Work Knife Suggestions....

Joined
Jul 29, 2003
Messages
147
Ok folks, it's time for me to find a new folder for work. A little background my old work folder is a S&W SWAT which has served well for the past 3 years. It worked great..but is being retired now. I finally ruined the tip and a nice bit of the edge. I work installing Heating and A/C and a good knife is a daily requirement. My knife cuts on a regular basis, fiberglass insulation, thick and thin plastic, cardboard, copper wiring, and foam rubber. It's also been over the past 3 years used as a pry bar, hammer, shovel, screwdriver, and writing utensil(no I'm not joking).

Here are my requirements:

-Must be a folder.

-No serrations. They're too difficult to sharpen and are often more of a problem than not.

-Blade Style: Tantos and Wharncliffs are out. Must be a drop point or clip point blade.

-Has to take a good edge and hold it fairly well...with occasional sharpening.

-Rust resitance isn't a huge factor, but it is important.

-Stout lock up...preferebly liner locking.

-Blade length minimum is 3.5", prefering something in the 3.75-4" range.

-Blade has to be thick and able to withstand much abuse. Prying and hammering, are general requirements of the job. The tip of the blade needs to be fairly thick as well.

-Handle must also be thick, able to fill a medium-large hand, and be able to withstand hard impacts and abuse.

-Other obvious little features are needed. A non slip grip, pocket clip, and one handed opening, are all important.

-Price: Folders over $50 need not apply. The risk of loss, breakage, or damage, is simply too high to spend a weeks pay on a knife.


In short...I need a fairly stout knife. Something that is thick and hard and won't break the bank in terms of cost. I know that is asking alot from a quality folder under $50. I feel there is something out there to fit the budget, though.

Thoughts, recommendations, comments are all welcome.

-Random
 
My plumbing/heating tech uses a Kershaw Vapor 50/50 edge. He bought it because of the price, but would have preferred a total plain blade. His endorsement had me buying a Vapor II within a couple days.
I'm not so sure that my guy uses his as a hammer, it was pretty well scratched and beat up however;)
 
One of the Walther allied forces is a great knife. It's well balanced, stout, comes with an aluminum handle, and a non-serrated blade. Check it out.
 
Although beyond your price range of $50, I'd strongly urge you to at least consider the Falcon by John Greco. No clip. This knife is built like a tank. Certainly loss is an ever present risk, but otherwise this knife should endure all of the abuse you mentioned for years and years. As you've probably noted in other threads, John is retiring for health reasons so the supply is limited.
 
My only thoughts is a Spyderco Endura with stainless steel handles...
Or if you want to spend slightly more...BM Griptilian
 
Originally posted by Matches

I'm not so sure that my guy uses his as a hammer, it was pretty well scratched and beat up however

Hehe...yea I don't usually use my knife as a hammer. I have had a couple of incidents, that would've destroyed lightweight handles though. I recall a certain incident where the knife wasn't clipped all the way into my pocket, while going down a ladder on the side of a three story building. ;)

-Random
 
Originally posted by Neanderthal
Although beyond your price range of $50, I'd strongly urge you to at least consider the Falcon by John Greco. No clip. This knife is built like a tank. Certainly loss is an ever present risk, but otherwise this knife should endure all of the abuse you mentioned for years and years. As you've probably noted in other threads, John is retiring for health reasons so the supply is limited.

I was about to say just that ! Yes . spend a few extra bucks and get a greco folder while you can . The knife is the strongest knife in its price range! I just got the falcon and whisper, both are made like tanks. I would have liked a pocket clip on mine .Both are perfect work knives !Heres a link to the knives !
http://www.grecoknives.com/GRECO275.htm
 
Greco folder is a very good choice.

However, you might consider a Buck 110 with or without finger grooves. After you trash the blade, send it in to Buck and for $35.00 you can have a BG-42 blade put on it.

Neither one is a liner lock, but they are tough.

Mike
 
what you really want is a REKAT Pioneer (ATS-34, dual steel liners & G10, rolling lock) except (1) the blade is around 3.4" (2) they are discontinued. But you can email me for a lead if you're interested at lumberingstone@hotmail.com

aside from that, look at the CRKT offerings. Most can be got for around $50. The Crawford Falcon & Maritzelli Prowler come to mind. Also the Benchmade Griptillian would be a great choice. All have blades at or under 3.5" however.

The Greco Falcon is a great knife, esp. for the price, but it doesn't have a clip & also it's kind of thin-gripped. not sure if you can buy a handle kit to thicken the scales & add texture, I think I've heard that?
 
I dont know anything about the other knives but if the SWAT was working well for you then you should get another one. "Find something you like and use it often."
 
In your price range, the CRKT Crawford/Kasper FF would be just about what you are looking for.
 
The Greco is an extremely tough folder, and it's my choice for potentially damaging work. However, it is quite different from your original requirements so it may not work for you. I would definately recommend that you look into it, though.

For a low-cost work knife with a nice comfortable grip there are few knives that can compete with the Gerber Gator series. With the exception of the liner lock it has everything else that you mentioned.

I have a friend who works in a manufacturing shop who carries a Gator every day; and he does terrible, terrible things to it regularly. For him it is more of a multitool than a knife, and that includes usage as pliers.

He has managed to chip the edge a bit and scratch the blade pretty bad, but after two years of regular abuse and neglect it is still going strong.
 
Back
Top