average, according to our latest subscriber survey.
 
have a look at the japanese forester sti as it goes like sh!t off a shovel
if you want a small car wait for the new honda civic type-r as it is going to be amazing
 
Shann said:
At that size and with the 6cy., I'd consider the Honda Pilot.

We have a Honda Pilot now. Want something different. I can also say the Pilot doesn't have the get up and go the Tribeca has.
 
While originally the thread was about Subarus, I am going to throw my vote in for the new Toyota Rav4. That is an awesome vehicle!
 
The front end on the Tribeca looks like a damned Edsel to me. The dealer where we bought our Mazda also sells Subs and the salesman said that the front end design was supposed to look like a stylized airplane, since Subs are made by Fuji Heavy Industries, an aircraft manufacturer among other things.
 
FullerH said:
The front end on the Tribeca looks like a damned Edsel to me.

Looks more Alfa Romeo to me. I'll admit the looks didn't appeal to me at all, but they are growing on me. My wife likes it, so thats all that really matters anyway. ;) I'll see if I can't talk her into looking at the RAV4. I haven't found a dealer around here that has one with leather though. :grumpy:
 
shootist16 said:
Looks more Alfa Romeo to me. I'll admit the looks didn't appeal to me at all, but they are growing on me. My wife likes it, so thats all that really matters anyway. ;) I'll see if I can't talk her into looking at the RAV4. I haven't found a dealer around here that has one with leather though. :grumpy:

Yes, word has it the Rav w/leather is hard to come by, depending where you live. If you go here: http://rav4world.com/forums/index.php and look around, someone might be able to point you towards one. There are a few "high volume" dealers in the US that seem to have a good selection, and some are spoken quite highly of by the forum members. I bought ours locally though (no leather).Also, if Im not mistaken, last orders for 2006 model year are this month. So you might be able to find some good deals if you find one on a lot. This months CU has a comaprison of small SUVs. No Tribeca, but the forester is in there.

Since we did the CU write-up on the Subby, how bout the 2006 Rav4:

Highs: Agility, fuel economy, rear-seat room, access, controls, refined and quick V6 powertrain.
Lows: Thigh support for some drivers.

The redesigned RAV4 tops its class with either the standard four-cylinder or optional V6 engine. An available third-row seat and powerful V6 make it a good alternative to some more-expensive midsized SUVs. It is agile and roomy, it rides comfortably, and it has a smooth drivetrain and a flexible interior. Fuel economy with either engine is impressive. Unfortunately, curtain air bags remain optional.

THE DRIVING EXPERIENCE

The RAV4 rides comfortably and without a lot of body motion. The V6 is quiet and polished. The four-cylinder engine drones at moderate speed but is not annoying on the highway. Handling is responsive and agile, and the quick steering provides good feedback. The four-cylinder version feels slightly nimbler than the V6 and has a tighter turning circle. Emergency handling is balanced and secure, aided by standard stability control. The 269-hp, 3.5-liter V6 uses a five-speed automatic and is very quick and uses only slightly more fuel than the four-cylinder model, returning a respectable 22 mpg overall. The 166-hp, 2.4-liter four-cylinder engine, coupled with a four-speed automatic transmission, has good performance and gets 23 mpg overall. The brakes perform very well. Low-beam headlights reach only a fair distance and have a distinct cutoff. The differential lock helps provide good off-road traction, but traction control brings the vehicle to a crawl in slippery conditions. With the V6, the RAV4 towed our 3,500-pound trailer to 60 mph in 16 seconds. The four-cylinder is rated to tow 1,500 pounds.

INSIDE THE CABIN

The spacious interior is well assembled, but the center console feels flimsy. Even with a tilt-and-telescoping steering column, some drivers found the steering wheel too far away and awkwardly angled. Foot, head, and leg room are generous. Large pillars can create rear blind zones. The base front seats are generally supportive; the optional leather seats are firmer. Some drivers found the cushions had limited thigh support. Head and leg room in the back are generous, and access is easy, but the seat cushion is a bit low. The optional third row can seat two adults in a pinch, but the second-row seat has to slide forward to make room for rear riders' feet. Most gauges and controls are simple and clear. The manual climate-control knobs are large and easy to use, but the automatic climate controls in the Limited are hard to read and confusing. Interior storage is moderate, with two glove boxes. Cargo space is generous.

SAFETY NOTES

Seatback-mounted side-impact air bags and curtain-style head-protection air bags are available as part of an extra-cost Air bag Package for the RAV4. The head-protection curtains extend to protect the outboard occupants in the first- and second-row seats and will deploy in either a side impact or a rollover. The air bags supplement required front air bags and three-point seatbelts in all seating positions. The front belts have adjustable upper anchors for getting a comfortable and safe fit and are also equipped with pretensioners and force limiters to reduce belt slack and forces in the event of a crash. The pretensioners will also tighten in a rollover on versions equipped with the curtain air bags. An occupant classification system in the front passenger seat detects the weight of the front passenger and will automatically deactivate the front- and side-air bags and pretensioner if it detects that a child is seated. Still, it's best to always travel with child passengers in the rear seats. Those same systems will also not activate if the seat is unoccupied. Sensors in both the driver- and front-passenger seatbelt buckles, which detect belt usage, and a seat position sensor for the driver will also influence the appropriate level of front air bag deployment. There are adjustable and locking head restraints in each of the five seating positions. The front restraints are tall enough even when fully lowered to provide adequate protection from whiplash; the rear restraints must be raised to provide adequate protection. Fortunately, the rear outboard restraints are of a design that would be very uncomfortable for adult passengers unless they are raised, prompting them to be moved up to a sufficiently high location. Daytime running lights are an extra-cost option. Driving with kids: The RAV4 is not particularly friendly to child seat installation. The center rear seat is offset into the left passenger seat, limiting the ability to travel with three across. The ceiling-anchored center belt also allows side-to-side movement of rear-facing seats installed there. Some rear-facing infant bases may also tilt in the rear outboard seats, but choosing alternate models or LATCH installation can provide a secure fit. For front-facing seats, there is a single tether for the center seat on the cargo area ceiling, but the housing that surrounds the anchor requires the tether strap to be twisted upside down as it doesn't allow the hook through. The outboard tethers are mounted low on the seatback and require moving the outboard seats forward to access them. The LATCH anchors in the rear outboard seats are recessed between the cushions and seatback but are easy to access.

RELIABILITY

We expect reliability to be better than average, according to our latest subscriber survey.
 
Well... traded for a Tribeca tonight. We considered other options but ended up getting a great deal on the Subaru. I'll let you guys know what we think after we've had it for awhile.
 
This ordeal isn't about the car. Its about making Wifey happy. Happy Wifey means happy shootist16. The car is incidental.

cheers
 
powernoodle said:
This ordeal isn't about the car. Its about making Wifey happy. Happy Wifey means happy shootist16. The car is incidental.

cheers

Amen to that. It is her car, so my opinion doesn't matter all that much anyway. I just want to make sure she gets a decent one.
 
I'm sure you'll like it. I saw one last night and peeked inside (didn't take anything, honest). It looked comfortable and roomy. I like the looks of it from every angle except the front. I pretty much think that Subbies, Hondas and Toyotas are so good that you can't go wrong and it comes down to what you just like best and where you can get the best deal.

Congrats!
 
:D
shootist16 said:
Well... traded for a Tribeca tonight. We considered other options but ended up getting a great deal on the Subaru. I'll let you guys know what we think after we've had it for awhile.


Congratulations! Welcome to the Cult Of Subaru. :D

You can't go wrong with a Subaru.

V-1
(Very satisfied owner/operator of a '05 turbocharged/intercooled Subaru Forester XT)
 
Back
Top