Wings and ByrdRench passaround

yablanowitz

Platinum Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2006
Messages
9,917
The passaround Byrd Wings and ByrdRench have recently made their way into my hands. Having had a couple of days to examine and evaluate them, here are my thoughts on the two.

Each of these knives came to me with a sturdy nylon belt pouch, which is a good thing, for reasons I will get into in a moment. The pouches are well made, with stitched and riveted construction that should last for years. The snap closures seem quite secure.

First the Wings. The Byrd Wings carries on the concept of the double-ended lock blade, a la Dyad. I was rather surprised at the size of this knife when I received it. It is quite large, nearly as long as the C44 Dyad with both blades open, and slightly longer when closed. The real shock was the thickness. The Wings is nearly as thick without the pocket clip as the Dyad is with the clip. After carrying a Dyad for a couple of years, the Wings feels chunky by comparison. That is not entirely bad, as the Wings is much more comfortable in use than the older Dyad, but it comes at the expense of extra bulk in the pocket. While it is not much heavier, that extra eighth of an inch of thickness makes a noticable difference in the bulk. That's why I liked the idea of a pouch in spite of the clip.

Speaking of clips, the Wings has a four way pocket clip that is a cause for rejoicing. It came set for right-hand tip down plain edge, which is how I wish my single position Dyad was. It can also be set for RH PE tip up, RH SE TD or RH SE TU, as well as all four variations for left-hand carry. Yes, I know there are only four positions, since RH PE TD also works as LH SE TU, etc. The double-ended lockblade would need a four-way clip even if no one was left-handed, just to get the knife aligned with the tip of the blade you want pointing the way you want it. The Wings shows it can be done, and hopefully any future Dyads will follow that lead.

The knife is nicely finished, with G-10 scales that give good purchase without being too abrasive. The Comet holes are large and exposed well enough to be operable with either the right or left hand. One odd thing I noticed was that sometimes the tip of my little finger would slip through the Comet hole of the off-blade far enough to hold the other blade shut while I was trying to open it. The liner locks are fitted perfectly, engaging exactly the thickness of the locking leaf. The lock surface on the blade tang is arced like the Spyderco Military, with no creep when applying pressure to the blade spine. The Walker-style ball detents are quite secure, so unwanted openings should not be a problem.

Overall, the Wings is a great way to carry both a plain and a serrated blade in one package.
 
The ByrdRench is Spyderco's economy version of the once and future SpydeRench. It shares most of the functions and features of the SpydeRench, with a few differences. The tool is longer and wider than a Leatherman Wave or Charge, and equally thick. The most noticeable difference between the Spyder and Byrd is the file. The SpydeRench features a rather oddly shaped diamond file, with flat, concave and convex surfaces. The ByrdRench features a rather coarse three-quarter round file which will shred the edge of your pocket in short order if you don't get the flat turned the right way, as the pocket clip will pull the fabric tight to the file as the tool goes into the pocket. Overall, using the belt pouch may be a good idea.

The ByrdRench comes with the same bit set that the SpydeRench does, except the file/punch lacks the small plain and Phillips ends of the SpydeRench's diamond file. Any standard quarter inch bits will fit in the storage, so if you want to carry a couple of Torx bits instead of the standard small and large straight or #2 and #3 Phillips bits, you can. The Byrd has a much better magnetic bit holder than my old SpydeRench, and the bit storage is more secure with the file out as well. The Byrd also shares the slip- joint pliers and the ability to seperate the bit holder/knife to use independently from the rest of the tool. So it allows you to use a screwdriver and adjustable open end wrench at the same time, which is a very handy feature.

Although the fit and finish are not quite up to Spyderco standards, the tool is well-constructed and should give many years of service. If you have been looking in vain for an original SpydeRench, this will at least hold you until you can find one.

Last but not least, a link to a bunch of my poor attempts at photography: http://s276.photobucket.com/albums/kk28/yablanowitz/
 
Thanks, yablanowitz.

Good pics and good comparison. Very well written.
 
Thanks, good review!
:thumbup:
I've been wanting the Wings model for a while.
And since the Buck custom shop quadrupled the cost of the custom 110 i was GOING (past tense) to buy i can now divert that money elsewhere.
So it will be a Wings model and maybe a Salt 1 or Endura 4.
:D
 
One odd thing I noticed was that sometimes the tip of my little finger would slip through the Comet hole of the off-blade far enough to hold the other blade shut while I was trying to open it.
Thx! Nice review, but i didn't really get what you meant by this..until I got my own Byrd 'Wings'. Same thing happened, though it is not a problem for me at all.
The serrations work pretty well and don't tend to snag on the material you're cutting. The wings are actually a bit lighter than a standard Byrd Cara Cara, which surprised me as they are, as you have already mentioned, a lot thicker. I definitely need to buy more Byrds!
 
Due to a cut on my right little finger, I have lost some of the sensitivity in that fingertip. There I was trying to open the knife and wondering why it was so hard, when I looked down and found out why :o. I couldn't even feel it when I saw what was going on. It really wasn't a problem, just one of those odd little things that I thought I'd mention. ;)
 
Thanks much for the reviews and photos!


The Wings was thicker than I expected and kind of heavy (the Byrds seem to use heavier liners than Spyderco). I was glad that it came with the decent quality nylon belt pouch since that is how I would carry it most of the time!


There are some things I liked about the 'rench and a few I didn't. Having both pliers and a cresent wrench along with a driver that takes standard hex bits (that you can seperate and use in conjuction with the cresent wrench) is very nice as is the one hand opening knife blade and pocket clip.


Things that I miss on the Byrdrench that are found on most Leatherman style multitools are the needle nose pliers, wire cutter, flat file/metel saw, wood saw, rulers and can/bottle openers.





Frank
 
Back
Top