I'm all for White's Boots! There are spendy (about $400 a pair now) and can be a real bugger to break in. However, once you get a pair broken in they are the best boots I've ever worn. I've had my current pair for about 8 years now. In that time they've been through three sets of soles and two complete rebuilds. When you go to the White's store in Spokane, WA. they measure your feet, ankles, and calves.......if they don't have a pair on the shelf, then they custom make a pair to fit YOUR feet. Commercially, the Redwings are nice, but only about $100 less than the Whites....and the longest any pair of Redwings has lasted me is about 8 months before the seams and/or the soles started splitting on me. If your just looking for comfort, and not long wear/protection, then I would choose the Redwings. The way I look at it now is that with Redwings your "buying" a pair of boots. With White's your "investing" in a pair of boots.